UNSOLVED

YDroid

updated

19 years ago

Y

YDroid

1 Rookie

•

61 Posts

0

1922

March 25th, 2008 07:00

Celerra NS20 NAS Backup Help Needed

Hi,

We recently bought Celerra NS20, and working on getting rid of our file server by using the NAS. We are running into problems with the backup, please share your knowledge or expereince with me on this.

We are using backup exec as our backup software and also bought NDMP license. We dont want to buy a diffrent tape library and use the existing one that is attached to our backup exec server. Is it possible we can do that?

What we found so far is that NDMP does volume level backup/restore? Is theer a better and easy way to backup the NAS using our existing backup solution?

As per EMC if we use NAS we ll be saving on the hardware/managment cost of the file server. But what i found so far is that we ll have to spend on NDMP licesnse, hardware/managment of CAVA servers, another tape libarary to hookup to our celerra. Please suggest what are our best available options for backup using NAS.

Thanks,
  • YDroid

    1 Rookie

    •

    61 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 08:00

    Thanks for your response, i have some further questions/clarifications to ur answers

    1. If we move to NetBackup or EMC networker where we can have drive sharing (DDS) or 3-way NDMP and use two drives in our tape library one connected to Celerra data mover fro NDMP and other to our backup server. Will the server control the robotics for the drive attached to the celerra?
    What do u recommend as a better option moving to Netbackup or EMC networker?


    3. If we backup by mounting the CIFS shares on the backup server, will we get the compression etc?
  • Rainer_EMC

    6 Operator

    •

    8645 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 08:00

    We are using backup exec as our backup software and
    also bought NDMP license. We dont want to buy a
    diffrent tape library and use the existing one that
    is attached to our backup exec server. Is it possible we can do that?


    Unfortunately Backup Exec unlike its bigger cousins like Netbackup or EMC Networkter cannot do drive sharing (DDS) or 3-way NDMP.

    If your library has multiple tape drives you should be able to wire one tape drive direclty to the Celerra data mover for NDMP and still let the backup server control the robotics and use the other tape drives.

    What we found so far is that NDMP does volume level
    backup/restore?


    yes, NDMP backup is normally volume level (one complete file system) but restore can also be done file-level

    Backup Exec does support DAR/DDAR so on a restore it can quickly position the tape to the position of the file/directory needed.

    Is theer a better and easy way to backup the NAS using our existing backup solution?


    If you dont use multi-protocol (CIFS and NFS) and you're ok with the performance you could also very well do a LAN based backed by just mounting the Celerra's CIFS shares on the backup server

    Actually quite a number of customers do that - its just that NDMP is better and faster
  • dynamox

    11 Legend

    •

    20419 Posts

    •

    87439 Points

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 08:00

    have you researched an option of using 3-Way NDMP ..where you don't have to attach library directly to your NAS unit.
  • Rainer_EMC

    6 Operator

    •

    8645 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 11:00

    1. If we move to NetBackup or EMC networker where we
    can have drive sharing (DDS) or 3-way NDMP and use
    two drives in our tape library one connected to
    Celerra data mover fro NDMP and other to our backup
    server. Will the server control the robotics for the
    drive attached to the celerra?


    actually what you are describing is library sharing - one drive is *always* used by the Celerra and another drive and the robotics is *always* used by the backup server.

    That is pretty basic and even Backup Exec should be able to do that.
    Same for controlling the robotics.

    DDS is dynamic - for example both the Celerra and the backup server are connected to the same tape drives through a FC switch and each drive can be used by both (of course not at the same time)

    What do u recommend as a better option moving to
    Netbackup or EMC networker?


    look at the cost - being employed by EMC I'm obviously biased :-)

    If its just for that reason and you dont need other capabilities I would stick with Backup Exec and try to make library sharing work.

    A Veritas Backup Exec support guy should be able to tell you exactly if its possible.

    If not then some libraries can be partitioned so that they look and act like two libraries.

    3. If we backup by mounting the CIFS shares on the
    backup server, will we get the compression etc?


    Sure - assuming you mean the compression that the tape drives do
  • Rainer_EMC

    6 Operator

    •

    8645 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 11:00

    have you researched an option of using 3-Way NDMP
    ..where you don't have to attach library directly to your NAS unit.


    Backup Exec doesnt support heterogenous 3-way NDMP - i.e. it doesnt have a tape server software implemented on the backup server that could receive NDMP streams over the network and write them to a local tape drive.
  • Rainer_EMC

    6 Operator

    •

    8645 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 14:00

    attached is the NDMP support matrix listing all the NDMP backup packages and their supported capabilities

    1 Attachment

  • dynamox

    11 Legend

    •

    20419 Posts

    •

    87439 Points

    256

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2008 16:00

    i have clients who use my CIFS servers but wanted to go with their own backup strategy. Many of them are using Backup Exec D. They are doing exactly what Rainer is describing. They are mapping the root of the CIFS share to their backup server and then spin it tape/disk/virtual tape. I'll save you some time with one caveat :) ..Backup exec uses port 10000 to communicate to its backup agents, but Celerra uses port 10000 for NDMP so before you decided to backup Celerra make sure to change default port on all of your currently backed up hosts to something other then 10000 as well as change NDMP port in the server configurations. Port 9000 worked just fine.
  • dynamox

    11 Legend

    •

    20419 Posts

    •

    87439 Points

    256

    0

    Posted March 26th, 2008 05:00

    oh yeah ..one more thing. If you also want to backup a consistent copy of your data utilizing snapsure, just schedule a daily snapsure snapshot , connect to that snapshot from Backup exec server after snapshot has been created and back it up to tape/disk. I have one schedule that's all its there for ..it get refreshed everyday simply for backup purposes.
  • Lynn_Ragan

    2 Intern

    •

    18 Posts

    256

    0

    Posted June 4th, 2008 13:00

    oh yeah ..one more thing. If you also want to backup
    a consistent copy of your data utilizing snapsure,
    just schedule a daily snapsure snapshot , connect to
    that snapshot from Backup exec server after snapshot
    has been created and back it up to tape/disk. I have
    one schedule that's all its there for ..it get
    refreshed everyday simply for backup purposes.


    dynamox,

    Can you dive into this response just a little deeper. I'm also trying to serve up checkpoints to a backup exec server. However BE12 is not seeing, nor allowing itself to map the .ckpt folder as a backup source.

    Is there some other step for completing this configuration?
  • cgolight

    3 Posts

    150

    0

    Posted July 24th, 2008 07:00

    Can you dive into this response just a little deeper.
    I'm also trying to serve up checkpoints to a backup
    exec server. However BE12 is not seeing, nor allowing
    itself to map the .ckpt folder as a backup source.

    Is there some other step for completing this
    configuration?


    If I could figure out the answer to this very question I would pretty much be done dealing with my backup issues. I've got a few filesystems that I need to make snapshots of and back up the snapshots, but I can't figure out how to get BE12 (or my NetBackup trial installation) to see the snapshots.

    Any ideas?