UNSOLVED

antohos

updated

6 years ago

A

antohos

2 Posts

0

2320

January 19th, 2021 20:00

Precision 5750: The selection - Intel Xeon W-10855M vPro, NVIDIA Quadro RTX 3000 6GB is incompatible

Hi Everyone,

When using dell configurator, I'm receiving an error message stating "The selection - Intel Xeon W-10855M vPro, NVIDIA Quadro RTX 3000 6GB is incompatible"

Essentially this happens when I change the processor from the "standard" Intel Xeon W-10855M (6 Core, 12MB Cache, 2.80 GHz to 5.10 GHz, 45W, vPro) to Intel Xeon W-10885M (8 Core, 16MB Cache, 2.40 GHz to 5.30 GHz, 45W, vPro)

Here is the configuration link:

https://www.dell.com/en-nz/work/shop/workstations/precision-5750-mobile-workstation/spd/precision-17-5750-laptop/on5750wm03nzvi?configurationid=1f745773-b8a8-436c-a90b-aea557a4addc

 

Is this true that I cannot buy 5750 with an 8-core Xeon processor?

 

Appreciate any help and considerations

  • 1650

    1

    Posted January 20th, 2021 06:00

    Hey! I just opened your link and here is what I saw first:

     

    nz0.png

     

    When I pressed the button 'Continue with New Zealand' and selected the processor Intel Xeon W-10885M (8 Core, 16MB Cache, 2.40 GHz to 5.30 GHz, 45W, vPro) I saw the following (I guess that you are seeing the same):

     

    nz1.png

     

    In the first window, when I selected United States and configured Precision 5750 based on your specification, I saw this (note that I didn't modify the default settings of warranty and software):

     

    us.png

     

    So, it seems that at the moment you cannot buy your desired configuration in New Zealand... By the way, my Precision 7750 is configured namely with Xeon W-10885M and Quadro RTX 3000 and it works great (except the coil whine noise...).

  • antohos

    2 Posts

    1620

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2021 19:00

    Hey, thanks a ton! I did contact dell support yesterday and they didn't give me a definitive answer. Smth like it was not likely tested with 8-core and this model of NVIDIA and hence probably won't be supported. But the US website clearly states that it's possible.

    But I got now really concerned about the noise. It seems to be still quite a problem for latest XPS and precision models.

    Is your whining coming from the charge or the laptop itself? Would it be difficult for you to record it?

    And another serious concern I've got if it's ok to use the laptop on the knees. E.g. will the cooler be unhappy or is the laptop getting too hot?

    I'm a data analyst, so it's mostly programming/data processing and remote desktop rendering workload. 

    Cheers

  • 1575

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2021 16:00

    > Is your whining coming from the charge or the laptop itself?

    In my case, the whining comes from the laptop itself. It doesn't matter if the AC adapter is plugged in or isn't plugged in. I can hear the coil whine noise in both cases.

     

    > Would it be difficult for you to record it?

    Try to listen from the 9th second:

    https://sndup.net/66fj/precision7750-coilwhine.mp3

    Also, please, look at this discussion:

    https://www.dell.com/community/Precision-Mobile-Workstations/Precision-7550-electric-noise/m-p/7783545#M5215

    There you can find more records made by others.

     

    > And another serious concern I've got if it's ok to use the laptop on the knees. E.g. will the cooler be unhappy or is the laptop getting too hot?

    Actually, I cannot say if it is OK to use the laptop on the knees, but I am pretty happy with the cooling system of my Precision 7750 so far. The fans are turned off all the time. They start their job if the temperature of CPU increases up to around 55 C. In my case, this happens only if I turn on the integrated video cam. If I browse the Internet, watch youtube videos, and work (I am a software developer right now), the fans don't work. On idle, the temperature of CPU is around 33 C (one time I even saw 31 C). For example, at this moment, I have the following temperatures (find the line "coretemp-isa-0000"):

     

    sensors.png

     

    However, I have to note that my dedicated GPU is turned off all the time. If I turn it on, the temperature of CPU increases about at least 10 C and fans may start their work even watching youtube. Also, note that I am talking about Precision 7750. The cooling system of Precision 5750 may be different.

  • raffaella

    33 Posts

    1303

    0

    Posted July 21st, 2021 09:00

    Just an idea to solve your noise problem: Part of the heat/fan noise generation could be due to having both the CPU's built in graphics and the dedicated GPU running. Does the BIOS give you the option of disabling the CPU's built in graphics? If yes, and if you did so did all or most of the fan noise stop?

  • 1291

    0

    Posted July 21st, 2021 11:00

    @raffaella  Thanks for your attention to this topic and the idea! Maybe I didn't emphasize this, but my Precision 7750 has the so called coil whine noise. The fans turn on pretty rarely. Even if they work, the noise of the fans is very low (at least for now).

  • raffaella

    33 Posts

    1248

    0

    Posted July 22nd, 2021 01:00

    It’s good to hear that your laptop’s 8 core xeon cpu rarely induced any appreciable fan noise, though I am curious to know of your typical task loads.

    But it doesn’t say much for Dell that so many have complained about that “coil whine” noise and that their engineering staff were unable-or unwilling-to find and offer a fix to owners of these expensive laptops.  

     

  • 1233

    0

    Posted July 22nd, 2021 10:00

    > I am curious to know of your typical task loads

    I am a software engineer specializing in compilers. So, the terminal and a browser are the main tools of my work.

     

    Actually, the dGPU of my Precision is turned off all the time (your advise!). This reduces the temperature of the CPU about 10 C. In addition, I recently changed my OS from Fedora to Debian (very minimal installation of Debian) and I am using the XFCE desktop environment. This also reduced the temperature of the CPU. So, during my work the temperature of the CPU is about 35 C. Of course, it also depends on the temperature of the room where is the laptop. In summer, I rarely turn on the air conditioner and usually work near the open window (the weather of Western New York is great!).