UNSOLVED

khaehl

updated

20 years ago

K

khaehl

12 Posts

0

18232

April 5th, 2007 02:00

Dim8250 video upgrade X1650 PRO failure

I have a Dell Dimension 8250 3.0GHz with 1GB RAM.  I want to upgrade my OEM video card (ATI Radeon 9700TX).  It has an AGP 4x slot.  I am running A04 BIOS.
 
I bought an HIS ATI X1650 PRO 512MB with the IceQ fan. 
 
My PC meets all the box specs except for the power supply (they recommend 450W), but I have read here and other places that my Dell 250W power supply should work.
 
I completely removed the old ATI drivers, then put in the new card (including attaching the power).  The computer will not boot (not even to the BIOS screen), and gives YGYG on the error lights which signifies a video card failure.  The card's fan is running.  When I replace the old card, everything works.
 
I assume my problem is either...
A)  The new card is bad.
B)  My power supply is insufficient
 
I don't have another PC with an AGP to test the card.  I could buy a new PSU, but I hate to sink more money into a four year old computer (this was to be my last upgrade - I promised!).  Am I correct in assuming that if the power supply was insufficient, the computer would at least try to boot?
 
Any other suggestions before I return the card?
 
Thanks,

Kevin


Message Edited by khaehl on 04-05-2007 06:49 AM
  • delta7000

    2 Intern

    •

    454 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 18:00

    This is a previous reply I posted in another thread. I'm not sure what the problem is but mine is still working without a problem.
     
    I installed the ATI X 1650 Pro in my 8250 about a 4 months ago and have had no problems.  I previously had a ATI 9700PRO. I'm running 2 monitors (2405FPW & 1900FP). I still have the stock 250W PSU. I did up date to the latest catalyst drivers. I'm just wondering if the problem arises with 1650 cards not made by ATI (AMD). I only needed to insert the card and connect 1 wire.
  • khaehl

    12 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 18:00

    I calculated the power requirements for my system with both the OEM card and with the X1650 with...
     
     
    The results:
    Existing System with Radeon 9700 = 272W
    Existing System with Radeon X1650PRO = 276W
     
    This surprised me.  It seems to indicate that the new video card should not draw much more power than the current one.  Can anyone confirm that this makes sense?
     
    Regards,

    Kevin
  • khaehl

    12 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 19:00

    Delta7000,
     
    Thanks, that's interesting.  I would think that your power draw running to monitors would be pretty high, so I'm doubtful it's a lack of power.
     
    I have an HIS ATI X1300 (PCIe x1) in my other computer (Dell E310) and it's running fine, so I was expecting similar results with the 8250.
     
    It looks like I need to return the card, but I wish I knew if I should request another one, or pay the restocking fee and order something different.
  • infocus

    65 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 6th, 2007 14:00

    I just installed a new HIS 1650 pro into my 8300 and attached the floppy power cable to it and it works perfect with my 250 watt power,it plays halflife2 with no problems.
  • khaehl

    12 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 7th, 2007 17:00

    Thanks for the response.  Unfortunately, I could not get this one to do anything in my 8250.  I even disconnected all the other peripherals and extra HDD to give it as much power as I could, but it still wouldn't boot.  I'm going to return it and buy a 7600GT instead.
  • infocus

    65 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 8th, 2007 13:00

    Dell parts told me 250 watts would never work with a 512mb 1650pro card,Ihad to settle with 256mb.only a power upgrade will work.
  • khaehl

    12 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 9th, 2007 10:00

    Hmmm.  That might have been my problem.  The HIS card I bought was 512MB x1650PRO.
  • tigerwolf7

    2 Intern

    •

    3906 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 9th, 2007 12:00

    Get a better card if you can. The x1650 is low end. It actually has only have the ROPs a 9700 has (though probably has a higher clock speed to offset that).
  • khaehl

    12 Posts

    769

    0

    Posted April 9th, 2007 14:00

    I'm currently considering an nVidia GeForce 7600GT AGP.  I understand these cards have a power requirement that is more likely to work with my Dell 8250 stock PSU.
     
    A couple of questions...
     
    It looks like both XFX and Leadtek make a version of the same card that should work.  Any thoughts on the merits of one company over the other?
     
    Also, XFX makes two versions, one at 560MHz, the other at 580 MHz.  Is the extra clock speed worth an additional $10 or so?
     
     
     
     
    Thanks,

    Kevin
  • tigerwolf7

    2 Intern

    •

    3906 Posts

    118

    0

    Posted April 9th, 2007 15:00

    Those are both good brands. It seems like in the past Leadtek has made some cards with quieter designs, but I don't know that that applies to their 7600GT card.

    You probably can't notice any difference between a 20MHz clock speed bump, though there's nothing wrong with going for the faster card.