UNSOLVED

carolski

updated

18 years ago

C

carolski

1 Message

0

4293

February 8th, 2009 10:00

Selecting Vista or XP for my new Inspiron 1525?

I have pretty much decided on buying a new Inspiron 1525 with 4GB RAM and 320GB HD.  The standard OS with this laptop is Vista Premium.  Because of the 'bad rep' Vista has in the community, I'm debating on whether to spend an extra $150 for the XP downgrade.  If I go with Vista, I would have to upgrade a couple of programs I use regularly so that cost would be a wash.  I wish I could wait for Windows 7, but my current laptop is ancient and limping along with not much life left.  All I want is a usable, stable system! 

I welcome any advice from those who have had to make this decision.  Would you make the same decision if you had to do it all over again?

  • NemesisDB

    2 Intern

    •

    7944 Posts

    225

    0

    Posted February 8th, 2009 14:00

    Are you absolutely positive that the software won't work with Vista?  Most programs will, but you are correct that some definitely won't.  Regardless, if it doesn't work on Vista, it's not going to work on Windows 7 either.  If the cost is a wash, I would get Vista and upgrade the programs.  As long as your upgrading, consider if you can move to a 64bit system as well...

     

    From my own experiances, Vista works fine with good hardware (it's more questionable on my D430 laptop with 2gb ram, integrated gpu, and a 4200rpm drive).  It's more secure and has some nice features.  The only UI elements that I have serious issues with are not having search on the taskbar and the new networking panels.

  • valh

    6 Posts

    225

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2009 18:00

    I'm currently trying to get a Stuido 1535 to work with VISTA 64 -- If only I could have purchased  the "downgrade" for $150.00 - but it wasn't available. 

    1.  Horrible wireless/cable internet connectivity

    After Dell took three months to correct hardware issues, I can only connect to non-secure wireless networks.   I call DELL and they tell me, VISTA 64 isn't compatible with the netgear broadband/ wireless box provided by my cable company.  But they'll be happy to help me set up netgear and any other boxes I might want to connect to -- for a fee   Thankfully, my cable provider gives something DELL has forgotten -- support.  I can connect wireless now -- for no additional charge.  But of course, the connections are slower than with XP and continually drop connections.   If I connect the Studio directly to the box, the connection is faster, but will just hang sometimes. I have to reboot all the machines that use the netgear box, power the netgear box back on and off and then reboot the Studio. -- And just in case you think it might be my cable provider, three other dell laptops and one desktop have none of these issues. - So basically, unless I can find an unsecured wireless, I have no internet access with the Studio 1535.

    2,  Questionable compatibility with games

    The O/S blue screens when playing Spider Solitaire which was installed with the O/S -so I won't even try other games. 

    3.  Limited to no compatibility with open source programs

    Open Office, the open source replacement for Microsoft Word doesn't work with VISTA 64, so I no longer have word processing - until I pay Microsoft.

    4.  DELL is offering no assistance and DELL Support says I should expect issues like this with a new O/S.

    5.  While other manufacturers, like ASUS, are offering their customers the downgrade for free, dell is charging -- and doesn't guarantee the drivers will work with XP.

    I have found a website that has process to remove VISTA 64 and installl XP.  I have paid more than $150.00 downgrade for the license for XP Pro.  If it doesn't work, my Studio 1535 will become a very attractive and expensive paperweight.