UNSOLVED

Guapo

updated

6 years ago

G

Guapo

12 Posts

0

4026

February 10th, 2021 14:00

Aurora R7, 8700/1080, insane heat

My Aurora R7 thermally throttles. I used Intel's Extreme Tuning Utility to adjust the wattage, but I can't move the the volts. The heat is out of control. The motherboard does not allow me to adjust voltage settings or even enable / disable XMP. The Tuning Utility showed some odd wattage settings. The CPU ramps up to 120w for 28 seconds during turbo boost. Then it drops down to 65 watts. When I run Cinebench, I can see 4300 on all cores to start, but then it drops to 3600 at 65 watts. Max volts are 1.3ish. The initial temps jump into the mid 80's during those first 28 seconds and then drops down low 70's at 65w. i can adjust the watts and leave it at 95w, but the temps climb to 91c. CRAZY. I have the AIO liquid cooler for all that it's worth. I've tried different fans too. I have an 8700k on another PC and it never goes above 80w and stays constant at 4300 through Cinebench. It has a similar 120mm AIO cooler as the Aurora R7, but the temps stay around 68-70c. Pretty frustrated with the Alienware. I'm just about ready to ditch the case and mobo and drop everything into something else.

  • Guapo

    12 Posts

    1524

    0

    Posted February 10th, 2021 21:00

    OK - really did some tinkering tonight and discovered Current Limit Throttling and Power Limit Throttling. Seriously, what a major pain. I ruled out PSU limitations. Then I discovered and played around with ThrottleStop. I was able to play around with turbo boost and voltages. I could keep the watts up, but the heat - yikes. My PC with the 8700k doesn't need more than 88w to run at 4300 all day long at 65c. The Alienware with the 8700 needs 105w to hit 4300, but the temps jump to 91c. Could this just be a limitation of the z370 board Alienware uses? Ugh - so frustrated.

  • markburv

    2 Intern

    •

    569 Posts

    1510

    0

    Posted February 11th, 2021 00:00

    @Guapo 

    You have changed the fans on the AIO? Before or after the problem initially started. The OEM fans go up to 5000RPM and AWCC may not manage lower speed fans correctly with the default thermal profiles.

    More info needed, have you changed the GPU?

    I guess if you have been playing around with fans, you have repasted the CPU with good thermal paste?

  • Guapo

    12 Posts

    1493

    0

    Posted February 11th, 2021 07:00

    I tried swapping the original fan and the Corsair ML120 Pro around a couple times.  I did re-paste it too.  I just don't understand why the non-k 8700 would need so much power to turbo boost compared to it's K version sibling.

    Maybe I'm only seeing these issues while running synthetic benchmarks?

  • Tesla1856

    10 Wizard

    •

    18086 Posts

    •

    71947 Points

    1471

    2

    Posted February 11th, 2021 10:00

    I just don't understand why the non-k 8700 would need so much power to turbo boost compared to it's K version sibling.

    ====================

    I've always heard that non-K chips were not quite as good as K-class chips (that is why they were not chosen to be K's).

    I think being able to handle higher-frequencies (and still staying stable) is part of the selection criteria. Seems like better thermals goes hand-in-hand with that.

     

    Dell Rockstar

    Microsoft Windows and Apple iOS Developer (Retired)
    - Like many of you, I can appreciate a good game-engine.
    - I answer questions here, but I'm not a Dell employee.
    - Consider giving posts you like a "thumbs-up"
    - Posting models-numbers and software versions speeds trouble-shooting.
    - Click "Mark as Accepted Answer" on any post that answers your question best.

  • markburv

    2 Intern

    •

    569 Posts

    1470

    2

    Posted February 11th, 2021 10:00

    My R8 Z370 runs a i9-9900k without problem, maybe not comparable, but adds some light to "Is the Z370" chipset limited.

    If you want to rule out the MB/chipset, test the i7-8700k processor in it, I insist however with standard OEM Fans.

    On to CPU specs and assumptions   (just some useless blah blah really, you can skip, question, correct me, bear in mind I am no expert in this electronic technical physics quantum stuff)

    The K version requires 95w for Base Frequency 3.7Ghz, the non K version requires 65w for Base Frequency 3.2Ghz.

    Intel Product comparison

    Iirc, Intel produces chips and then classifies them based on their efficiency, power, whatever, etc. Then they fix the limits somehow on the chip to give it 8700/8700k/whatever product id. Forgive me simplifying, but a K processor is a higher quality result than a non-K processor afaiac, especially obvious within the same serie/production line, 8700 in this case takes out all doubt of being on a different production line.

    So, an 8700 processor is much happier at it's base clock and less tolerant at higher clocks, although it can run up to 4.6Ghz within limits.

  • Guapo

    12 Posts

    1452

    1

    Posted February 11th, 2021 13:00

    If you want to rule out the MB/chipset, test the i7-8700k processor in it...

     

    I thought about doing this very thing last night, but it was after midnight and I couldn't bring myself to do it even though I was on a mission!  The 8700k PC is so dialed in right now that I don't want to mess with it, but I know that it's just a matter of time before curiosity gets the better of me and I'll tear them both apart.

     

    This is off the top of my head, but the cost difference between the two chips when new was around $25 I think.  The K version boosted on single core to 4.7.  The non-K boosts to 4.6.  Both are supposed to boost to 4.3 on all cores.  I'll probably drop the non-K version into the z390 board to see what happens because there aren't as many limitations with a non-Alienware board.

    Guapo_0-1613078728592.png

     

  • Guapo

    12 Posts

    1425

    1

    Posted February 12th, 2021 21:00

    OK - more to share.

    It's Friday night.  My wife is in bed already and there's nothing on TV, so I went to town on my PC's.  Here's a little more background.  I have four gaming PC's for myself and my three boys.  The 8700 / 8700k were recent pick ups to replace a 3770 / 4590 PC.  In any event, I swapped CPU's and tried the 8700 from the Alienware Z370 board in a Gigabyte Z370 board that uses the 8700k.  Still with me?

     

    Here is a pic of the two CPU's in the Gigabyte board.  In case the pic doesn't blow up, this is the result:

    8700 - 3943 r20 score, 65c, 98.10 sustained watts @ 4300 speed.

    8700k - 3408 r20 score, 63c, 81.37 watts @ 4300 speed.

    Single core boost had the advertised 100mhz difference.

    The bottom line - the 8700 trounced the 8700k all over the place.  It had just slightly more heat and drew a couple more watts, but that was it.

    Guapo_0-1613193927522.png

    Then I reinstalled the 8700 back into the Alienware. 

    Guapo_1-1613194277313.png

    Seriously, what a massive let down.  The first pic is during the test and you can see the CPU boosting to 106.40 watts and then hitting the power throttle limit and dropping down to 65watts and only 3690 speed.  The temps went from 75c to 59c once the power dropped.  The r20 score went from 3943 down to 2892.  That's over 1000 points!  What is going on with the Alienware?!  Talk about crippling the CPU with a terrible motherboard and cooling.  I'm using the AIO Alienware water cooler, but it's terrible.  Maybe there is something wrong with it... I have a Noctua D15 laying around, but can't use it in the Alienware because of the tight space.  Maybe I could swap out the H60 AIO on the 8700k rig into the Alienware and use the D15 on the 8700k.


    I'm kind of rambling a bit here.  Ultimately I think I'll probably have to swap the motherboard and case because Dell still insists on using proprietary connections on their mobo's.

     

  • markburv

    2 Intern

    •

    569 Posts

    1404

    1

    Posted February 13th, 2021 04:00

    @Guapo 

    That was a lot of work, quite sad to see the results because if it was the other way, a new CPU is easier to drop in. Swapping out the Motherboard will be quite a bit of work.

    Swapping in the H60 may include a little afterwork to get a tangible result as AWCC will need tuning. But this would certainly rule out the AW Liquid Cooling assembly if the AW still has the same problems. If you do that, the final test would be the 8700k in the AW.

    It may seem a lot to do, the alternative would be to rebuild on a new motherboard, you will need a new PSU (8pin power for CPU instead of 4pin), you will need to rewire the power button and the leds as the propriety connector will not be present if you stay in the same case. You may not end up with the result you hoped.

    Once you start the route of a new motherboard, you may end up moving to a new case, you may have fun with the AW cooler. If you go that far, all that you will end up transferring to a new case will be CPU/RAM/GPU/DD

    Example, new case (100-200$) + Z370/90 MB (150-300$) + 850W PSU (150$)  + Corsair cooler (100-180$) gives you a price range from 500-830$ depending on you choices and availability. Weigh up your choices on the value of your three potentially most expensive parts, CPU/GPU/RAM/DD.

    Cost me 700€ to transfer the same worth around 2000€ from my R8 to my H500 ARGB.

    Alive and all systems goAlive and all systems go

    An R7 is not that old. It does, as do all Aurora nano cases, suffer from lack of cool air above the GPU.

    If it is a faulty motherboard, the cheapest route is to get a replacement, albeit with more money you can choose the route you want to take.

    I would advise to keep testing to isolate the proble, it is not normal a CPU is throttled by a properly functioning AW Motherboard, it seems obviously related to CPU temps not being cooled, thus throttling the CPU.

  • markburv

    2 Intern

    •

    569 Posts

    1384

    0

    Posted February 13th, 2021 10:00

    A much less expensive test is add an upper front fan in the HDD cage to pull in cool air to the upper half of the case. NF-A12x25 PWM. I had 100° on my CPU and pulled it down to 82° in Timespy tests during my adventures on my R8.

    With a lot of other tinkering I got it to 75°. At that point CPU-Z Stress Test resulted around the 66° mark as the inside case temperatures were moreso around the 35-40° instead of 60° after GPU tests.

    Comparing CPU-Z to now, I get around the 60°.

    I did a Cinebench test, each pass progressed from 61° max to 67° max.

    So I believe you could get a similar result with adding an upper front fan.

  • DrkHwk

    1 Rookie

    •

    71 Posts

    1429

    0

    Posted February 13th, 2021 20:00

    I wish I had some constructive input for you. After I received my R11 my wife literally stole my R7 from me. I blinked and it was gone and she had it hooked up in her setup    She has been playing tombraider almost all evening and based on this post I asked what her temps were. Her temps while playing were comparable to the temps of my R11 @ idle. High 30's C cpu and low 50's C gpu with a 1070.