UNSOLVED

fesarlis

updated

12 years ago

F

fesarlis

12 Posts

0

60302

May 8th, 2015 08:00

RAID5 with SATA disks on older hardware

Hello community.


I am looking for a server with minimal cost (will buy a new one after summer), and have found lots of refurbished equipment even under 200GBP on eBay. I have administered Dell servers in the past, but only used them with disk arrays and/or SAS drivers. Basically it will be used as file server (probably with Windows Server 2003 or 2008, 10 users or less, no concurrent file transfers). My requirements:


1. I need at least 3TB of storage

2. I would like to use SATA drives for cost reasons.

3. I would like to setup either a RAID5 (with 3 1TB disks) or a RAID1 (with two 3TB disks).

4. The sever will have to be rack-mounted.


My questions are:

1. What is the oldest generation server that will support the requirements above?

2. I've found some PE1950s and PE2950s in great prices but I am not sure if they will do.

Thank you

  • fesarlis

    12 Posts

    1647

    0

    Posted May 8th, 2015 09:00

    Thank you for such a fast reply.


    Strangely, after my post, I have looked around and seen that SAS drives are not so expensive! In particular I found this drive:

    SAS SEAGATE ST1000NM0023 ES.3 1TB CONSTELLATION

    I also found the drive you said (RE4) which is also cheap.

    So, I will be going towards 2950 because it supports more than 4 drives, and I will be creating a RAID5 with 3x1tb disks.

    And to sum up :

    1. Would you recommend the SAS or the SATA drive above?

    2. I see that the server has a 750w power supply. Do you think it will consume the maximum power for the above configuration?

    3. Can't I just install a small 60GB SSD on one tray to store the OS?

    4. Would this be bad if I turn the server off every night? Never done that with others and I really don't know.

  • theflash1932

    11 Legend

    •

    16255 Posts

    1647

    1

    Posted May 8th, 2015 09:00

    1950/2950

    Yes, these will work, BUT ...

    • They do NOT support UEFI, so you cannot have an array/VD larger than 2TB that will hold the OS.
    • The controllers for these servers (PERC 5 and 6) do NOT support disks larger than 2TB.

    A 2950 would work fine as long as you are careful with the disks you use.

    An R710 is the replacement for the 2950 - it supports all your requirements (system can use the PERC 6/i, but you will need the H700 for +2TB disks).

    The R510 or R610 (assuming you want rackmount servers) would also be fine. The R410 would be ok. The R310 would be fine for a single-processor system.

    Just don't buy the cheap consumer desktop/laptop/NAS drives for a server. Drives like the WD Green and Red are not suitable for servers. The WD RE4 would be recommended. The Black would be about the only consumer drive (performance-driven) I would consider. Dell-certified drives would be ideal, but enterprise-class should be the minimum to look for.

  • theflash1932

    11 Legend

    •

    16255 Posts

    1647

    0

    Posted May 8th, 2015 11:00

    1. I would always recommend SAS where possible for performance and reliability reasons.

    2. No, 750W will power any supported 2950 configuration.

    3. Yes, you can, BUT you have to be careful - not all SSD's will work. MOST SSD's are designed for consumer use, and enterprise SSD's are expensive. It is hit/miss. If you do this, I would recommend a RAID 1 for the OS with the two SSD's or a REALLY good backup just in case.

    4. It's no different from a computer in that respect - you can, but you don't need to. Why do you want to? Some servers can take a while to start up, depending on the services/software configured.

  • fesarlis

    12 Posts

    1647

    0

    Posted May 12th, 2015 16:00

    Thanks again.

    I have come across another great product, in particular T310. (Perhaps I will drop the rack-mountable requirement.)..Just some questions in the same direction.


    1. It says it has a PERC 6/i. Can I create a RAID5 with SATA disks?

    2. It seems there is a version with a backplane (for hot swap disks) and one with internal disks (let's call it 'cable version'). My question is: Supposing that 6/i works fine with internal disks, are the same cables used for both SATA and SAS disks?

    3. Can I use 4 2TB WD RE4 disks? (THE SERVER WILL BE PURCHASED HAVING 4X146GB SAS DISKS.)

    4. There is also an LCD panel for this machine, sold separately, I noticed that according to specs it comes with the hot swap version. My question: Will it be useful in any way if used with the cable version?

  • RAJ54

    1 Rookie

    •

    71 Posts

    1647

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2016 07:00

    If you have a Perc 6/i it will work with WD RED SATA 2TB drives.  Im using a 1950 server with those drives in RAID 1 with zero issues.    It will do RAID 5 as well.

  • theflash1932

    11 Legend

    •

    16255 Posts

    1647

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2016 08:00

    Not sure how this got missed, but its rather old. For those who may come along with the same questions:

    1. Yes, the PERC 6 supports RAID 0,1,5,6,10,50,and 60.

    2. It depends on the cables you have. SAS cables/backplanes will take SAS and SATA drives. If your cabled machine has SATA drops on the cable from the controller, then you can't put SAS drives on them - you would need SAS drops/connectors, which will take both.

    3. The RE4 is not validated by Dell, but WD has validated it on many Dell controllers (including the PERC 6).

    4. Useful? Yes. However, it may not have the proper connectors on the non hot-swap version.

    They may seem to work, but in general, the Red is a poor choice for a server or a workstation. You'll find more that don't work in these forums than do, so saying they work with "zero issues" is anecdotal at best.