.miQ

updated

2 years ago

Closed

M

.miQ

1 Rookie

•

1 Message

2

13020

June 16th, 2019 19:00

Precision 5820, U3415W, popping from connected speakers

We are experiencing a similar issue here on our Dell Precision 5820 towers. Whenever the computer goes to sleep or wakes up, the speakers pop loudly. It seems to be as though the sound card is turning itself off abruptly when sleep mode kicks on or off, resulting in the loud pop to the speakers. This is going to eventually damage our speakers, I'm afraid. There must be a way to have the sound card attenuate first before abruptly shutting down when the computer's sleep mode kicks in, no?

.miQ

  • Andrewsil1

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    7672

    11

    Posted September 18th, 2019 11:00

    Think I may have found a fix in a different registry location based on a web post I didn't find in my first search:

    With regedit, try changing:

    HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Realtek\Audio\RtkNGUI64\PowerMngt\Enabled to 0.  This should disable the power management function and eliminate the pops.

  • bradthetechnut

    9 Technologist

    •

    9712 Posts

    •

    40924 Points

    7891

    0

    Posted July 7th, 2019 21:00

    There isn't a way to make a sound card automatically attenuate before sleep mode that I know of.

    You probably know you have at least 3 volumes to work with - Computer, media player, and speaker.  Did you try experimenting with those with any success?  Like turning down the computer volume and compensate by turning up the speakers where listening is comfortable.  Media player open or closed; different media player?

    If your machines are new or in warranty, opening up a ticket sbould be the best route to go.

    This post may seem a little similar to the thread you linked, but those are the ideas I had.

    On a side note, my TV likes doing that, notably when the weather is warmer before I have the a.c. going, the speakers will pop when it's turned on if it hasn't been off for very long.

    Not that I need a fix for my TV, just that hopefully you have no PC or environmental heat issues going on.  Heat issues can cause capacitor issues, hence the speaker pop noise.  Hopefully that makes sense.

    One more idea - Are computer/Windows/OS sound effects, beeps and chimes for this and that, on or off?  With it off, the PC has less excuse to send power or sound to the speakers when it wakes or sleeps.

  • bradthetechnut

    9 Technologist

    •

    9712 Posts

    •

    40924 Points

    7885

    0

    Posted July 7th, 2019 22:00

    If all else fails, is turning down the speakers before putting the computer to sleep a viable option in your environment?

  • Dell-Alan D

    4 Apprentice

    •

    1159 Posts

    7862

    0

    Posted July 9th, 2019 06:00


    @.miQ wrote:

    We are experiencing a similar issue here on our Dell Precision 5820 towers. Whenever the computer goes to sleep or wakes up, the speakers pop loudly. It seems to be as though the sound card is turning itself off abruptly when sleep mode kicks on or off, resulting in the loud pop to the speakers. This is going to eventually damage our speakers, I'm afraid. There must be a way to have the sound card attenuate first before abruptly shutting down when the computer's sleep mode kicks in, no?

    .miQ


    @.miQ can you advise what model of speakers you are using and how they are connected i.e is it via the monitor or direct to the soundcard / onboard audio on the motherboard?

    Has this popping sound only recently appeared or has it always been present?

    Are the speakers powered by a separate ac adaptor or do they run off USB?

    Do you have any other equipment there that you can use for testing?

    Alan

  • Andrewsil1

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    7742

    0

    Posted August 28th, 2019 16:00

    I'm having this problem virtually ANY TIME it plays a sound in Windows 10 (Pops, then plays the sound.) (Precision 5820, latest drivers from Dell support site, Windows 10 1903, external speakers plugged directly into sound card - NOT using monitor for speakers.) I came to the forum looking to see if anyone else was having this problem, and found this thread, which is close.

    This problem was not happening when the system was originally purchased but at some point in the last month or so this started happening.  I tried deleting the Dell drivers (completely) and using the generic Win10 drivers, and then I tried reinstalling the latest sound driver from Dell, but I can't get rid of the popping sound no matter what I do and it's driving me a bit batty, actually.

    Service code: .

    Andy Silverman

  • Dell-Alan D

    4 Apprentice

    •

    1159 Posts

    7734

    0

    Posted August 29th, 2019 07:00

    @Andrewsil1 thanks for adding to this. As per my response to the previous poster, can you help me out with these additional details please

    Are the speakers powered by a separate ac adaptor or do they run off USB?

    Do you have any other equipment there that you can use for testing?

    Alan

  • wdsims3

    1 Message

    7621

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2019 08:00

    I have the same issue on my 7920 workstation running Win 10.  I updated all drivers, BIOS, firmware, etc, but most times when an alert or system sound happens, a loud bang/pop precedes.  Volume and mute has no effect.  Externally attached speakers plugged directly into sound port (headphone type jack).  HIGHLY irritating.  Anybody have an idea **bleep** is the fix?

  • Andrewsil1

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    7616

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2019 09:00

    I researched this online and found that windows 10 has some registry settings, where if the device is idle for a certain number of seconds it will be put into a lower power state. Coming back out of this power state seems to be what causes the pop. Unfortunately, trying to change these registry settings doesn’t stick, and I think something, perhaps the driver itself, is putting the registry settings back to what they were before and the pop continues. I have not been able to find any alternative driver or other solution to the problem either, and I agree that it is incredibly annoying. I think Realtek will have to provide a fix.
  • Andrewsil1

    1 Rookie

    •

    6 Posts

    7615

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2019 09:00

    I’m sorry I didn’t see your earlier reply. The speakers are independently powered from AC.
  • Dell-Alan D

    4 Apprentice

    •

    1159 Posts

    2342

    0

    Posted September 19th, 2019 03:00

    @Andrewsil1 thanks for getting back to me with an update. That's interesting that it appears to be power management related and it does make sense. When the system requires audio output it sends a signal to the speaker waking it up giving that pop sound.

    From my research previously on the issue I was under the impression that it was relatively normal behaviour for speakers and was more common with speakers that had their own power supply. I know personally that when I connected my PC directly to my home cinema kit I had the exact same issue along with a constant hiss.

    How long have you successfully had this working for?

    Like yourself, i'm concerned that an audio update make undo your registry key changes.

    Alan