UNSOLVED

Todd D.

updated

20 years ago

TD

Todd D.

1 Rookie

•

13 Posts

0

12481

May 1st, 2007 17:00

Got a few video card questions for you guys

Please take a few minutes to answer and discuss these questions.

 

When upgrading your unit’s video card;

(1)   What factors are most important to you?

(2)   What benefits are you hoping to achieve

(3)  What are some potential drawbacks to consider?   

 
Thanks,
Todd


Message Edited by DELL-Todd on 05-01-2007 01:46 PM
  • RJRUNDE

    199 Posts

    750

    0

    Posted May 1st, 2007 22:00

    1.  Important Factors:  Compatibility with system which includes the card safely sitting in it's slot on the motherboard, and voltage compatibility with the supplied power supply.  Sufficient gain in performance over the present video card without bottlenecking because of OEM processor.
    Cooling of the video card is also important. I shoot for a price range of between $150.00 and $225.00 when purchasing upgrades.
     
    2.  Benefits hoping for:  The ability to play newer games with minimal change in hardware. Otherwise a person should invest in a new system, but that is a very expensive option.  Memory upgrade might be needed besides a video card upgrade, but that is permissable.  Take our 8300's for example.  Many owners of 8300's and they are a very good computer for many tasks but newer games.  We can't afford to replace our rock solid PC's everytime a new game comes out, so we try to change what we can. 
     
    3.  Possible drawbacks:  Purchasing a $200 plus card that shows minimal increase in FPS because of CPU bottlenecking.  The ATI X1950 Pro AGP card in an 8300 Dell with 3.0 Ghz or less is my best example as that card is a great card, but is held back from it's full potential and value because of the CPU.  I did not make that mistake, but it is an easy one to make with all of the hype in the gaming community.  Another drawback would be incompatibility because of amps needed on the rails, or the card is too long and interferes with a SATA connection or a hard drive cage. 
     
  • Flytyer06076

    176 Posts

    750

    0

    Posted May 1st, 2007 23:00

    (1) Will it fit? No way to find out if you own a Dell unless someone took the step and purchased one and says it will fit. Dell could include Max length a card can be to fit in a Model.

    (2) Hope for better performance than a card that is offered by Dell.

    (3) Will Dell's Power Supply be enough to run the Card.

    These are things that are being asked by People who own a Dell E521.
  • eluna

    16 Posts

    750

    0

    Posted May 2nd, 2007 04:00

    When upgrading your unit’s video card;

    (1)What factors are most important to you?
    power supply option, e520 stuck around, not even can move.


    (2)What benefits are you hoping to achieve
    fully customize with standard design


    (3)What are some potential drawbacks to consider?
    size and powersupply are major factor cause alot consumer regret buying from dell. if this issus could be solve, well... everyone would happy with it
  • gbickster

    46 Posts

    750

    0

    Posted May 4th, 2007 12:00

    I think RJRUNDE hit it right on the head with his answer to question 3. 
     How do you know what card to by for the cpu you have without wasting your money.
  • 727stretch

    140 Posts

    750

    0

    Posted May 4th, 2007 15:00

    1) Important factors are performance increase, system compatibility (power; will it physically fit?), and price-to-performance ratio
     
    2) The benefits I hope to achieve with an upgraded video card are good to excellent gaming performance with good to excellent visuals.
     
    Side note:  I hope that Dell realizes that there are Dimension customers and potential customers that may want a bit more of a GPU option than the Radeon X1300 Pro, but who may not want to spend the money on an XPS if they don't need/want an aluminum case, better mobo, 10K RPM hd options, etc.  It would be nice if a 8600GTS (even a 8600GT!) or similar was a top-of-the-line option on E520s.  I understand Dell wants to carve a niche for the XPS line, but there are a ton of GPUs in between the X1300 Pro (best offered on Dimension E series) and the 8800GTX (best offered on XPS).
     
    3) Potential drawbacks to consider are added heat/stress on the system, price (if too expensive), installation (for those that have no computer knowledge)
     
     
  • camry8300

    12 Posts

    750

    0

    Posted May 7th, 2007 14:00

    (1) What factors are most important to you?

    Whether the card will fit, the powersupply is strong enough and the possible compatibility (e.g. 7800GS has shown a lot of troubles)

    (2) What benefits are you hoping to achieve

    Better performance on current games, and of course, some sort of future proof.

    (3) What are some potential drawbacks to consider?

    a) Powersupply. The dell powersupply is somewhat well-known to be underrated, but still, putting an x1950pro in a case with 305w powersupply is a gamble.
    b) Ventilation. 8300's original design has a not so stellar ventilation design for a prescott CPU. My case has be heavily modified to make sure the CPU stays cool.

    As for the CPU bottlenecking, it really isn't a big deal with the P4 processors. By looking at all the reviews published on Tomshardware and other various sources, the bottlenecking is only significant when gaming at low resolutions (1024x768). Nowadays most people game at much higher resolution due to the availability of high-res LCDs, for example, I do mine at 1680x1050 (2005fpw) therefore a high end graphics card is almost a must in my case, and x1950pro fits perfectly.

    Another general rule of thumb of testing bottlenecking is to use aquamark3. My cpu (p4 3.0G prescott) scores are only slightly behind my graphics (x1950 agp 512mb) so I don't think bottlenecking is significant at all.