Does Dell Universal Dock D6000 supports 2 2K monitors at 144Hz refresh rate?
Hi,
I am after a docking station which would allow my XPS13 7390 2in1 to power a dual monitor setup where each monitor is running 2K (2560x1440 or also known as QHD) at 144hz refresh rate.
One of the candidates is the Dell Universal Dock - D6000. However, the sales team cannot confirm and the manual doesn't clarify if the docking station is capable to do it (it only has the refresh rate matrix for 4K resolution) and also it is missing the info on what DisplayPorts and HDMI generations it is fitted with. Does anyone have any idea about the video port generations?
Ideally, it should be able to run the 2x2K at 144hz because running 4K at 60hz is about twice as much as running 2K at 144hz, but then still how about the power of the machine?
My Dell XPS 13 7390 2in1 specs are:
Processor: i7-1065g7
Video card: Intel(R) Iris(R) Plus Graphics
Memory: 32GB 3733MHz LPDDR4x Memory Onboard
Can someone help me to conclude that if the docking station would be able to run the monitor setup mentioned above with my XPS13?
@CsabaGB You almost certainly don't want the D6000 if you have an XPS 13 7390 2-in-1. The D6000 uses "indirect display" technology called DisplayLink not to be confused with DisplayPort. And DisplayLink has a bunch of drawbacks that can be significant in certain use cases. I wrote about those in the post marked as the answer in this thread.
The better dock to consider would be the WD19TB. I don't know if it will run dual QHD at the full 144 Hz, since I'm not even sure the Intel GPU in that system supports 144 Hz at ANY refresh rate, but it definitely has enough bandwidth to run dual QHD 120 Hz, and I know Intel GPUs support at least that refresh rate.
Side note: It's good that you clarified the resolution you're talking about, but 2K is technically a film resolution of 2048x1080, and when used in the consumer space it correctly refers to the nearest and slightly lower resolution of 1920x1080 -- just like 4K is a film resolution of 4096x2160 but in the consumer space refers to 3840x2160. But since so many people have started to use 2K to refer to QHD/1440p, the end result is that the term has become completely useless because it's never certain what resolution anybody is talking about when they say it. QHD and 1440p are both unambiguous, and QHD is only one more character to type than 2K.
Thank you! We have received the required details. We will work towards a resolution. In the meantime, you may also receive assistance or suggestions from the community members.
@CsabaGB The WD19TB's DP outputs support DP 1.4 and the HDMI output supports at least 2.0, not sure about 2.0b. That's mentioned all over the Display Resolution Table in the WD19TB User Guide. As for clarity on refresh rates, I wouldn't expect that from a dock user guide. A dock is predominantly a business product, so you won't find things like high refresh rates, ultrawide resolutions, and HDR mentioned. The tables are already a bit complex as they are, IMO. But it's not even quite that simple anyway. You have to consider the DisplayPort revision of the traffic coming from the system to the dock and how those interfaces work. For example, a TB3 system that only supported DP 1.2 would send two full DP 1.2 interfaces to the dock (8 lanes of HBR2). But that wouldn't allow the dock to run a 4K 120 Hz display though the dock and display might support DP 1.4. The reason is that the dock won't aggregate multiple DP 1.2 source interfaces into a single DP 1.4 interface -- and the Intel GPU in that system doesn't support using multiple interfaces to drive a single display.
But when connected to a TB3 system that supports DP 1.4, there are 1.25 interfaces of bandwidth available (5 HBR3 lanes). One of those lanes is assigned to the downstream TB3 port, but that's only enough for QHD 60 Hz. The other 4 lanes are split across the remaining outputs. I just don't know if a DP 1.4 interface (4 lanes) is enough for dual QHD 144 Hz displays. The math suggests it would be quite close. Dell's WD19TB User Guide says QHD 60 Hz requires 5.6 Gbps, so if that scales up linearly, QHD 144 Hz would require 13.44 Gbps. Two of those would be 26.88 Gbps. But 4 lanes of HBR3 gets you 26 Gbps usable. If you could use all 5 lanes, you'd certainly have enough bandwidth, but again the dock isn't infinitely flexible in terms of how it allocates lanes, and even if it were, that setup would essentially involve one source GPU interface driving one QHD 144 Hz display and part of a second one, with the remaining partial interface driving the rest of that second display. The Intel GPU wouldn't support that, and I'm not sure any GPU would. NVIDIA and AMD GPUs support using multiple source interfaces to drive one display, but I don't know if they can do that while also splitting up one of those interfaces to drive a second display as well.
In terms of Intel GPU capabilities, those aren't as simple as they look either. Yes, dual QHD 144 Hz requires slightly more bandwidth than 5120x3200 at 60 Hz, but only about 8% more. And it's not necessarily the case that 5120x3200 60 Hz uses 100% of available bandwidth. It's possible that Intel simply doesn't mention that 5120x3200 65 Hz would be possible from a bandwidth standpoint since nobody uses that. But bandwidth isn't even the only concern. For example, that Intel GPU is limited to 3 total displays. That is true regardless of resolution, bandwidth, how they're connected, etc. There might be a similar hard limit on refresh rate, also regardless of resolution. I just don't know since I haven't seen confirmation one way or the other as to whether 144 Hz on an Intel GPU is possible. But dual QHD 120 Hz should certainly be possible if that would be enough for you. (Is it really possible to tell the difference between 120 Hz and 144 Hz? I haven't spent much time with such displays.)
As for an eGPU, that would certainly open up quite a few more options, but it would also be an expensive solution, especially if you don't even need the additional performance of the eGPU. If you can get dual QHD 120 Hz through the WD19TB without an eGPU, then getting an eGPU just to get to 144 Hz seems like a waste to me. But of course value is subjective.
@jphughan I think you are right. Dell support kindly fished out the specs from intel. I think it supports only 120Hz for QHD by looking at the supported 60hz refresh rate for 5120 x 3200 resolution (5k).
@jphughan Thanks for your reply. Yes, picked up on the bad habit of using the term 2k. Yes, in this case, I meant QHD or as some marketers refer to it WQHD resolution.
WD19TB got the two Display Port, however, the documentation is not clear on what refresh rate it supports for QHD setups or what generation of Display Port and HDMI it is fitted with. Any idea?
So you kind of confirmed, what I suspected about the Intel GPU. Do you think by purchasing an external GPU would be a better option to achieve the setup?
@jphughan and @DELL-Cares very much thanks for your help with this. I will keep the discussion open and provide an update as a solution after I tested the setup. My monitors can run on 144hz so after putting the WD19TB between my machine and them, I run some tests and share here. So we can confirm the actual performance possible.
jphughan
11 Legend
•
13985 Posts
•
79931 Points
12233
2
Posted February 2nd, 2021 16:00
@CsabaGB You almost certainly don't want the D6000 if you have an XPS 13 7390 2-in-1. The D6000 uses "indirect display" technology called DisplayLink not to be confused with DisplayPort. And DisplayLink has a bunch of drawbacks that can be significant in certain use cases. I wrote about those in the post marked as the answer in this thread.
The better dock to consider would be the WD19TB. I don't know if it will run dual QHD at the full 144 Hz, since I'm not even sure the Intel GPU in that system supports 144 Hz at ANY refresh rate, but it definitely has enough bandwidth to run dual QHD 120 Hz, and I know Intel GPUs support at least that refresh rate.
Side note: It's good that you clarified the resolution you're talking about, but 2K is technically a film resolution of 2048x1080, and when used in the consumer space it correctly refers to the nearest and slightly lower resolution of 1920x1080 -- just like 4K is a film resolution of 4096x2160 but in the consumer space refers to 3840x2160. But since so many people have started to use 2K to refer to QHD/1440p, the end result is that the term has become completely useless because it's never certain what resolution anybody is talking about when they say it. QHD and 1440p are both unambiguous, and QHD is only one more character to type than 2K.