UNSOLVED

Funk 49

updated

19 years ago

F4

Funk 49

17 Posts

0

35610

May 23rd, 2008 02:00

Is it better to Leave a PC Running OR Shut it Off ??

 If a PC is not going to be used for (8) hours or more, is it better (for parts/HDD longevity) to just leave it running or Shut if Off ??

 

 

  • mfinnan101

    2 Intern

    •

    1180 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 08:00

    If you're not using it, it's best to shut it off. It'll also lengthen the life of the components such as the hard drive. Generally hard drives fail due to wear and tear resulting in mechanical failure from constantly spinning at revolutions such as 7200rpm all the time.
    Message Edited by mfinnan101 on 05-23-2008 10:02 AM
  • RobinBredin

    6 Operator

    •

    3717 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 13:00

    If you are running Vista, you could put it in the sleep mode. 
  • Ringfinger

    148 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 13:00

    I generally leave my PC running and reboot once a week to clear things out and release regain resources that may be hung up.  i am sure you will find more people that not that leave it running.  That way, your defrag, scans, etc can run in the middile of the night. 
  • x_lab rat

    1976 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 14:00

    Running constantly, a computer burns through about $10 of electricity a month.  Leaving it on gains nothing.  Dust builds up faster.  Windows needs to be shut down.  It's a very poor housekeeper, and over time it clutters itself up to where it won't run anymore.
  • Alexandra_P

    4 Apprentice

    •

    2554 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 16:00

    Another vote for turning it off.  The classic argument is that powering on is more stressful than keeping it running.  If you power cycle it every 5 minutes, well, yeah.  Every 12-24 hours - come on.

     

    Here's a classic article on the subject from 1993 (!).  Even way back then hard drives were rated for about 20,000 power cycles and 25,000 hours of continuous operation - powering off every day was just fine.  Today hard drives are easily 2-3 times more reliable than that.

     

    http://www.umich.edu/~archive/mac/misc/documentation/tooffornottooff.txt

     

    Of course that's hard to believe when you're unlucky enough to have one die on you after 6 months.  I've been extremely lucky and had 2 PC's with drives that lasted 5 and 7 years with daily power-downs.

     

  • Ringfinger

    148 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 16:00

    I set mine to power down hard drives after 1 hour.  So, no stress on the hard drives in my case.
  • x_lab rat

    1976 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 18:00

    Startup stresses are negligible. Power supplies do not 'lurch' on, they startup under a programmed ramp, the designers recognizing that at cold start, capacitors briefly appear to be a dead short. They turn off the same way. So it's not like slamming the doors on your car.

     

    Certain old drives actually landed the heads on the disc surface at shutdown. They also were prone to bearing changes with temperature from long runtimes. Those two reliablility factors cancelled each other out. Starting/stopping it was bad, leaving it running was bad. Those issues have largely been overcome in recent designs.

     

    When you hear/read about people having trouble turning their computer on after it's been off, that is a circumstance specific to that unit, and the root cause is the current generation of marginally-defective capacitors being used in all computers. When that starts happening, you might get another month's use out of it by leaving it on. But as the capacitors continue to deteriorate, the system will still fail outright.

     

    Technically, this should not be happening.  Capacitors in computers are under much less stress than they are in say, a CRT television.  But vendors have cost-reduced the parts to the extent their reliability is heavily compromised. 

    Message Edited by x_lab rat on 05-23-2008 02:41 PM
  • mfinnan101

    2 Intern

    •

    1180 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 18:00


    @drprinter wrote:

    I leave mine on 24/7.  When you turn a cold computer on there is a "electronic shock" to the system.

    after a while this "shock" can blow a component on startup.


    Not true any more. 

    The only thing that would cause a "shock" as you put it on startup is if there is an electrical inductance present. The inductance that is on all integrated circuits inside your typical computer today is completely negligible and is of no concern whatsoever.

     

    The only component that is susceptible to this would be the power supply, however in recent years the parasitic inductances and capcitances has be ironed out. So this shock is no longer present.

  • drprinter

    3 Posts

    783

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 18:00

    I leave mine on 24/7.  When you turn a cold computer on there is a "electronic shock" to the system.

    after a while this "shock" can blow a component on startup. if you leave it on then everything is at optimal

    running temp.

     

    just my opinion 

  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    273

    0

    Posted May 23rd, 2008 19:00

    Funk 49

    The great on/off debate still continues, here are two versions of it here and here of it.

    Turning on the hard drive a few times per day, is considered normal usage and should not pose any problems.

    If a drive is turned on and off excessively on a daily basis, then this could affect its longevity.

    Personally, I shut the system/systems down at night, when I'm away from the home office or when a computer is not being used for any lenght of time. Hate to waste energy!

    Bev.


    ===================================================
    Please don't send me questions about your system by DCF Messenger.
    Post the issue in the appropriate Board, where they will be answered.