UNSOLVED

Ratford

updated

22 years ago

R

Ratford

1 Rookie

•

13 Posts

0

881

August 22nd, 2004 20:00

Advice needed: Best monitor for games?

I just ordered my new Dell XPS and decided to get the nifty 20" LCD. But I am having second thoughts and need some advice and opinions. The native resolution of the 20" is 1600 x 1200 and to get the best quality display for games that's the resolution I should be running at. I also got the X800 XT video card so I'm pretty sure I can run all of the current crop of games at 1600 x 1200. But in a year or two, games may require more power than my computer has and I may have to drop down to 1280 x 1024. I guess the question comes down to this: How much worse is the display quality if I'm not running at the native resolution? Is it a whole lot worse or is it really not noticeable? I usually play games nowdays at 1280 x 1024, even if I can go higher, just because I don't notice that much of a difference between that and 1600 x 1200. If I switch my order to the 19" LCD monitor then I'm pretty sure I can play all my games at 1280 x 1024, the native resolution, for the lifetime of my computer (factoring in a new video card purchase in about 2 years). The drawback is that the 19" can NEVER run at a higher resolution than that. Also the 20" monitor's 16 ms response time is pretty seductive. What should I do? Would it be really bad to run the 20" at 1280 x 1024?

Also a second, lesser, question: How are games with an LCD monitor nowdays? For awhile it's been no contest, a CRT was the better choice hands down. But how about today's crop of LCD's? I understand the refresh rate is slower. Any other reasons why a CRT is still better? Is it a LOT better? I just really like the idea of that small, thin, lightweight monitor and getting ris of that 10 ton monstrosity that's taking up space on my desk right now. But I use my computer almost exclusively for games.

Any hardcode gamers out there who know about this stuff?

Alvin
  • Dysseron

    96 Posts

    368

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 13:00

    Sorry, I don't have an answer for you.  I want to know what other people think too.  I have the same concern you do, which is why I have not ordered the LCD yet.  For example, in games, such as Doom 3, when you walk up to a computer screen, the information (text) is rather sharp and this is playing on my 19" CRT at 1280 x 1024.  If I purchase the 20" LCD (with a native resolution of 1600 x 1200), but I continue to play the game at 1280 x 1024, will I notice a HUGE difference in some of the aspects of the game where "sharpness" is needed. 

    Thanks.

  • Ratford

    1 Rookie

    •

    13 Posts

    368

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 14:00

    Another thing occurred to me which makes me want to get the 19" monitor instead. I remember this now from the current CRT I have. I don't remember the size of my CRT but measuring the viewing area diagonally with a measuring tape, it's 18". For its time it was a pretty big monitor and it was impossible to play any game at a resolution below 1280 x 1024, because at 1024 x 768 the horizontal scan lines were quite visible. I remember complaining about this to other gamers who couldn't figure out what I was talking about. To them 1024 x 768 was a perfectly good resolution but it turned out they had smaller monitors than I did. A big monitor kind of turned out to be a curse, anything below 1280 x 1024 was too liney, but later games ran too slowly at that resolution. Now if we're talking about a 20" monitor, it could well be that anything below 1600 x 1200 would be too "liney." Hey, since LCDs don't use a scanning electron beam, then would they even have scan lines? What happens to the display on one of those things as you crank the resolution down?

    Since a 19" LCD is even a bit bigger than the monitor I have now, I'm convincing myself that's what I should get instead. But the 20" LCD has that great response time ...
  • Dysseron

    96 Posts

    368

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 16:00

    Yeah, I would jump all over the 19" if it had a 16ms response time.  I don't know if I want 1600 x 1200 all crammed into a 20.1" screen.  The 1280 x 1024 on my CRT is just a hair small for me at that resolution, and I would not want everything to look even smaller.  Plus the 19" is cheaper. 

    I think that maybe I need to do a test by going into Best Buy and seeing if they have a game hooked up to a demo computer with an LCD. 

     

  • 368

    0

    Posted August 26th, 2004 16:00

    I had the same concern when I bought my computer: how would a game look at other than native resolution? I have the UltraSharp 1703FP, that's a 17" LCD display with a native resolution of 1280x1024. In my opinion, the difference between running a game at the native resolution and a lower resolution (say, 800x600) is not noticeable. Of course the picture looks better at a finer resolution but but the display does an excellent job at stretching a smaller picture to the full screen.

    The response time of the 1703FP is about 16ms, same as the 20" 2001FP, and when I play games I notice no ghosting at all. I also feel that an LCD is a lot easier on the eyes than a CRT monitor. Overall I am extremely pleased with the display. If you want to learn more, AnandTech has a detailed review of the 2001FP:

    http://www.anandtech.com/showdoc.aspx?i=1918&p=1

    Lastly, I should mention that I have the display connected through a DVI adapter. It is my understanding that the picture is noticeably worse if you use an analog adapter. Hope this helps.

    Message Edited by Fred-from-NYC on 08-26-2004 02:01 PM