
UNSOLVED
W
winterbagel
19 Posts
0
186691
January 1st, 2010 21:00
Brightness control disappeared with new LCD
I recently installed a new LCD screen in a Dell Inspiron 1525. The machine had a cracked screen which still displayed and functioned perfectly but the crack was annoying. I got what I was led to believe was a "compatible screen" as it matches the original identically, except for the surrounding bracket which was not difficult to exchange. However now the brightness cannot be controlled and I am stuck with 2 choices more or less - actually less or less to be precise, as the screen is too dim for my taste.
If I start on the "lowest" brightness setting, and press the + Up Arrow key, the brightness will cycle through all 8 steps to the "highest" brightness setting.
The problem is, rather than the screen gradually getting brighter, it follows the pattern from step to step:
Step 1 - dim, Step 2 - slightly brighter, Step 3 - slightly dimmer (same brightness as Step 1), Step 4 - much dimmer, Step 5 - slightly brighter, Step 6 - slightly dimmer, Step 7 - much brighter (this is the brightest setting), Step 8 - Slightly dimmer.
Even at Step 7 (the brightest setting) the screen is only half as bright as it should be.
I tried the backlight from the old LCD screen and got the same results.
The Dell Diagnostic scan shows no issues. I've tried making adjustments with the Intel Graphics Media Accelerator driver control panel with no success. The moblity setting, bios etc all have no effect and are set to max. I've also Googled like crazy on this and found at least 4 other incidents identical to this but no answers had by anyone so far - except for one who replaced the screen and motherboard again but that seems unreasonable in my case since all was well and good before, even with the crack.
Help/insight would be greatly appreciated =)
Responses (29)
Solutions (0)
winterbagel
19 Posts
6077
0
Posted January 2nd, 2010 04:00
Since my original cracked screen functioned perfectly I saw no need to buy a new inverter or backlight, so I only have the original inverter. Unless plugging in the new screen ruined it I see no reason why it should suddenly quit working...
I have contemplated putting the old screen back in though, that would certainly tell me if the inverter has been ruined by the new screen, it's just time consuming and I need to use this laptop most of the day, everyday you know?
winterbagel
19 Posts
6077
0
Posted January 2nd, 2010 17:00
So I broke down and put the cracked screen back in today - and it is working fine again, all controls functioning properly. It would seem there is something specific about being connected to the new screen it does not like. I found the data sheets for both and compared their attributes, the only difference there is that the replacement screen does not have ambient light sensor built into the screen, whereas the cracked one does - other than that they appear identical.
They do have different numbers on their respective pcb boards however, and when I googled said numbers I did find another person with the same issue, who seemed to have solved the problem - however it is in Russian and the google translation was only adequate enough to show the issue was the same and the solution had something to do with the EDID EEPROM.
Anyone here read Russian by any chance? =)
winterbagel
19 Posts
6077
0
Posted January 18th, 2010 21:00
I'm sorry to report shruthi that I worked on this for nearly 2 weeks and never found any solutions. I could not find someone to translate the Russian solution properly which was the only real insight into the problem. I gave up and bought another used lid from a broken 1525.
Inside it was a different screen brand altogether - this time an LG, LP154W01 (TL) (F2). I now have normal brightness control again, but I have lost the superior image quality I had in both Samsung screens. I am not impressed by the LG screen's image quality, it has faded washed out color compared to the deep rich color in the Samsung's, one of which was in use 2 years longer than the LG!
If you should ever solve this yourself, I too would still like to know how =)
Hey,
I've got the same problem :| . A guy at the computer repair store I gave it to first suggested it was either a Voltage regulator problem OR a problem with the new screen I had put in. So he tried putting a new one VR in but it didn't work. Tried it with a couple of other screens too but that didn't work either. Now he says it could be a problem with the video card (dunno how that could have gotten damaged). And since the video card is built into the motherboard I'd have to change that. :| Wish someone could come along who could fix this problem!
winterbagel
19 Posts
6077
0
Posted January 22nd, 2010 13:00
"Voltage regulator" is incorrect, it is a voltage inverter (that little strip below your LCD with a socket on each end) but in either case if it was working properly before your screen was broken then there is no reason to suspect it. If your screen was not physically damaged, ie: cracked - but instead just went black, it could be either your inverter or your backlight - the easiest and least expensive fixes - or your video card/chip, obviously far more expensive. If your screen was not physically damaged it (your LCD) should not have automatically been replaced.
If the replacement screen(s) work, but there is just no proper brightness control as described in this thread - then there is absolutely nothing wrong with your video card or anything else on your system - the guy replaced your screen with one that is not recognized by your system. All screens are NOT created equal, and you can't just throw any "15.4" screen in as a replacement (or whatever screen size you have).
There is obviously a reason screen sellers ask for specific laptop and LCD model numbers before selling screens, laptop manufacturers (Dell, HP etc) likely have a set or list of screen EDID's that are recognised by their specific system setups. In my case the first replacement was manufactured in 2006 and had an EDID, my original screen, although made by the same company (Samsung) was manufactured in 2008 and actually has an EEIDID which I gather contained information my system was looking for and could not find on the older screens chip (LCD's have their own circuit boards and chips on their backs).
There is most likely a single line of code in the EEDID eeprom that we need, but as I lamented earlier - until I learn to read russian there is no way for me to know what exactly needs to be flashed to the EDID eeprom!
I would suggest that you find out what the exact screen brand/model number is on your replacement screen and google it in combination with your laptop model to see if the screen sellers show it as a compatible match. If you bought the screen yourself you will have to re-sell it and buy a compatible one (my situation) but if you bought the screen from the laptop guy then he is resposible for putting in a proper screen - DO NOT let him change your motherboard or anything else on your system, he is obviously not that well informed, and if he is well informed - then he's a crook - sorry to say.
Let us know how you get on :emotion-21:
The problem is with Dell. Laptopscreen1 which does business on Ebay, via phone and online has the solution. They will not give it to you but their screens are guaranteed to work properly with the Fn + brightness controls problem. I just got off the phone with them and ordered a screen for an Inspiron 1501 - promised to work properly (price was good also - about $90.00 with second day shipping).
winterbagel
19 Posts
6077
0
Posted February 15th, 2010 20:00
It doesn't really have anything to do with Dell, except in that their bios is looking for one of the screens on their list of components. The same is likely true for all the Laptop makers - it would be ridiculous to enter the info for all thousands of screens available if your models only use 20 different ones. The eBay outfit doesn't have any "secret" solution, they just make sure to send Dell cutomers one of the required Dell models. The most useful thing for us to have would be a list of the LCD models found in Dell laptops from the various manufactures ie: Samsung, LG, AU Optronics etc.
You know, the same list the screen repair guys guard like virgins lol!
Anyone ever get a fix for this or know how to resolve?
I am also in the same boat. Having contacted a seller for a replacement screen for our cracked one they assured us that the screen would work for our Dell Inspiron 1525. What they returned was a screen that has brightness issues as discussed above and told me the laptop is at fault!
I know it is not, and have proved this but im finding them rather hard to deal with now with regards to a refund. Plus I will still be out of pocket for courier each way... ARGH!

ejn63
11 Legend
•
87469 Posts
•
321256 Points
6077
0
Posted January 2nd, 2010 04:00
Did you change the inverter with the screen?