UNSOLVED

KHecker

updated

22 years ago

K

KHecker

1 Rookie

•

10 Posts

0

3703

July 1st, 2004 14:00

Never try to load XP professional over XP home

I learned something the hard way a couple months ago.  Fortunately it was a friend who suffered the consequences, and not me.  She wanted to have XP professional on her Dell laptop, but didn't want to pay the additional $79 to have it loaded by Dell.  She had an "archival copy" disc of the Thai version of XP professional, and tried to install that over XP home.  This totally messed up the installation (NOTE: I did not originally use the word "messed" in this message, but Dell's system wouldn't allow the original, and very commonly used, word), and Dell's outsourced tech support couldn't figure out how to fix it, even with trying to recover with the Dell software.  They finally had her send the computer back, and sent her another one.  Whether she ever got XP professional installed, I do not know.  I learned from this to order XP professional with my M60 notebook.

Has anyone else noticed that there isn't an upgrade path from XP home to XP professional?  When I upgraded my desktop, I had to get out my ancient Win NT 4.0 disc, and use that as the qualifier.  Everything went perfectly after that.  What is the rationale for not allowing an upgrade from XP home to XP pro?

 

 

 

Message Edited by KHecker on 07-01-2004 08:50 AM

  • Denny Denham

    2 Intern

    •

    18798 Posts

    377

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2004 14:00

    KHecker,

    Although the vast majority of the regular contributors to this forum strongly recommend a clean install rather than an upgrade from any operating system to another, there is a legitimate upgrade path from XP Home to XP Pro. However, Microsoft, in its wisdom, has not created an upgrade path from "an "archival copy" disc of the Thai version" (which sounds suspiciously like a pirated copy).

    Message Edited by Denny Denham on 07-01-2004 08:59 AM

  • KHecker

    1 Rookie

    •

    10 Posts

    377

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2004 17:00

    Denny,

    I'm just saying that when I bought my upgrade to XP Pro, XP Home was not listed as an upgrade qualifier (Win 98SE and Win NT 4.0 were), and the installation program told me it couldn't find a qualifier on my computer, even though XP Home was installed.  That is why I've kept my Win 3.1 floppies and Win NT 4.0 disks around all these years.  I use them to prove to MS that I am indeed a registered owner.  Up until my M60 Dell, I've only had one computer at a time, and paid for every copy of Windows I install.

    Yes, my first clue that my Thai friends have software of questionable origin is that the jewel box liner is printed on a bad inkjet printer, and the title is written on the disc with a Sharpie.  Their culture seems to find all this acceptable.  I often throw little digs at them about this, especially when the pirated software messes them up, and they wonder why.   I have to wonder if there is more than one purchased copy of Windows in all of Thailand 

  • Denny Denham

    2 Intern

    •

    18798 Posts

    377

    0

    Posted July 1st, 2004 19:00

    KHecker,

    XP Home is listed as a qualifying operating system here. I can't explain its performance on your system.