UNSOLVED

subscriptio

updated

21 years ago

S

subscriptio

10 Posts

0

15334

May 5th, 2006 19:00

Hard drives hot in Dimension E510 case; cooling options?

I installed a second drive in my new Dimension E510 case and after 10 minutes got a SMART alarm from the hard drive monitoring utility I use. The second drive had heated to 48 degrees C. I swapped position of the first and second drives and was able to bring drive temps to 46 degrees.

This is hotter than I would like to run them. I had to bump up the warning threshold in my monitoring utility, which doesn't seem right.

Dell engineers: The case design seems flawed when it comes to hard drive cooling. There isn't much air blowing over the drives, and I can't see any way to retrofit a fan into this cramped drive area. Also, the plastic mounting clips act like insulators, instead of helping to conduct heat away into the frame.

Does anyone have any solutions to this problem? I can't use the 5.25" cooling rigs from Coolermaster, etc. because I have both 5.25" bays filled with DVD drives.
  • iamarmand

    28 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 7th, 2006 11:00

    I was hoping someone with some knowledge would reply to this. I was interested in an extra cooling option also.
     
    Armand
  • jsohio

    8 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 8th, 2006 23:00

    Have had my E510 for a week. Ordered with a 250G drive (seagate) and decided to add a second 320G (Western Digital). I also have HD monitoring software that checks the SMART temps. And, like you, the main drive is 48C and the secondary is 46C. Maybe it is inherrent in the E510 design to run this hot, but I really am not used to such temps. My other computers are sure noisier, .... but cooler!!
  • subscriptio

    10 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 9th, 2006 00:00

    Now that's validation! The exact same situation on two boxes. :) Sure sounds like this behavior is "by design," which seems pretty laughable and unfortunate, considering the way they promote it.

    Check this out:
    "Keeps Its Cool/The innovative XPS 400 design [same as E510 case] features a front-side air vent that helps keep system components cool, even when running intensive multimedia applications

    Well I guess hard drives are not "system components." I wonder if the Dell case engineers read these forums? Are there Dell case engineers? Or is it just some guy in an office in Austin who purchases cases from Taiwan?

    Perhaps the Dell folks will learn some new things about cooling now that Dell has purchased AlienWare. (Let's hope the knowledge transfer doesn't go in the opposite direction!)

    Message Edited by subscriptio on 05-08-200609:21 PM

  • 634

    0

    Posted May 10th, 2006 05:00

    I'm using a Dimension E310, which has a similar case.

    Right now my two Seagate drives are running at 42C  and  51C

    The one on top, my second drive, is the hotter one - probably absorbing heat from the lower drive, I would imagine. They're very close to each other. Needless to say, I'm also concerned about cooling options.

    I'll try switching their locations, as mentioned above, and see if that helps any. (I tried this and now the drives are running at 44C  and  46C)

    I ran Seagate diagnostics on both drives, and the hotter one has bad sectors on it already. It's not even a month old. I wonder if it's because of the heat?

    Message Edited by Snidely Whiplash on 05-11-200601:25 AM

    Message Edited by Snidely Whiplash on 05-11-200601:26 AM

  • jsohio

    8 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2006 16:00

    Decided to try a little 'cheap' test by installing a BestBuy 80mm case fan controlled by a RadioShack SPST toggle switch (altogether under $15). When running an intense defrag on both drives the temps got up 118F and 125F. Turning on the fan switch (mounted on the back beside the fan) dropped the temps to 111F and 110F.

    Agreeably, the E510 is quiet. But if you're doing HD intensive app's like video editing and rendering, you also want a cool PC. This little fan/switch worked nicely and didn't add too much noise. Now, I'll run the PC with the additional fan off unless I decide to do some HD intensive apps that need the extra cooling.

    BTW -- To the Dell case engineers... I'll let you can incorporate this into your next designs for free. A better idea would have been to have a better cage design on the HD's. As it is, there is very little access for air circulation with the cage effectively enclosed and using plastic mounting trays (insulators... not conductors of heat). (Just one engineer to another -- you can use this idea freely also!!)
  • iFanboy

    25 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 14th, 2006 21:00

    I was going crazy with this, and I still monitor the temps a little obsessively, but I added a Seagate 300 GB (7800.8 I think) drive in the second slot, and it regularly runs in the low 50's. I think 54 is the highest I've seen it. However, the Seagate site says it's safe if it's under 60. So, according to that, I have nothing to worry about. I still backed up most of the important data from the drive to an external drive, just in case. The main drive (80 gb) it came with gets hot as well, hotter than before I added the second drive, but it seems within reasonable limits, and I don't want to switch positions so it's in the lower slot, in case it runs hotter than it already does.

    I guess I'm just reinforcing what you've already said. It runs hot, but doesn't seem to cause a real problem. Speeds are fine. The SMART tests confirm that the drives are in good shape, so I just keep an eye on it, and backup when I need to.

    It is annoying though.
  • iamarmand

    28 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2006 12:00

    Great info thank you. Just curious does the motherboard board come with a power slot for for the fan or do you have to ginny rig the toggle switch.
     
    Thank you
     
    Armand
  • jsohio

    8 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2006 20:00

    Just used a Y-splitter cable off one of the CD-drives to the fan and put the switch on the black lead. Would be nice to have a fan controller on the board -- but that would be asking too much.!!
  • subscriptio

    10 Posts

    538

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2006 20:00

    I am also wondering where you put the fan. I couldn't find any place to add one except perhaps to tape it onto the front cover. Were you able to put it behind the grille? Did you need to pry open some sheet metal to do that?
  • iFanboy

    25 Posts

    634

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2006 20:00

    Where did you put the fan?