UNSOLVED

darrell_ingram

updated

24 years ago

0

25682

March 8th, 2003 15:00

Problems with 3Com 3C920 Integrated NIC & GX150s

We're a college and we've got 112 GX150s with Windows XP Pro connected to a NT4 Server. But only just - they all nearly ended up in the rubbish skip last Friday afternoon...

Looking through this forum it looks like we are not alone in having major problems with this model PC and the onboard 3Com 3C920 Integrated NIC.

We have the "can't log you on because the xxxx domain is not available" all the time on all of them and the only way is to shut the PC down and restart and even then you can't guarantee that this will solve the problem. Sometimes it takes multiple shutdowns and restarts to enable the users to be able to log on. Before we got the GX150s we never ever saw this problem before.

We've got Dell E1s, GX100s and other makes of PCs (all with different make or model NICS) on the same network running NT4 Workstation and they work okay with no problems at all. Stick one of these on a network point where a GX150 keeps  and it works fine. Stick a GX150 on a network point where an E1 or a GX100 or another make works fine and it immediately becomes.

We also see the GX150s dropping the network mid session so the user logs off blissfully unaware that the stupid  has lost all their work for them.

We've checked all the settings, checked our network cabling, switches and hubs, installed the latest BIOS and drivers - and it all points back to something to do with either the GX150s, the 3Com 3C920, or both.

Don't tell me to set the NICs to 10Mb & half-duplex - what's the point of having a 100Mb network otherwise...?

Darrell Ingram.

P.S. , but as you can probably tell, I'm pretty off with this situtation.

  • droid256

    73 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2003 13:00

    It sounds like you are more interested in venting than getting help, but a few more details in the message might help.  What version driver is on the GX150, What kind of switches are you connecting to?  Does the RJ-45 connector provide a positive lock?  What OS is running on the GX150s?

    Droid

  • aborq

    8 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted March 10th, 2003 18:00

    Oh man - and I thought I was alone on this one.

    I had a GX150 go nuts on me two months ago (wouldn't turn on at all). Dell sent someone over to change RAM and Motherboard - but that's just when my trouble started.

     

    The 150 is used as a development server for me alone, so it's network load is not high - and hence my problems were hardly noticeable in the beginning.

     

    But to make a long, tiresome story short: I have the exact same problems that you describe (although in a much smaller environment) This problem occurs on all Windows OSs from NT4 and forward (haven't tried Linux, but including servers and beta-releases), with all assortments of drivers, IP-configs, you name it.

     

    Dell insists that this is a software error, since the diagnostics turn up nothing, yet I believe that it is a hardware error - I even had a MCSE-certified engineer go over it. With certain tweaks and probably forcing 10 Mb, etc. he got it to work on a Windows 2000 Advanced Server, but it's not stable in my environment.

     

    The only thing I haven't tried yet is getting a crossed patch cable and connecting it directly to one of the other machines. Apparently, they say, 3Com NICs are known to have problems with certain types of switches - so if you have another type of switch, try plugging one of the lousy machines into that one instead.

     

    Regards,

     

    Anders

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2003 02:00

    This problem sounds more like "we changed out hubs for switches" problem. I have over 5000 GX150's running on a very Diverse network that includes, Appletalk, Banyan Vines, Netware 3,4,5,6
    NT 4.0, WIN2000, and workstations running 95,98,2000,Me and XP.


    When one group installed Cisco 2950 switches in place of 10 Meg hubs this became a problem.

    Enableing Spanning Tree Port Fast on specific ports and making sure that the net was setup in a STAR fashion instead of hubs daisy chained like a choo choo train fixed the problem.

    With Hubs you are all on the same segment. With switches you
    have to do more than just plug them in and get the Link status lights to show up.

    The 3C920 (3C905B compatable 10/100 nic) is unlikely to be the real problem.
  • aborq

    8 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2003 16:00

    That's not quite it.

    I do have a switch (one) on the network - but that's the way it has always been.

    The only thing that has changed from when my system was working fine to not working is that the GX150 blew a fuse or something, Dell came and changed RAM, motherboard, etc.

    Before this everything worked perfectly. After this the other machines in the network still work perfectly - but the GX150 will do absolutely nothing when it concerns network issues.

    /Anders

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    408

    0

    Posted March 16th, 2003 23:00

    NT4 REQUIRES pnpisa.inf before the nic will work.

    LMHOSTS and WINS affect this also.
  • aborq

    8 Posts

    408

    0

    Posted March 17th, 2003 08:00

    I don't really care what NT needs. I have the problem on 98, Me, Nt, 2000, XP, .NET Server 2003 (both RC's). With or without the newest drivers supplied by Dell or MS - it doesn't make a difference.

    /Anders

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    408

    0

    Posted March 19th, 2003 01:00

    The number of switches doesnt matter. Spanning Tree Port fast DOES matter.

    Again. If you use a Hub or turn on spanning tree port fast the problem is solved.

     

    Others talk about

    ip helper-address XXX.XXX.XXX.XXX

    the switch may not be passing the WINS requests along.
    Put that line in with the IP address for the WINS server 
    Also see:

    http://www.itp-journals.com/nasample/p1417.pdf

    There is no problem whatsoever with the 3COM integrated NIC.

    Spanning Tree portfast cannot be done where hubs are daisychained off from the switches. So this is not done on all the ports. Also HANGING a 10Meg Hub off of
    a port set this way will KILL the entire LAN. So planning is a must when doing this type of config.

    Also I am sure that daisy chaining the switches like a train is not the best way to
    set them up. It must be that a star configuration where the switches are all tied to
    a central switch.


    Cisco 2950 looks something like this in the IOS

    #SH config
    Using 3585 out of 32768 bytes
    !
    ! Last configuration change at 22:03:55 UTC Wed Aug 8 2001 by admin
    ! NVRAM config last updated at 22:04:05 UTC Wed Aug 8 2001 by admin
    !
    version 12.0
    no service pad
    service timestamps debug uptime
    service timestamps log uptime
    service password-encryption
    !
    hostname 2950

    !
    ip subnet-zero
    !
    !
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/1
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/2
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/3
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/4
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/5
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/6
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/7
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/8
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/9
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/10
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/11
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/12
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/13
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/14
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/15
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/16
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/17
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/18
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/19
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/20
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/21
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/22
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/23
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/24
    spanning-tree portfast
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/25
    !
    interface FastEthernet0/26
    !

     

  • aborq

    8 Posts

    408

    0

    Posted March 23rd, 2003 17:00

    So. Now I've attached a 10/100 hub instead. No fancy stuff there. Same deal.

    Three machines active on the LAN - two still works fine together and on the net, and then there's the GX150. For that one it is still the same deal.

    It seems like it recieves data-packages OK, and hence it must return ACK-packages OK as well. Also, as noted above, certain simple tasks will work on the internet - but as soon as it has to send real data, it messes up.

    It can browse foldes on a healthy machine - but if it tries to update some of the 'auto' files in XP (like thumbnails.db) it fails.

     

    /Anders

  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    408

    0

    Posted March 23rd, 2003 18:00

    There is no such thing as a 10/100 Hub. If its 10/100 its a switch.


    If its 100Meg Only its a Hub or if its 10 meg Only its a Hub.


    Poor wiring and or Non twisted pair wiring will work on 10 meg ethernet but will mess up on 100 meg.

    If you use a 10 Meg Only Hub the results will be much different.
  • aborq

    8 Posts

    265

    0

    Posted March 23rd, 2003 22:00

    Yeah, that's what I thought, too... But I looked it up - as I wanted to be precise in my argument - and the vendor consistently referred to this particular model as a hub.

    As for cable quality, I use only professional cables.

    Anyway, it doesn't really matter - it has been tested at a site with tons of different equipment, all to no avail.

     

    /Anders