UNSOLVED

Haukon

updated

5 years ago

H

Haukon

1 Rookie

•

9 Posts

0

1484

July 3rd, 2021 18:00

Area-51m R1, physical and mental exhaustion

Yes, this is yet another "the laptop is overheating" post in a way, but I can't help it due to my prolonged and extensive frustration towards this machine recurring issues.

 

I'm the unlucky owner of an out of warranty Area-51m R1/Nvidia RTX 2080/i7-9700k, etc.

I got the laptop in 2019, and it was nice and all for a while, until (only took several months) it started showing all those wonderful issues that come along with overheating, such as throttling.

Unfortunately, that all happened during the height of the pandemic, so it took me a couple of tries to get Dell to acknowledge the issues the laptop had (I'm sure you're all familiar with how until temperatures reach melting point, it's all good and dandy), and eventually send a technician to replace the heatsink assembly part plus repasting (he was nice enough to repaste it with my own Kryonaut thermal paste). I assumed the issue must've been the horrid Dell paste all dried up, and they replaced the part just in case, so I went on enjoying the laptop once more.

That was October last year. Fast forward to now, it all is happening again.

I thought 'fine, whatever, I'll repaste it and it'll be okay', and so I went on and done it. Gave it a nice deep clean too... shame it did nothing at all. I thought that perhaps I had done a terrible pasting job, we all have bad repaste days (I know I had in the past).

So I reopened it all up, and noticed that there was nothing wrong with my repasting, but I went ahead and RE-repasted it. Almost emptied a can of compressed air to try getting those heatsinks and heat pipes clean. I even used my vacuum cleaner against the heatsinks not to leave anything out.

And no, it did nothing at all. GPU is reaching 75° (would be much higher if the system didn't regulate it), my keyboard is burning to encourage me to type extra fast, the left palm rest is cooking my hand, and hope I never put a finger on the panel on top of the keyboard, where the power button is resting, or I might catch on fire.

I could now replace the thermal pads but honestly, I doubt they'll suddenly bring the temperature down by 20° or more, in fact I feel more like it'd be a waste to use them in this system.

I honestly don't understand how the laptop is sold with this major flaw. My warranty is well over, so if I want Dell to do something about it, and perhaps replace the heatsink assembly again (I guess it just gets wrecked over time?!) I'm gonna have to pay probably dearly for it. And I'm also assuming that since this tends to repeat itself every 7-8 months, I'll have a nice recurring fee to pay every year for it. Just insane.

I swear, if I could go back, I'd stop myself buying it. it's never been so unpleasant to use a pc more than using the Area51m. I'm no stranger to having to maintain your own gaming rig, but that is different than having to care for a dysfunctional machine.

I have read plenty from people with heating issues trying to solve this, so I don't hold much hope, but by all means, if anybody has got the answer to this total mess, I'm gonna double-welcome it

/rantover

  • crimsom

    9 Technologist

    •

    6114 Posts

    1088

    0

    Posted July 4th, 2021 00:00

    Hi @Haukon welcome to this user to user discussion forum. This is not Dell Support. 

    Dell has embraced the Intel Plundervolt vulnerability fix of disabling CPU features and saying CPU temperature of 100ºC (boiling point of water) is suddenly acceptable. There is no report of the Intel Plundervolt vulnerability having been exploited. 

    Advocate factory reset to reinstate the original laptop performance, and not install the Dell updates to fix the intel Plundervolt vulnerability. 

    Please click on Kudos to say thank you for response from user that is not employed by Dell. Please share an update on progress, so that other users derive benefit from your experience. Thank you. 


    [This user does not work for Dell and volunteers their free time. Please remember to say thank you by clicking on my thumb up icon.]

  • Haukon

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    1073

    0

    Posted July 4th, 2021 11:00

    Hey Crimsom,

    Thanks for taking your time to reply. I am aware this isn't Dell support, as I have scoured these forums far and wide when the laptop first started acting up two years ago, trying to diagnose and fix things up.

    I am aware that people have the same issues with this laptop, and more, the whole BIOS controversy, the locking of the alienware command center overclocking feature, and all that jazz. I'm aware of the whole undervolting, tinkering with MSI afterburner and Intel Extreme utility tool to tweak the performance and lower the temperature at the same time, and also the "factory reset", installing specific updates, specific BIOS etc.

    I have already done all those things previously, and while they did help shave off some degrees, it was like adding a couple of tablespoons of cold water in a pot of boiling water, and hope it would now be considerably colder. The issue still remained unfortunately.

    I will admit, it is the first time I read about the whole 'intel plundervolt' thing, and I am not saying it won't help, but in the logs I have taken, the CPU temperature isn't what's going off the roof, the GPU is. CPU core temperature is on average around 65°/66°C, give or take depending on the core, as some might run hotter than others

    Which also doesn't make sense, cause the side of the laptop that runs excruciatingly hot is the side where the CPU is installed, but alas that's another mystery I don't yet grasp about this system.


    Don't get me wrong, it's not that I'm not willing to do another factory reset. But last time it did practically nothing, beside wasting my time. Even if it makes the CPU cooler, I don't see how it can stop the GPU running infernally hot.
    Also the fact that after the repasting/replacing of the heatsink assembly last time, kinda validates the point that this isn't caused by something software side: it's something happening hardware side.

    To me, this felt like little by little, the temperature started creeping up more and more, over the months, and now we're at a point where it's just unacceptable. It feels like a behavior more related to hardware than software.

    /rantover2

  • crimsom

    9 Technologist

    •

    6114 Posts

    1069

    0

    Posted July 4th, 2021 12:00

    Hi @Haukon  thank you for sharing additional information that a factory reset, etc. has already been undertaken. 

    To recap, the Intel i7 9700k (with on-board Intel UHD Graphics 630) CPU core temperature is about 65°/66°C (max safe temp 100°C), and the discrete NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2080 GPU temperature is reaching 75°C (max safe temp 88°C). 

    The Alienware series is designed to deliver performance and the Area-51m R1 is no exception. Both the CPU & GPU temperatures are both running at less than their maximum safe temperatures. 

    Thermal Grizzly Kryonaut Extreme Thermal Paste is probably the best thermal compound. Its thermal conductivity is 14.2 W/mK. The operating temperature of this thermal paste is -250ºC / +350ºC, which makes it the best thermal paste for both Traditional Overclocking and Sub-Zero Overclocking. The thermal paste is greyish in colour and is electrically non-conductive and also non-capacitive. It is also a long-lasting thermal paste and has no curing time. It can be applied to both aluminium and copper heatsinks. 

    Please explain why you think there is a temperature problem more clearly. Which Kryonaut thermal paste was used during your repasting? 

    Please click on Kudos to say thank you for response from user that is not employed by Dell. Please share an update on progress, so that other users derive benefit from your experience. Thank you. 


    [This user does not work for Dell and volunteers their free time. Please remember to say thank you by clicking on my thumb up icon.]

  • mattyb3

    7 Practitioner

    •

    1681 Posts

    •

    8370 Points

    1050

    0

    Posted July 4th, 2021 16:00

    Just so we can rule everything out, can you run the ePSA diagnostic in the Boot Menu to make sure the fans are running properly. I'm sure they are but it doesn't hurt to try.

    EDIT: Also, try having a go at what the guy suggests in this video. I've never had a 51M though so I can't use personal experience.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aavjaAdUzpA

  • Haukon

    1 Rookie

    •

    9 Posts

    1025

    0

    Posted July 5th, 2021 07:00

    @crimsom 

    To answer your questions:

    - Yes, the recap is correct, although I'd like to point out that the 75° C temp doesn't go any higher because the system won't allow it, by sacrificing the performance and allow it to sustain that heat, as you probably know. I could raise the limit, and make it reach over 80°C, but I don't see the point, except for making the laptop be even more uncomfortable to use.

    - As far as I know, there is only one Thermal Grizzly Kryonaut paste, and it's the one and the same I was referring to, and that you described in your post.

    - Why do I "feel" I am having temperature/hermal issues is a question simply answered by: because I already had the same issues before, over a year ago, and Dell acknowledged it after several diagnostics/temperature logs, software side tweaks. The technician came around, and he replaced the heatsink assembly (the part that hosts the fans, heatsinks and heat pipes) along with repasting using my Kryonaut paste. I don't honestly remember if the GPU was replaced too, but I wouldn't say so, considering no changes were necessary software side. The results were pretty drastic: from peaking 82° and over in a few minutes of gaming, the GPU was reaching barely 60° and never going much higher, the whole system was running very cool, so I know how it's technically supposed to run, and how it shouldn't. 

    In fact, I challenge any Dell employees to come over and experience my laptop, type on the scorching hot keyboard, maybe cook an egg on it too, while telling me that this is how the machine was intended to be working, cause I'm pretty sure it isn't. 

    I don't know what is causing this, but given the reasons above, I believe it has something to do with the hardware. Considering I repasted twice, i am assuming it isn't that. I clean the laptop regularly, but as I said this time I was very thorough, hoping that maybe some dust was clogging the heatsinks/pipes somewhere, but whatever I did, it didn't work.

     

    @mattyb3 

    Hey there,

    I have ran the diagnostic, and the fans don't seem to have any issue. 

    Regarding the video, that's part of what I already went through software side, in fact it was one of the things the Dell assistant told me to do the first time around when I contacted them. The system is already running with the tweaks through intel extreme utility and MSI afterburner to lower the temperature down.

  • 1009

    0

    Posted July 6th, 2021 05:00

    Please explain why you think there is a temperature problem more clearly. Which Kryonaut thermal paste was used during your repasting?