
UNSOLVED
Closed
Regarding the 5150...
I've read alot of stuff about this system, but im still new to navigating the Dell forums and couldn't find a thread that was still going about the 5150, so I figured I might as well post a new thread in the main forum. If it needs to be moved I guess it will be? In anyevent, here is my story/problem with the laptop and the complaints...
I bought my laptop online in mid August and finally had it in my hands on September 1st of 2004. Since it was better than my rotting desktop, I used it for everything and took it everywhere. In January, I bought World of Warcraft, a game which I thought was very stressful on my system, but regardless played it litterally 24/7 with a friend of mine who lived with me at the time. When I wasn't on it, he was. Its now one year later, and the only problem I have is my headset is somewhat loose in the sound jack. I believe this from the headset plug being slightly pushed to the side in the jack by the padding of my laptop bag. This is because I used to have the laptop turned on so I could listen to music on the walk home from where ever. No worries though, I had the laptop sideways with the bag open, fan and vents pointing out, for air flow. Winter conditions helped too! ;)
Anyways, I wanted to upgrade my Ram to 1gb, and while researching I find out the 5150 has sooo many problems, yet I haven't had one of these problems yet. Its unfortunate since Im now freaking out that my laptop is doomed to die and I have to buy a new one, which blows because I am also a student, so its under the 4 year plan, stupid of me?
In responce to the overheating issue, I have always taken good care of my laptop. The only thing I neglected to do was use compressed air to clean it. Eeek! But after buying Warcraft, it rarely left my desk. So because of this, and the fact it is/was ALWAYS on, I have a fan constantly on, pointing at it from the back. I did this because 3 months after I bought it, the glue on the rubber 'feet' melted off, so with no means of air flow, I have a crude device set up to prop my laptop, tilted so air can flow freely with the help of the fan. However, Out of the 12 months that I've had it, 1 month ago was the first time I used compressed air to cleaned it out. A small/fair amount of dust came out, but it took a whole 5 seconds to finish cleaning it out totally. I was shocked, so I tried every small hole that could harbor dust, but I just ended up wasting alot of compressed air on nothing. :P I guess constant flowing air helps keep dust out a bit, ^_^
In any event, I was hoping that Dell had fixed this 'flaw' in their more recent 5150s, seeing as how most people who complain about it bought theirs back in '03. I am really hoping they fixed it so that I didn't waste 3000$ on a laptop that has a good chance of dying at anytime. Can anyone tell me if they did fix it, or at least some sort of way to save it before its too late. =(
Responses (4)
Solutions (0)
fenderguitarguy
328 Posts
621
0
Posted September 1st, 2005 14:00
Honestly, if you have a 5150 that actually works, you are lucky. Most 5150's have so many problems and so many arent even operational. If my motherboard goes out again, mine will be a boat anchor, there is no point in putting money in something thats going to break again.The main problem i have with mine is the power. The spot on the motherboard that your ac adapter plugs in to breaks very easy. It is a major design flaw and Dell will not admit or fix it. My warrenty just ran out so if something happens, i am out of luck.Most likely, your laptop is doomed to die. You wont get any warnings, it will just not work. Depending on which problem your laptop has, diferent things will happen to it. Some 5150's have a problem where the motherboard warps and if you touch it, it will die. Some have the loose power connector that eventually breaks off. A few catch on fire where the memory is. Sometimes, the motherboard will die and it wont power up. Also, as you mentioned, watch out for the dust. I clean mine by taking the fan assembly out and blowing the vents that way. Over time, the dust will clump and it wont come out unless you take it apart. Ill post a link to the instructions after I post this message.Another problem these laptops have are the hard drives. If your laptop is equipped with a Hitachi hard drive, you most likely will have problems. You will notice an irregular clicking sound. I have went through a few of those too.The 5150 would be a great machine if there wasnt so many design flaws. I think mine would run forever if the ac adapter had a right angle plug instead of the straight plug that sticks out 2 inches.- Haha I know what you mean. My 7 year old 15gig harddrive has been making those soudns for years. Still works great though. As for my laptop, yeah the ahrddrive does sometimes make those clicking noises, but rarely. I have it sitting on my desk constantly being cooled by a fan, and feeling around the outside casting, it feels cool everywhere. Im not sure about hte inside, but if it is working in keeping itr cooled, then maybe I am delaying the overheating factor? Also, since it has just sat on my desk for 70% of its life, maybe the power supply issues have been avoided as well?In anycase, I still wish to know if there is any permanent way to fix this, even if its after it breaks down. Or, should I jsut not worry about it for now, and jsut buy a new system when it does go? But I am a starving student, and its only been a year since I bought this laptop, I have 3 more years to go. if it craps out,. Dell better be compensating me for this because if its been such a problem since 2003, then I should get some sort of compensation for them selling me a faulty product even after they knew of it's flawed design. Other people have had them fix the problem free of charge, multiple times, sometimes even getting a brand new laptop. I dont care, as long as they satisfy me as a customer I will be content with repairs/replacements, as I wont rely on this sytem as I used to.Sorry for the long post. I just hoped they fixed this flaw before taking it off the market, but it seems that they may not have. If i remember correctly, they also took 5150s off their website shortly after I bought mine, so what does that tell us? :P Anyhow, any permanent fixe I can do without going through Dell? Sending it away is such a chore =/
fenderguitarguy
328 Posts
621
0
Posted September 1st, 2005 19:00
unfortuanatly, there isnt much that you can do. Laptops are much harder to service than desktops. You cant just go to circuit city and buy a part. If you want to avoid dell, i would suggest ebay, you can get cheap parts there.
Some problems that the 5150 has are fixed in the 5160, even so, the 5160 has many problems also. Its a Dell thing. Lately, Dell laptops havent been quality products.
For most of the "common" 5150 problems, you have to send the laptop in.

fenderguitarguy
328 Posts
621
0
Posted September 1st, 2005 14:00