UNSOLVED

Brendan Kelly

updated

20 years ago

0

21031

November 11th, 2006 23:00

How could both hard drives fail simultaneously? Please help!

I have a Dell Dimension 8300.  It came with a 80 gig Western Digital HD (IDE).  A couple of years ago, I installed a second HD, a 120 gig Seagate (IDE).  I never had any problems until today.  When I turned on the PC, I got a message that read "Primary Drive 0 not found. Primary Drive 1 not found. Strike the F1 key to continue, F2 to run the setup utility."  When I pressed F1, I got the same message.  I checked the BIOS setting, and it showed the "unknown device" for both the Primary Master Drive and Primary Slave Drive.  I also noticed a faint clicking sound, so I concluded that my HD must have been fried.  I took it out and made my second HD (Seagate) the primary (moving the jumper to master) figuring there was no way they both were fried.  No luck.  Same message.  How in the world can both HDs fail at the exact same time?  Could there be something I'm missing here?  In addition to not wanting to go out and buy new HDs for an aging machine, I have photos, music, etc. that I was backing up fairly regularly on the second HD.  Now it looks like I've lost both.
 
BTW - I've checked all of the connections and they appear to be okay. 
 
Could it be the battery on the motherboard? 
 
The only other thing I thought of was a lightning strike as we did have a ugly storm last night in Chicago.  However, the PC was plugged in a surge protector and nothing seemed to be affected and no fuses were blown. Besides, why would it fry both HDs and nothing else?
 
Any thoughts? 
 
Thanks in advance!
 
   
  • rickmktg

    2 Intern

    •

    11898 Posts

    761

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 00:00



    Brendan Kelly wrote:
    I have a Dell Dimension 8300.  It came with a 80 gig Western Digital HD (IDE).  A couple of years ago, I installed a second HD, a 120 gig Seagate (IDE).  I never had any problems until today.  When I turned on the PC, I got a message that read "Primary Drive 0 not found. Primary Drive 1 not found. Strike the F1 key to continue, F2 to run the setup utility."  When I pressed F1, I got the same message.  I checked the BIOS setting, and it showed the "unknown device" for both the Primary Master Drive and Primary Slave Drive.  I also noticed a faint clicking sound, so I concluded that my HD must have been fried.  I took it out and made my second HD (Seagate) the primary (moving the jumper to master) figuring there was no way they both were fried.  No luck.  Same message. 
     
    How in the world can both HDs fail at the exact same time?  Could there be something I'm missing here?  In addition to not wanting to go out and buy new HDs for an aging machine, I have photos, music, etc. that I was backing up fairly regularly on the second HD.  Now it looks like I've lost both.
     
    BTW - I've checked all of the connections and they appear to be okay. 
     
    Could it be the battery on the motherboard? 
     
    The only other thing I thought of was a lightning strike as we did have a ugly storm last night in Chicago.  However, the PC was plugged in a surge protector and nothing seemed to be affected and no fuses were blown. Besides, why would it fry both HDs and nothing else?
     
    Any thoughts? 
     
    Thanks in advance!
     
    Put the jumper back on Cable Select like it was... 
     
    It may be that the SECONDARY drive failed, in which case if you hook the primary back up it may work fine.  Some systems lock up when either drive fails, happened to my 400sc that way when the secondary failed.
  • Karts4Kids

    99 Posts

    761

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 05:00

    Have you tried to access the harddrives via your os disk by choosing to run a repair?  Does it frreeze when attempting to load dos or do you see the drive and its files?  Do you still have your utility partion installed and if so does F12 work?  Have you tried to take one of the harddrives with its cables to another system to try eliminate the controller on the board?
  • maddy78

    132 Posts

    761

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 05:00

    Hi Brendan,
     
    It generally does not happen that both the drives fail. Just to be on safe side, try plugging the IDE cable of hard drive to the CD drive slot on the system board.
     
    I am sure you are resetting the defaults everytime you swap any cable or reseat the connections.
     
    Keep updating.
     
    Cheers,
    Maddy.
  • Karts4Kids

    99 Posts

    761

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 12:00

    All these changes occur within the F2 setup menu.  The simplest way to is to just press the Ctrl and F key simultaneously and that will reset your BIOS to the factory defaults (Cable Select set to Auto).  Press the esc key twice and then Choose save and exit.  See if it will reboot.  If not go back into System Setup (F2) and move down to Boot Device Sequence.  Once into this panel move your cdrom device all the way to the top.  Have your windows xp cd in and press the esc key twice.  Choose Save changes and exit.  After the failed reboot you should now be able to boot to your windows cd.  When your windows reinstallation screen bgins you will be given a choice of either a clean install or a repai.  Press the letter R and then choose your XP operating system and then let us know what happens.  If your MSDOS (that black screen with white letters) appears then we atleast know your system sees the hard drive.  Perhaps a chkdsk /r may help to repair some of your damaged clusters?
  • 761

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 12:00

    Thanks for the responses.  Unfortunately, I'm not very 'technically inclined' so I have a few follow-up questions.  How do I run a disk repair?  F12?  It seems like my system isn't seeing the HD installed.  How do I select "Cable Select"?  Lastly, the only thing I seem to be able to access at this point is the BIOS (when I hit F2).  I'm pretty sure I have everything set up correctly there.  Is there something else I have to do to set-up the drive? 
     
    Thanks in advance.
     
     
  • rickmktg

    2 Intern

    •

    11898 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 13:00



    Brendan Kelly wrote:
    Thanks for the responses.  Unfortunately, I'm not very 'technically inclined' so I have a few follow-up questions.  How do I run a disk repair?  F12?  It seems like my system isn't seeing the HD installed.  How do I select "Cable Select"?  Lastly, the only thing I seem to be able to access at this point is the BIOS (when I hit F2).  I'm pretty sure I have everything set up correctly there.  Is there something else I have to do to set-up the drive? 
     
    Thanks in advance.
     
    Perhaps I'm a little confused.  You stated that you changed the jumper to Master.  Right?  And you don't know how to change it to Cable Select?  Read the diagram on the drive and move the jumper.
     
    Running a disk repair is a waste of time at this point.  Did you read my response to your initial post?  Have you tried just the primary drive on the end of the cable without the secondary drive attached?  If that doesn't work, have you tried the secondary drive on the end of the cable without the primary attached?
     
    Next step would be to run diagnostics, F12, on each drive.
     
    Of course you can't boot to the secondary drive without Windows installed, but you need to figure out if either or both drives have failed first. 
  • Karts4Kids

    99 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 15:00

    Since your "former" configuration worked for x period of time then nothing on your drives should of changed.  If your System Setup is showing Auto for your drives then it is set properly.  Its quite possible, especially since this is a master/slave config, that either the cable is bad or the controller is bad.  Does you BIOS recognize the cdrom?  If it does then try and reverse the cables off the board.  Trace the cable from your cdrom device down to the board and unseat that cable.  Then trace your hard drive cable to the board and unseat that cable.  Then just reseat your 40 pin cdrom cable where the hard drive was once seated and then reseat the 40 pin hard drive cable where the cd rom was once seated.  Power up your system and go into your system BIOS.  Does it now see your hard drive(s) and not your cdrom drive?  If this is the case then the controller is bad.  If it now sees the cdrom on your ide0 controller and still doesnt see the drives then its quite possible the cable itself is bad.  Switch the IDE cable with a known good IDE cable and see if that works.
  • 763

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 15:00

    I moved the jumper on my second HD (Seagate) to the same place it was on the Western Digital.  I did this assuming this would change it from "slave" to "master".  This seemed logical. I have no idea where I would move the jumper to make it "cable select" and since I don't have a "diagram of the drive" handy, I thought I'd pose the question here.  As I mentioned,  I'm not very technically inclined so while I appreciate your advice, please be patient. 
     
    Also, I read your initial advice.  As I mentioned in my post, I've tried removing and installing each drive alone so I'm assuming this means that I have attached the primary without the secondary and the secondary without the primary. 
     
    Thanks.
  • rickmktg

    2 Intern

    •

    11898 Posts

    763

    0

    Posted November 12th, 2006 15:00



    Brendan Kelly wrote:
    I moved the jumper on my second HD (Seagate) to the same place it was on the Western Digital.  I did this assuming this would change it from "slave" to "master".  This seemed logical. I have no idea where I would move the jumper to make it "cable select" and since I don't have a "diagram of the drive" handy, I thought I'd pose the question here.  As I mentioned,  I'm not very technically inclined so while I appreciate your advice, please be patient. 
     
    Also, I read your initial advice.  As I mentioned in my post, I've tried removing and installing each drive alone so I'm assuming this means that I have attached the primary without the secondary and the secondary without the primary. 
     
    Thanks.
     
    Moving jumpers on one brand of drive to match a different brand, or even a different model, doesn't work.  Each drive has a diagram on a sticker showing proper placement.  LIkely the Seagate was properly jumpered, you changed that.
     
    When you installed the drives by themselves, they MUST be jumpered as Cable Select and they MUST be on the end of the data cable.
  • 497

    0

    Posted November 13th, 2006 01:00

    Update:
     
    - I confirmed that the jumper was the proper "Cable Select" position. No luck.
     
    - I moved the Seagate HD between the primary and secondary slots.  I also flipped flopped the IDE plugs.  No luck.
     
    - I flipped flopped the IDE cables for the CD-ROM and the HD.  BIOS recognized the CD-ROM (now listed as Primary), but didn't seem to recognize the HD.
     
    - I used the IDE cables from the CD-ROM drive, which I know worked, and used them for the HD.  Nothing. 
     
    - I tried different power plugs (not sure what they're called - black/red wires).  No luck.
     
    During all of this I reset the BIOS and ran IDE Drive Diagnostics and I always got the message that the drive wasn't found.
     
    At this point, I just want to establish whether the drives are dead, or, if there's something else going on.  I have access to a lot of PCs at my office.  Would popping one open, pulling the HD out and replacing with the two drives from my 8300 help? 
     
    Have I missed any tests?
     
    Thanks again for your help.