UNSOLVED

pachl

updated

20 years ago

P

pachl

2 Posts

0

5731

May 2nd, 2007 07:00

Trunking Between VLANs on One Physical Switch?

My goal is to setup redundant bridging-firewalls between two VLANs on a single PowerConnect 3248. Is this possible? My bridging-firewalls are OpenBSD machines configured as bridges running pf (packet filter).

I was thinking it would be cool to use trunking to increase bandwidth as well as redundancy. I tried several configurations on my 3248, but nothing seems to work. The simpliest configuration that works is connecting a single OpenBSD bridge between VLANS 1 & 2 with no trunks.

Disconnecting one side of the bridge breaks communication between VLAN 1 & 2, which is expected behavior and proves all traffic must go through the filtering bridge to talk to different VLANs.

My setup:

VLAN1 -> Ports[13-50] (unused)
VLAN2 -> Ports[1-4] (client group 1)
VLAN3 -> Ports[5-8] (client group 2)
VLAN4 -> Ports[9-12] (bridges and trunk)
TRUNK1 -> Ports[9-10] VLAN[4,2] PVID = 4 (bridges listening to client group 1)
TRUNK2 -> Ports[11-12] VLAN[4,3] PVID = 4 (bridges listening to client group 2)
Bridge1 -> Port[9,11]
Bridge2 -> Port[10,12]


[VLAN1] = network 1.1.1.0/24
/ \
/ \
/ \
[Trunk1] [Trunk1] = Ports 9,10 on 3248
| |
| |
[BR1] [BR2] = OpenBSD boxes running as bridges
| |
| |
[Trunk2] [Trunk2] = Ports 11,12 on 3248
\ /
\ /
\ /
[VLAN2] = same IP subnet as VLAN1



Is there a better way? Any pointers in accomplishing my goal will be much appreciated? Basically, I want to (1) create redundant bridges and (2) share load among those bridges.

Thanks,
Clint Pachl
  • MiF_STIG

    5 Posts

    246

    0

    Posted May 5th, 2007 10:00

    ... sorry, i hit the ENTER touch, so :
     
    - Hi, i don't know that kind of switch, i worked on Avaya, Cisco and Nortel, ... but i gonna try to help you.
     
    - Can you set a port "passive", turning on if an "active" port turns down ? (this is called "software redundancy" by Avaya)
    - Bridge 1 would be connected to the "active" port, and Bridge 2 to the "passive".
     
    Alex.
  • MiF_STIG

    5 Posts

    246

    0

    Posted May 5th, 2007 10:00

    -Hi, i don't know that kind of switch, i worked on Avaya, Cisco and Nortel, ... but i gonna try to help you.
    -Can you affect 2 vlans per port, without activating 802.1q on those ? ... depending on the manufacturer 802.1q can be called