UNSOLVED

papienka

updated

22 years ago

P

papienka

12 Posts

0

6263

January 20th, 2005 00:00

Windows can only see 3GB out of 4GB installed in my XPS Gen4, how to enable the rest?

The amount of memory installed in my system is 4GB, but the amount of memory reported in Task Manager or Control Panel is only 3GB. I'm using Windows 2003 Server Enterprise Edition, but the exact same problem occurs on Windows XP. System cache and other stuff seems to be allocated out of the 3GB pool I'm getting. There is no trace of the missing 1GB anywhere, as if it was simply nonexisting. How to enable the missing 1GB of memory? Is it possible? If not, why is DELL selling workstations with a 4GB option? My configuration is XPS Gen4, Intel P4 3.8GHz + 4GB DDR2 533.
 
  • salucchi

    2 Intern

    •

    275 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 02:00

    Hi,
     
    Check out this white paper from Microsoft. Hope it helps.
     
  • nhel

    175 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 02:00

    have you checked the system BIOS of your computer? check it first if it only detects this amount of memory. And if you only have 3GB of RAM in BIOS, reseat all your memory but drain flea power first before you do it so as to refresh the BIOS. Before you go to Windows, go back to BIOS and clear NVRAM and proceed to Windows. post what ever the result that will happen.
  • papienka

    12 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 02:00

    Thanks for suggestions... unfortunately they don't help to solve my problem.
     
    -- Bios does report 4GB properly installed. Also SiSoft Sandra and other software report that there are apparently 4 x 1GB chips in the slots. Everything seems to be fine with the hardware itself, must be something with Windows.
     
    -- Using the "/3GB" switch actually causes the system to go unstable: freeze and make the screen periodically go black etc. Other switches are related to going beyond 4GB, but I'm just trying to use the 4GB that my 32-bit CPU is supposed to handle... and I don't even aspire to give more than 2GB to a single application, I'd just want the OS to SOMEHOW use all the 4GB it was given, whether by applications or at least file buffers cache etc.
     
    Can DELL please comment on this? I've paid for 4GB, but I only got 3GB ;-).
     
  • volcano11

    2 Intern

    •

    27973 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 18:00

    Yes, you do deserve a comment from Dell explaining this issue and their tech support department should be able to explain it, but you will not likely get any comment from Dell here on this forum because it is a user to user forum.  I have seen this problem reported on other systems (non-Dell) suggesting it may be a Microsoft problem rather than a Dell problem.  When I researched a problem similar to yours a couple of weeks ago, I could find many discussions (on Google groups, for example) stating the problem, but few giving a resolution to the problem.  Installing 4 Gb of RAM on a computer is not common (since in most cases that amount of RAM is overkill), so I suspect it will take some time to figure out how to resolve the issue.  You might try your own search on google or google groups to see if anything else has emerged and you might also press Dell Tech Support to upgrade your support request to a higher level. I'll keep searching for answers as well, but obviously the problem is more internesting to you than it is to me, and I have lots of other stuff to keep me busy.  Nevertheless, if I find something helpful, I'll post it here.

    Steve

  • papienka

    12 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 18:00

    Allright, so far all that I heard from various DELL representatives is a bunch of jokes, such as:

    - My CPU is just "not fast enough" to address 4GB of memory, I should buy Pentium 4 EE. I thought they might have meant EMT64 support, but no, EE doesn't include EMT64, either. It's just a random response to make the customer spend even more money.

    - Pentium 4 EE has more L2/L3 cache and therefore it can address more memory. No comments.

    - My CPU has a 32-bit architecture and therefore WIndows cannot properly report more than 3GB of memory. I guess that's becuase 3 and 32 both start from the same digit ;-).

    - Somehow the fact that 1000 is not same as 1024 explains everything, though we don't know why.

    - Drivers or devices consume 1GB of virtual memory. Although this one actually isn't just as absurd as the previous ones, it seems rather inlikely besides being somebody's blind guess. Anyway, I've seen a 32-bit system reporting 3.5GB of usable memory out of 4GB installed as wlll as some people claiming to have available anywhere between 3.4 and 3.8 GB. All using Windows 2003 EE, same as I'm using with my P4, and none on CPUs with EMT64 support.

    And so on.

    Again, if there's some kind of inherent limitation of this hardware that makes it unable to utilize more than 3GB of memory, why is DELL selling 4 GB configurations, causing customers to spend money unnecessarily?

    Do I deserve a comment from DELL explaining this issue?

     

  • talmy

    1034 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 19:00

    The last (aproximately) 1GB of the 4GB is not accessible with Windows XP or most Linux distributions because memory locations are reserved for memory-mapped peripheral devices such as the display. Some Linux distributions intended for servers, and also the server versions of Windows work around this problem, at a loss in raw performance. I see this dificulty in my Precision Workstation which has 4GB of expensive ECC RAM yet the (Linux) OS only can use 3.2GB of it. So the memory is there, but it is the fault of the OS that it cannot be used.

    For Windows server, you need to add the /PAE switch to the boot.ini entry to recover the memory.

    I would not expect to see the problem fixed in at least the near future for workstations because, except for server use, that amount of memory almost always unnecessary.

    Obviously these systems should be ordered only with 3GB, as you are wasting money with the fourth. Dell does warn, weakly, "The total amount of usable memory available will be less than 4 GB, depending on the actual system configuration."
  • papienka

    12 Posts

    267

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 19:00

    Thank you for your responses. It just sounds unlikely, devices on the bus consuming precisely 1GB of memory, since my system is reporting 3.0 GB, not a single byte more. I have tried adding /PAE as well as /3GB, /4GT and combinations of those, but now that I'm applying it to a clean vanilla install of Windows 2003 Server Enterprise Edition (to eliminate the risk it is a driver issue), it actually does not seem to make the slightest bit of difference whether I boot with this or another set of switches. I also don't have this many devices, after all... it's a plain XPS Gen4 with P4 3.8GHz + 4GB + 2x160 SATA RAID0 + 256MB GeForce 6800 + Audigy 2. I have installed precisely the same OS on a PowerEdge, with a quadruple Xeon and also 4GB and without using any switches I could see as much as 3.5 out of 4GB available to the system... and it's not a EMT64 version of Xeon, no no, just and old 32-bit one.