UNSOLVED

marinfr

updated

9 years ago

M

marinfr

4 Posts

0

5583

June 23rd, 2017 07:00

T610 Noise Fan Speed

St

Server running fine no issues other then very loud fan speed and noise. No fan failures that can be identified , Overall system performance is fine

OS = 2008R2

  • Daniel My

    12 Elder

    •

    6204 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted June 23rd, 2017 10:00

    Hello

    Here is a post where I describe how the fan speeds are controlled:

    http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/servers/f/956/t/19527554

    If you install unsupported hardware into the server that the BMC/iDRAC does not have a profile for it is programmed to assume that the item creates a lot of heat and will adjust the minimum fan speed higher.

    Regardless of temperature probes, there is a minimum fan speed that will be set based on the hardware configuration. The fan speed can increase from that minimum based on temperature probes. Also, certain conditions will cause the fans to run at maximum RPM. One of those conditions is the chassis intrusion switch being open. Check the hardware log for any errors/warnings.

    Thanks

  • marinfr

    4 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted June 23rd, 2017 11:00

    thanks for your response , are there any firmware or  driver etc updates that I should apply/

    Also I cant seem to launch the Open manage software any longer could that be related? As a result I can not check for any warnings etc

  • Daniel My

    12 Elder

    •

    6204 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted June 23rd, 2017 13:00

    are there any firmware or  driver etc updates that I should apply/

    The iDRAC/BMC controls fan speeds. The profiling may change with updates, so updating the iDRAC may change how the fans operate. Also, the system BIOS manages hardware communication throughout the system. Updating the BIOS may affect hardware communication or temperature probes. That could have an impact on fan speed.

    Also I cant seem to launch the Open manage software any longer could that be related?

    It depends on whether the OMSA issue is software or hardware related. If OMSA is launching in a browser but not displaying any information then that is likely an issue with the iDRAC/BMC. If OMSA is having issues launching then that is likely software related.

    OMSA communicates with the iDRAC to populate the hardware information. If the iDRAC is not functional then little or no information will be displayed in OMSA. If the iDRAC is not functional the system fans will run at maximum RPM continuously. The two issues could be related.

    Thanks

  • marinfr

    4 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted July 6th, 2017 08:00

    Can you recommend steps to correct, either firmware updates or drac patch etc

     

    It seems this is a know problem with other users in the forum . all experiencing different resolutions

     

    I do not necessarily need the drac

     

    I have tried to update the bios and chipset with no correction of the error or fan speed

     

    Frank

  • Daniel My

    12 Elder

    •

    6204 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted July 6th, 2017 09:00

    It seems this is a know problem with other users in the forum . all experiencing different resolutions

    You are noticing a symptom of the issue. You don't know what the cause is yet. Just because other users have reported the same symptom does not mean they have the same issue. The symptoms you are noticing can be caused by several potential issues.

    I would suggest trying to update the iDRAC. If you are unable to update the iDRAC then it may be faulty.

    I do not necessarily need the drac

    If you don't want your fans running at maximum RPM all the time then you need the iDRAC.

    Thanks

  • skylarking

    2 Intern

    •

    548 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted July 7th, 2017 00:00

    @Daniel it's not really a symptom of an issue as such. It's more an issue of design that Dell does not expose for example fan parameters via BIOS (where users can apply their judgment and adjust an overly aggressive fan profile that results in excessive noise). 

    Simply installing a non Dell card will result in lots of noise where as a Dell card (which may be based of the non Dell card and with same heat output) will result in a quiet system. In such cases the cynic in me sees it as more about punishing the owner for use of non Dell cards than about protecting the system from overheating.

    Even the latest PE servers have a kludge of a design as seen when telsa/graphics cards are installed. Fans are forced to 75% max output rather than using mobo temperature sensors to control system fans as the terlsa/graphics card's firmware manages it's own fans to control and expell heat from the card out the PCIe bracket and out of the case (since they are not passively cooled via heatsinks).

    I'll agree with @marinfr that this is a know problem. But i'd go further and say Dell simply doesn't care as Dell could simply fixed the issue but has no interest in doing so (or it could be fixed by others as mentioned in another posts if Dell provided a full build environment for the opensource bmc/idrac firmware that manages the fans - but not enough has been released to build anything).

    [Edited to add following]
    IIRC all T610 have an base idrac which can be upgraded to idrac enterprise by another add on part. The base idrac is located on the mobo under a plack plastic shield below the pcie slots (that is away from the PCIe face plate) and it controls the fan speed. Whether @marinfr needs idrac is irrelevant unless he has removed it but i'd think the system wont boot in such cases.

  • theflash1932

    11 Legend

    •

    16255 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted July 12th, 2017 14:00

    Dell does not expose for example fan parameters via BIOS (where users can apply their judgment and adjust an overly aggressive fan profile that results in excessive noise)

    Ha ha ... can you imagine if users were allowed to more easily "apply their judgement"?! Not saying anything about the judgement of those in this thread, but in general, that is a horrible idea. Users break it, and Dell pays to fix it. Bad, bad idea, and there is no way they can possibly design the system to accomodate and work with every part a user could conceivably put into their server. If you want versatility, build your own server. Dell provides stable solutions for business, and does not cater to the enthusiast crowd.

    (You probably knew that was coming ;))

  • skylarking

    2 Intern

    •

    548 Posts

    4179

    0

    Posted July 28th, 2017 21:00

    skylarking
    Dell does not expose for example fan parameters via BIOS (where users can apply their judgment and adjust an overly aggressive fan profile that results in excessive noise)

    Ha ha ... can you imagine if users were allowed to more easily "apply their judgement"?! Not saying anything about the judgement of those in this thread, but in general, that is a horrible idea. Users break it, and Dell pays to fix it.

    Hmm..

    Makers of a $35 Raspberry Pi have the forsight to use a sticky bit within the SOC as an indicator that the user has overclocked/overvolted their RPi thus voiding the warrenty.

    Dell, with all it's resources and knowledge, could expose cooling parameters within system firmware and warn the owner that changing such parameters could void the warrenty. Then it's a simple matter for the firmware to make note that the user has changed such parameters within NV memory that all system boards have. So such warrenty concerns do have solutions, it's not rocket science.

    Bad, bad idea, and there is no way they can possibly design the system to accomodate and work with every part a user could conceivably put into their server.

    (You probably knew that was coming ;))

    As you know, it's all be based on industry standards. PCIe slots and PCIe card, as used within our computers, should work together without issue. As such one should expect the PCIe slots are certified to those industry standards as should the PCIe cards. IMO, Dell seems to document it backwards by stating specific cards are certified for specific systems. So, if Dell actually designs and certifies their motherboards to industry standards, there should be little issue with the various components an owner may throw into the machine. It should just work and work reliably (unless there is a deficiency in the standards in which case that issue should be addressed in the standards).

    If some cards don't work in the machine, then there is an element of "propriatary" in the design which in the long term is a dissservice to the market. So I don't think it's an issue of Dell providing a stable solution, rather it's an issue of Dell (and all other server manufacturers) trying hard to lock in the customer.

    (You probably knew that was coming ;))

    Yeah :emotion-5:

    You should probable be aware that I'm manufacturer agnostic. So while W. C. Fields was quoted as saying "I'm free of all prejudies. I hate everyone equally", i can say "I'm no fanboy, i hate all manufacturers equally" :emotion-5:

    [PS]

    Who's idea was this silly captcha system... it's a royal PITA.