
UNSOLVED
J
JimDudeBob
14 Posts
0
19259
April 4th, 2005 05:00
dimension 8100 graphics card update advice
hi, i have a 8100 and was considering upgrading my gfx card, but i'm not sure how far i should go before my cpu (1.7ghz), and whatever else becomes a bottleneck.
like so many other people on this forum, i'm tempted by the 9800 pros, but worry about the power issues and whether my system will make much use of the improved performance over my current ti4200.
my system consists of:
1.7ghz p4,
768mb rdram,
asonic 7.1 sound card,
avermedia tv tuner,
ebuyer 10/100 lan card,
linksys wireless pci card,
standard dell 56k modem
120gb hdd, 200gb hdd, 300gb hdd (all internal ide)
dvd burner
floppy drive
a few usb devices inc. printer, irda port, phone cable, webcam, and a few others
no extra fans or lights or anything, just the standard 8100 bits.
and currently a geforce ti4200 vivo.
i think i have quite a lot loaded onto there, hence my power worries for the 9800 pro. but if i'm going to get the same performance increase from a cheaper card because of a bottleneck in my system, then i'd happily go for something cheaper and less powerful. but this is where you clever knowledgeable people come in, and i'd much appreciate your advice on which graphics card would give me the best possible performance for my farcry, doom3, halflife2, sof2, heavy gaming lifestyle.
thanks mucho!
like so many other people on this forum, i'm tempted by the 9800 pros, but worry about the power issues and whether my system will make much use of the improved performance over my current ti4200.
my system consists of:
1.7ghz p4,
768mb rdram,
asonic 7.1 sound card,
avermedia tv tuner,
ebuyer 10/100 lan card,
linksys wireless pci card,
standard dell 56k modem
120gb hdd, 200gb hdd, 300gb hdd (all internal ide)
dvd burner
floppy drive
a few usb devices inc. printer, irda port, phone cable, webcam, and a few others
no extra fans or lights or anything, just the standard 8100 bits.
and currently a geforce ti4200 vivo.
i think i have quite a lot loaded onto there, hence my power worries for the 9800 pro. but if i'm going to get the same performance increase from a cheaper card because of a bottleneck in my system, then i'd happily go for something cheaper and less powerful. but this is where you clever knowledgeable people come in, and i'd much appreciate your advice on which graphics card would give me the best possible performance for my farcry, doom3, halflife2, sof2, heavy gaming lifestyle.
thanks mucho!
Responses (13)
Solutions (0)
You really need a 2.6-2.8GHz CPU using the Powerleap adapter. My system (specs below) will play all the old games at max settings. Most of the top new games will run smooth at desk top resos and card/game settings notched down one (some run fine at higher resos and the highest game settings). Doom III taxes the vid card and Half-Life 2 taxes the CPU. Weigh the costs of upgrades vs. saving for a new machine. The games in development now will tax systems even more. If you go the upgrade route, I would recommend the PS made just for the proprietary D8100 wiring here:
http://www.pcpowercooling.com/products/power_supplies/selector/index.htm
The D8100 can still be a good game machine, but the cost of the upgrades and the limitations on the new games may not make it worth it in the long run?? And yes, the new games will run better on the 9800Pro.
Message Edited by dogin on 04-04-2005 08:53 AM
- If your interested in the 9800, maybe you should look at the 6600. I have a EVGA 6800 along with a "Powerleaped" 2.6 GHz CPU in my 8100 and play Half-Life II at some fairly high settings with no problems. I, however, do not have three hard drives installed... I only have two. I agree with dogin that you will probably want to "PowerLeap" your CPU.
JimDudeBob
14 Posts
316
0
Posted April 4th, 2005 13:00
thanks for the replies.
would i be better off going for something like the 9600 instead? that would require less power, but i'm not sure what the performance decrease would be like... would the 1.7ghz be enough of a bottleneck so that the 9600 would make games almost as fast as the 9800? i thought a much faster cpu was needed to make full use of the 9800's power, or am i wrong?
as for the powerleap stuff, i'm in the uk and i'm finding it very difficult to find somewhere that sells the kit, not sure if the american one will ship here. anyone know of anywhere in the uk that sells dell 8100 PSUs and other proprietary bits?
thanks for the help, i'm gonna be keeping the 8100 for another couple years at least so i'm just trying to get the best out of it that i possibly can. would've been nice if i could just stick a standard faster processor or PSU onto it, the proprietary thing is very annoying :)
cheers you guys- Contact Powerleap here: http://powerleap.com/ I am pretty sure they will ship the adapter to you. You really need the CPU upgrade.
JimDudeBob
14 Posts
316
0
Posted April 4th, 2005 15:00
if i can't afford to upgrade the cpu and psu and just wanted a gfx card for the moment, and i was to keep my current system configuration (apart from maybe unplugging a few things to save power if necessary, such as a hard drive, dvd drive which i rarely use, network devices, and usb devices), which graphics card would people recommend? have a budget of around £90 to £120, which basically means the best thing i can afford is a 9800 pro, but not sure if it's worth it for my current system.
help! :) ta- Unless your PSU is going downhill from use (should perform well 3-5yrs of steady use) it should power the 9800pro. If you are going to keep the system and slowly up grade, the 9800 Pro is a good card. You could also do what G1mac suggested so check prices. Not all your components run at once so unless your hard drives are in raid configuration, you should be ok for awhile. If your system crashes during gaming, then I would look to as new PSU soon rather than later. The 9800 Pro really will improve with the faster CPU.
JimDudeBob
14 Posts
316
0
Posted April 4th, 2005 16:00
i've had the computer for 3-4 years and it's been working fine, haven't had any problems. so you think the 9800 will run ok in my computer as it is?
i'm planning on keeping my system as it is, at least for quite a while, so i'm slowly maxing it out in all areas so it will perform optimally without having to spend too much on significantly upgrading it.
so do you think i'll benefit from the 9800 over the 9700 with my current specs? if so then i think i'll definitely give the 9800 a try.
i don't run the hdds in raid, and the majority of stuff sits idle in my computer.
any other advice will be appreciated.
thanks!You may be interested in this article:
http://anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2277&p=3
The 9800 Pro and the 6600GT are about the same price here in the United States, but the performance of the 6600GT is much better. The power requirments for both cards is very similar. If anything the 6600GT runs a little cooler. For the price/performance ratio, I would recommend the 6600GT.
JimDudeBob
14 Posts
157
0
Posted April 4th, 2005 19:00
the 6600gt over here in the uk is about £30 more expensive, but i've looked at reviews and benchmarks and it does look a lot faster. the only thing is all the cards are benchmarked with 3ghz machines with gigs of ram, and i'm not sure if it's worth spending £130 instead of £100 on the 6600 gt instead of the radeon 9800, because i'm not sure how noticeable the difference would be on my own 1.7ghz.what would you recommend? is it worth splashing out on the bit extra - will the performance increase be worth it?thanks, this will probably be my last message :)

Kadaj
26 Posts
316
0
Posted April 4th, 2005 05:00
Message Edited by Kadaj on 04-04-2005 02:51 AM