UNSOLVED

Porsche911

updated

23 years ago

Closed

P

Porsche911

105 Posts

0

14056

December 24th, 2003 05:00

To 'Centrino' or not to 'Centrino' - that is the question...

Centrino is limited to 802.11b @11Mbps

802.11g and 802.11g108 respectively provide 54 Mbps and 108 Mbps

If I do not care about battery, size and weight, is there any other reason why I should consider a centrino vesus a Pentium  4 with a 802.11g 108 card?

  • RandyB

    518 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 24th, 2003 07:00



    @Porsche911 wrote:

    @Centrino is limited to 802.11b @11Mbps

    802.11g and 802.11g108 respectively provide 54 Mbps and 108 Mbps

    If I do not care about battery, size and weight, is there any other reason why I should consider a centrino vesus a Pentium  4 with a 802.11g 108 card?



    Centrino next year - that is the answer!

    If I had the money, I would certainly try that Eurocom...looks like a 'mean machine' to me. Isn't that the model with the 256MB video RAM?

  • HMKrieps

    713 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 24th, 2003 08:00

    The last thing you could care about is heat generation resulting in more fan noise. I see that you have an Inspiron 5100 at work (featuring the Desktop Pentium 4), so if the fan noise doesn't bother you and you don't care about battery, size and weight, there should be no major advantage of the Centrino.
    But it is still possible to equip a Pentium M Notebook with an 802.11g (I assume that 802.11g isn't a standard yet) card for example, like my Inspiron 8600. It has the Pentium M, i855 chipset, but an 802.11g WLAN instead of the Intel2100, so it doen't get the Centrino sticker, but I don't mind about that
  • its_edwin

    16 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 24th, 2003 08:00

    The only thing that limits the centrino to 802.11b is the wireless card that's installed on the board. The mini-pci card installed can be removed and replaced by a different card. The antenna already installed on the computer should be good enough for 802.11g (and 802.11g108 since it runs on the same frequency).

    If you don't care about battery, size, or weight.. then go with the Pentium 4, but not the 4-M.

  • RandyB

    518 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 24th, 2003 12:00



    @HMKrieps wrote:
    The last thing you could care about is heat generation resulting in more fan noise. I see that you have an Inspiron 5100 at work (featuring the Desktop Pentium 4), so if the fan noise doesn't bother you and you don't care about battery, size and weight, there should be no major advantage of the Centrino.
    But it is still possible to equip a Pentium M Notebook with an 802.11g (I assume that 802.11g isn't a standard yet) card for example, like my Inspiron 8600. It has the Pentium M, i855 chipset, but an 802.11g WLAN instead of the Intel2100, so it doen't get the Centrino sticker, but I don't mind about that

    ...same with clothing! Would you rather pay $30 for an article of clothing; or, spend $60 for basically the same article because it has a 'brand name' (brand, being any company that has seduced the general public through advertising) label?

    eg: I saw a pair of 'Speedo' swim trunks for $30. I bought the same style and quality from a (no name) manufacturer at another store for $9.

  • Porsche911

    105 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 25th, 2003 17:00

    -------------
    But it is still possible to equip a Pentium M Notebook with an 802.11g (I assume that 802.11g isn't a standard yet) card for example, like my Inspiron 8600. It has the Pentium M, i855 chipset, but an 802.11g WLAN instead of the Intel2100, so it doen't get the Centrino sticker, but I don't mind about that
    -------------

    Yes not having the Centrino sticker is not going to bother me.  I believe Netgear (and maybe DLink and others) support the 108 Mbps 802.11g.  Dell only offers 54 MBps 802.11b/g for additional $29

    Now that brings up another question:  When plugged to an AC source how does the top of the line "Intel Pentium M @ 1.7 GHz" compare in performance to the top of the line "Mobile Intel Pentium 4 @ 3.2GHz".  I will post this as separate post.

  • Porsche911

    105 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 26th, 2003 13:00

    Randy,

    Eurocom's options seem to be a little expensive.  $230 USD for an upgrade to a 7200rpm 60 GB HD.
    Plus they still don't have the WUXGA (1920 x 1200)
    I also need to find out how reliable the company is and how the support is?

    I hope Dell's replacement for Inspiron 8500 is offered with WUXGA (1920 x 1200) in 17" widescreen configuration with0.19mm pixel pitch.

  • RandyB

    518 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 26th, 2003 13:00



    @Porsche911 wrote:

    -------------
    But it is still possible to equip a Pentium M Notebook with an 802.11g (I assume that 802.11g isn't a standard yet) card for example, like my Inspiron 8600. It has the Pentium M, i855 chipset, but an 802.11g WLAN instead of the Intel2100, so it doen't get the Centrino sticker, but I don't mind about that
    -------------

    Yes not having the Centrino sticker is not going to bother me.  I believe Netgear (and maybe DLink and others) support the 108 Mbps 802.11g.  Dell only offers 54 MBps 802.11b/g for additional $29

    @Now that brings up another question:  When plugged to an AC source how does the top of the line "Intel Pentium M @ 1.7 GHz" compare in performance to the top of the line "@Mobile Intel Pentium 4 @ 3.2GHz".  I will post this as separate post.


    ...about that Eurocom. I just priced one out. I couldn't seem to configure an UXGA; but, with the WXGA 17", 2.6 hyperthreaded, 40GB 5400RPM HD, 256MB Radeon 9700 video, 512MB RAM, 6-in-1 card reader/subwoofer, 12 cell lithium battery, 1.3MP built-in camera, Gigabit LAN, WIFI, separate numeric keypad - all for around $3500CDN (about $500 in taxes included)...about the same as I would pay for an I8600. Considering what you get with the Eurocom; I would say that's a REALLY GOOD deal and a VERY NICE gaming machine!
  • RandyB

    518 Posts

    576

    0

    Posted December 26th, 2003 14:00



    @Porsche911 wrote:

    Randy,

    Eurocom's options seem to be a little expensive.  $230 USD for an upgrade to a 7200rpm 60 GB HD.
    Plus they still don't have the WUXGA (1920 x 1200)
    I also need to find out how reliable the company is and how the support is?

    I hope Dell's replacement for Inspiron 8500 is offered with WUXGA (1920 x 1200) in 17" widescreen configuration with0.19mm pixel pitch.


    Yes! It can get very expensive; but, for what I listed at that price - Dell doesn't even come close!
    The company IS reliable. There's a computer store here in Vancouver that has been selling Eurocoms for years and everbody's happy.  I think that rather than pouring millions of $$$ into advertising; they put it into their computers.
    I already have a 7200RPM HD.  That sort of thing is easily upgradable in the future anyway.