UNSOLVED

spinchik14

updated

21 years ago

Closed

S

spinchik14

1 Message

0

61547

April 17th, 2006 18:00

Mother board/Battery/AC Adaptor

Sorry for the length but I have read many postings and decided to register to add my two cents. I purchased an Inspiron 5160 in December 2004 and by March 2005 began having usage problems. First the battery would charge intermittently even though the AC adaptor was connected. Then error messages about overheating (after it had been off and not running for a day, and cold as a cucumber!). Finally, no battery charge was made and the battery icon continued to appear even though it was plugged in.
 
I chatted with Dell Customer Service and took their recommendation for a new AC adaptor. However, after reading many of the postings, I knew it had to be a mother board problem. After the AC adaptor arrived, no change in battery charge. I returned it and got full refund, including the shipping costs, since it was their error.
 
Over the weekend I went laptop window shopping. I really don't want to spend money I don't have but wanted to do the research anyway, esp since I am extremely frustrated with this problem. Since I see this is a common theme with the Inspirons, I was looking at HP's. I had heard replacing the motherboard can run several hundred dollars. Buy new or fix, hmmm. So I decided to give it one more try with customer service.
 
I just hung up with Dell Customer Service, paid the $41.73 Diagnostics charge, ran an assessment unsuccessfully, and was told it is a mother board problem (enj63 was right on in all those posts I read that he replied on). I called for service and found some encouraging news - they are running an all-inclusive special now - motherboard replacement, labor, shipping both ways, parts - for $378. For me that is still considerably less than a new laptop so I am going for it.
 
It is guaranteed to be back within 7-10 days. I'll let you all know how it turns out since I was getting the same problems many of you share.
 
One last thing. I spoke to the supervisor in the Dell customer service phone support. I asked him if anyone from Dell reads the online forum posts. I pointed out that there are many reports of this same problem and that perhaps Dell should read these and fix whatever is causing this problem in their laptops. I indicated that I may ultimately switch brands (even though we have facilitated 8 desktop/laptop purchases with our family members) because I am SO frustrated but willing to give it a try. Dell should consult this forum as the consumers here are representative of a large sample I bet.
 
So, many of you with the whole no AC charge/battery charge issue, it might just be the motherboard. I ran a download file from the Dell site which confirmed this. $378 for a replacement for a system only 15 months old is far better than $1000-$1300 for a new one for me.
 
Good luck all! 
  • 5160

    10 Posts

    1667

    0

    Posted April 19th, 2006 22:00

    HELP!!  I purchased a new mother board, it worked for a few weeks, but then stopped charging.  We would get an intermittent message that it did not regognize the AC adaptor.  We tried a new adaptor, same problem.  I had Dell replace the motherboard, since it was under the 90 day warranty.  First one has no power coming through it at all, the second one is giving us the same error message.... 

     

    What now?

  • shadesoflife

    1 Message

    1667

    0

    Posted April 21st, 2006 00:00

    Just thought I´d add my voice to the growing complaints re laptops not powering up from the ac adapter. Im having the same problem. Adapter seems to be functioning ok, it lights up when plugged in. The battery also works...but the computer just wont operate from the ac adapter. When connected to the adapter, the three lights on the front of the computer blink intermitently, however no power reaches the computer and as such it wont turn on.....I purchased this computer (5160) around November 2004. From the number of complaints on this forum, it would appear there are faults with these computers, so maybe if enough persons register their complaints Dell could do something about what is obviously not a fluke but a common problem.

    Shadaine

  • BethieAUS

    13 Posts

    1667

    0

    Posted April 23rd, 2006 21:00

    Yet another case here on my end. My Inspiron 2500 is four years old, however, so is it something to be expected the older a computer gets?
  • gmj9803

    8 Posts

    1667

    0

    Posted May 2nd, 2006 13:00

    Dell has a real problem here.  I have an inspiron 8100 and a Latitude Cpx and both are experiencing the same problem described in this forum.  Come on Dell do the right thing.  Offer a recall and fix the problems.  The complaints on this message board are only the tip of the iceberg.  I know of several businesses that are having the same issue.  If something isn't done Dell is going to lose a lot of business.  The 378.00 replacement deal is not a good option.  With computer prices being what they are you could add a little money to boot and have a new, FULL WARRANTY, computer.  You could spend the 378.00 this week and next week have a whole new issue costing more money, and by the time you are finished, you could have bought a new one.  This is obviously not an isolated problem and Dell should take steps to make it right. 

    Message Edited by gmj9803 on 05-05-200606:33 PM

  • jpmpt

    1 Message

    1687

    0

    Posted May 5th, 2006 17:00

    I totally agree with you.  I am having the same problem with my laptop nspiron 8600.  I can not use my computer because my motherboard maybe defective according to a customer rep I spoke today.  However, I am being charged $499 plus apllicable tax ($540 total), which is higher than what I just read in this forum.  That's for shipping, motherboard replacement cost and labor. Dell should fix the problem for free since I begin to suspect that this is a common problem and, therefore it maybe a factory defect and necessitates recall and free replacement.  I bought my computer late 2004 and I can't understand how it just stopped working when I am very good about care and order especially of all my electronics, which they last forever.   
  • gmj9803

    8 Posts

    1687

    0

    Posted May 5th, 2006 22:00

    I do not recommend the repair. There are a number of post on this board stating they repaired their laptop only to have it fail again in a short while.  Until Dell comes up with a permanent fix, repairs are useless, and at $500 plus a throw it's just not worth it.

    I have seen others on this board advocating a Class Action.  However, I am not interested in anything that gets me a $20.00 check and buys a lawyer a yacht.  We need some regulatory agency to step in and force Dell to fix their product.  If this were an automobile we were talking about with this wide spread problem, NTSA would have been all over this and whatever manufacturer would be recalling vehicles faster than you could say flaming Pinto.  The problem is no one seems to know to whom this matter should be reported in order to get a response.  So, anyone with any ideas please respond.  There are just too many of us with some variation of this issue to let this go.  We are talking about millions of dollars worth of hardware that for all intensive purposes are now paper weights.  Something should be done.  And another thing...I am tired of enj63 telling everyone they should have bought the warranty.  Many of us bought the warranty and a fat-lot-of-good that did.  All warranties expire, and laptops are too expensive to be disposable after only 3-4 years.  (Yes I know many of you lost yours after a much shorter period of time.)  The point is that no warranty is going to give you enough coverage when the problem is recurring.  The warranty will eventually expire and then you're stuck.  You would think we all bought these things at the drive-thru.  Because you all know what they do to you at the drive-thru...if you don't watch Lethal Weapon II ... Sorry for the rant...but I feel better. 

    Message Edited by gmj9803 on 05-05-200606:28 PM

    Message Edited by gmj9803 on 05-17-200604:29 PM

  • f21_six

    3 Posts

    1687

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2006 16:00

    Just think, I blamed my poor wife for neglecting our Inspiron 5160. After I apolgized, she now shares my new laptop. :smileysurprised:
     
    First, my 2 USB ports stopped working (suspecting a soldering problem on the motherboard), then later the intermittant charging issue flared-up.  Thanks to those who post on forums!!! There is absolutely no doubt that the motherboard defect is causing the issue, but what is still at issue is the solution to a $1,200 paperweight.  That system rocked!  You notice I used the past tense. What is the best solution???  New mobo + same design = same problem, right?
     
    Dell, take heed.  I own 2 Inspiron 5100s, 1 dead 5160, and 1 3 week old Inspiron 6400.  I've advocated Dells for their power and price.  Many in my fortune 50 pharma company ask for my advice with respect to purchising desktops and laptops.  We use IBM ThinkPads, but few home users want to fork-out $2,500.  I'm not happy, and on top of that, I am leary about the quality of my 6400.  Overheating 5100s, badly soldered 5160 mobos, and now let's see how long this lasts.  Do I need to find another brand?  Too bad we can't build frankenstein laptops like we can desktops. 
     
    I'm opting to find a smashed-lcd 5160 and replace the mobo myself.  :smileymad:
     
     
  • BethieAUS

    13 Posts

    1687

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2006 00:00

    I bit the bullet, purchased a motherboard off Ebay (correct part #, no worries there) and installed it last night. When I first plugged in my universal adapter (NOT Dell-brand), the laptop immediately began recharging. Within ten minutes, though, it was back to the intermittent charging and then stopped conducting power altogether. So I'm wondering if I should get the appropriate Dell adapter to see if that works with the new mobo, or simply chuck it all in (which I can't really afford to do). I'm seriously turned off Dells, though, and looking to make a Sony Vaio my next computer.
     
    ---
    Inspiron 2500
    Hitachi Travelstar HDD 60GB/7200RPM
     

    Message Edited by BethieAUS on 05-16-200609:03 PM

  • f21_six

    3 Posts

    1001

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2006 18:00

    I purchased my 5160 December 2004.  I have an IBM Thinkpad T42.  It is very nice, very durable, but expensive -- no video card though.  There are many motherboards on Ebay, and I would DIE if $400 was paid for a new mobo and the failure still occurred.
  • trkrechko

    1 Message

    1687

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2006 18:00

    I also purchased a 5160 in late 2004. As of recently it has started giving me that delightful "ac power adapter type cannot be identified" warning and it is not charging. It seems that most, if not all the computers were purchased in late 2004. If anybody else replies in this thread please tell when you purchased the computer because it seems very likely that there was a manufacturing problem with the 5160's and/or some other laptop models. Also, I refuse to pay for a new motherboard out of principal. $378 is not really a deal for having to fix a problem that should never have happened in the first place. Up until recently I have defended Dell against people who have been complaining about their quality. Rest assured I am now on their side. My brother is going to college in the fall and has been looking at new computers. I have successfully convinced him not to get a Dell. He will probably end up getting a Lenovo Thinkpad. I will also probably be looking for a new computer for obvious reasons. I have been looking at Thinkpads, Sonys, and Macs. It will likely be many years before I consider getting another Dell.

    Message Edited by trkrechko on 05-17-200602:45 PM

    Message Edited by trkrechko on 05-17-200602:47 PM