UNSOLVED

The4Bs

updated

20 years ago

Closed

T

The4Bs

1 Rookie

•

100 Posts

0

19386

September 10th, 2006 03:00

Bad Card or Bad Card Reader?

We've got an Ispiron 6400 with the built-in card reader. We've been transferring pictures from our 1 GB xD card (from our Olympus camera) to the computer. About 10% of the pictures have bad data in them (small black bars in the picture). Some of the pictures we've copied more than once and sometimes they are fine and sometimes they have bad spots. So the camera is fine and the files on the card are fine, it would seem. But they don't always transfer to the computer fine. We've used two different software packages to transfer the files with similar results. So we think we've narrowed it down to the card reader or the card.
 
Is there any way to tell if the card reader is bad or if it's the card that is faulty? It appears that data just gets lost along the way during the transfer. I know I could go buy another xD card and another card reader. But is there any way to find out without spending any cash?
 
Thanks.
  • 1d49f54a95134b2

    2 Intern

    •

    422 Posts

    1199

    0

    Posted September 10th, 2006 10:00

    You should be able to check in the Dell Diagnostics boot.

    If you dont mind spending a little cash,you could try a exeternal card reader.I think it might be the card.
  • Mary G

    6 Operator

    •

    20095 Posts

    1199

    0

    Posted September 10th, 2006 14:00

    You can also leave the card in the camera and connect the camera to the computer via usb or firewire to transfer pictures. I believe you will have better results.
  • 1d49f54a95134b2

    2 Intern

    •

    422 Posts

    1199

    0

    Posted September 10th, 2006 14:00

    I see what your saying.Have you tried a different card? Otherwise you will need to call Dell,i think the card reader is built into the motherboard.

    Nick

    P.S

    Does your username mean The Bee Sharps?
  • The4Bs

    1 Rookie

    •

    100 Posts

    1199

    0

    Posted September 10th, 2006 14:00

    I did some more testing and I think it might be the card reader. If I transfer my files with the camera connected by USB, everything is fine. I tried transferring the files a few times by card reader and then viewed them while on the card via both the card reader and via the camera/USB. With the camera everything is good every time. With the card reader a picture that previously transferred fine, now has bad sections, and vice versa. No consistency. Given that it goes fine one time and not the other, but only with the card reader and not the camera suggests to me it's the card reader. Make sense?

    Any card and card reader experts out there?

    Thanks for the diagnostics tip. I'll have to look into that.

     

     

  • The4Bs

    1 Rookie

    •

    100 Posts

    1199

    0

    Posted September 10th, 2006 15:00

    I was able to find another card reader in a Dell Dimension 9100. It worked fine. Both viewing the files on the card and copying the files.

    So I'm pretty comfortable that it's the card reader that is the problem.

    And if it's built into the mother board - Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh! Not going there. I think you're right because when I looked for a driver update it fell under the chipset section. Thanks nickinspiron6000 for that observation - that makes the chipset thing make sense.

    I was already dreading the thought of calling Dell tech support. Now I'm pretty sure I'm not.

    I'll use the camera as Mary G suggested. Our camera takes two different kinds of cards - xD and CF - so I think I'll try for an external card reader that supports both styles, too, if the speed becomes an issue since it takes twice as long via the camera.

    Many thanks to you all. I wondered what my next step was and I'm pretty sure what to do now. Nothing.

    Oh, and about our username. It was supposed to be The4B's (since there's four of us and all have B in our name) but it wouldn't let me use an apostrophe in the username. At least it let me use capitals so it didn't look really bad.

  • 1d49f54a95134b2

    2 Intern

    •

    422 Posts

    1234

    0

    Posted September 11th, 2006 15:00

    Why are you afraid of calling Dell Support? I would just chat with Dell it is far easier!
  • The4Bs

    1 Rookie

    •

    100 Posts

    1234

    0

    Posted September 11th, 2006 16:00

    I'm leary of calling tech support because it seems the standard answer is "let's reload the operating system." That's being a bit harsh on my part but my experience with tech support has generally not been good. I generally don't find them that helpful. But that's not always the case. We have had occasions where the tech support person was quite helpful (we have 3 Dell computers so we've had some opportunity to deal with them). But overall... calling tech support is not my first choice.

    Regarding live chat, we live in Canada and live chat is only available in the US.

    Edited to add: I've thought of calling them just so the problem is on record and there is a case number. I have an extended warranty and I may want to address it in the future. In the meantime I'll watch and wait to see if there's a driver upgrade that might fix the issue.

     

    Message Edited by The4Bs on 09-11-200612:11 PM

  • zianchoy

    23 Posts

    1234

    0

    Posted October 26th, 2006 18:00

    I have the same problem although I was unluckier because all my photos are messed up.

    I went ahead and contacted Dell support and your premonitions are dead on.

    They asked me to reload the system back to factory state. Of course, I wasn't about to wipe out my only computer so I tested my card on a brand new Dell E1505 at a store. On the store's E1505, the images didn't even appear. The problem is clearly the card reader.

    I think the Ricoh xD card reader can't read type H xD cards. I've asked Dell Support about it so that I can get a more conclusive answer.

    By the way, now I'm supposed to send my laptop to a service center for a more "thorough check."
  • The4Bs

    1 Rookie

    •

    100 Posts

    1234

    0

    Posted October 26th, 2006 20:00

    Thanks zianchoy for your input and comments.
     
    Interesting observation about not reading the type H xD cards. I hadn't thought of that and that's the type of card I'm using too. I wonder if that's fixable with a firmware/chipset update or if it's a hardware issue. I use SD and memory stick cards without trouble in the card reader. Maybe it is what you suggest, the type of xD card we're using.
     
    Luckily for me my camera also uses CF cards. So I've switched to saving pictures to that card and then use an external card reader to transfer them to the computer. It is literally 10 times faster than getting the pictures from the camera directly. If I'm away from the computer for a while I copy from the CF to the xD card within the camera so the xD card becomes a backup only now. If worse comes to worse and I lose the CF card or it becomes corrupted somehow I can transfer them from the xD card in the camera directly and still get the pictures okay, albeit very slowly. Not sure if you've got the option to try another card or not but I thought I'd toss that out there.
     
    If you do get any more insight about the type H xD card compatibility, please let us know.
     
    Cheers.
     
    Editted to fix typo.

    Message Edited by The4Bs on 10-26-2006 04:20 PM

  • zianchoy

    23 Posts

    236

    0

    Posted October 26th, 2006 22:00

    Actually, I wrote "Type H" because earlier, someone else also started a thread on this topic but they did a bunch of research and fingered it as a possible issue.

    According to Olympus, "...because the cards utilize advanced new technology, previously released digital cameras will either require a firmware update or be unable to support the new cards. Detailed information will be posted on the Olympus website prior to the M-XD1GM xD-Picture Card's market introduction." (http://www.xd-picture.com/press/index.html)

    The announcement is from Feb 15, 2005.