UNSOLVED

Fatsmalloy

updated

17 years ago

F

Fatsmalloy

15 Posts

0

24299

November 4th, 2009 19:00

Censorship?? You decide.

I have had the same post deleted now 3-4 times.  Each time I received the email stating that in some way I had violated the Terms of Service Agreement that I consented to.  And each time I edited the content of the post as to conform to Dells policies.  Robert p finally got back to me and said that it was because I used a term that is filtered by the system (I am told I can't post the two words but they are the equivalent of legal counsel employed and revered by each state).  If you think about it you can figure out what those two words are.  I typed them in the search box of Dell Community and low and behold pages of post that go back as far as 2004 have them in there.  I feel that I am being singled out and being censored because of my particular problem with Dell.  They do not want you to know what has happened to me!  If someone from Dell is reading this then please explain to me this inconsistency that is so obviously blatent?

  • hrova

    2 Intern

    •

    2242 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 4th, 2009 21:00

    Dell Forums began using automated filters earlier this year (I think that was when).  Posts before the automated filters may have had some TOS violations slip by, thus the automated filter to avoid that. I suspect the posts you refer to are are older than the automated filter, and that it is not singling any one or any viewpoint out.

    I posted a link for you yesterday to review the TOS.

    Also, there was a known situation of a Windows update causing a blue screen which is why Dell recommended you turn off the automatic updates until Microsoft resolved that issue.  It seems like a reasonable troubleshooting measure. If you didn't get the blue screen without using the updates, that would indicate a software issue, and not a hardware warranty issue.

    Hope this explanation helps.....

    EDIT: I looked it up, and the most recently I found that disallowed phrase was in April of 2007... Maybe they've had the autmatic filters longer than I thought, but the point remains the same....

  • Fatsmalloy

    15 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 4th, 2009 22:00

    Thank you for your posts.  And i have reviewed the TOS many times.  But I have disabled updates several times and it doesn't help, and Dell should have had a disclaimer at time of sale that said they would not gurauntee the compatability of their preinstalled software with the hardware of the system.  I didn't buy a computer with an OS that cannot be used as the OS manufaturer recommends.  I just don't see why Dell doesn't get that.  By the way everytime that my wife calls Dell for technical support they turn the updates back on reinstalling many updates, then I have to try to figure out which one is causing the Blue Screen.  This makes me question the effectiveness of Dell's technical training. 

    I understand that the posts that refered to legal counsel may have been before the dissallowed phrase but it was very easy for me to find them and I am an amatuer at the computer.  If they haven't gone back and deleted those post it just doesn't jive. 

    To recap: I didn't get what I paid for and there are inconsistentcies in Dell's censorship practices.  And from what I have been told there is more than one update that are causing the problems (if you want to look at it that way but I prefer to look at it as the incompatible hardware that is factory installed on here).

  • hrova

    2 Intern

    •

    2242 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 01:00

    "And from what I have been told there is more than one update that are causing the problems ."

    It is either a hardware problem or software problem. Dell does not warrant against software problems. Dell or any  manufacturer cannot and therefore do not guarantee their systems sold will work once changes  (which Windows Updates are) in the software are made.

    Regarding the forum TOS,  any one that has posted since the automated filters has exactly the same rules as you. It is not anything censoring just you, though since they own theese forums, they would be within their rights to do so. Crying wolf does not help your cause.

    To recap: Until you troubleshoot (including removing the chance that Windows Updates are causing the problem) and show you have a hardware issue, which it sounds like you have been unwilling to do, there is no evidence that you did not get what you paid for, as software issues are not part of your warranty. Nor is there any reason to believe  that Dell is censoring you.

    Since they have offered a replacement machine (as stated in another post of yours), enjoy it. If you have problems not covered by your warranty, please repost in a new thread in these forums asking for help. I am guessing someone can and will help you.

     

  • Fatsmalloy

    15 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 06:00

    Have you read my post about the original poblem?  I have been trouble shooting and have tried everything that Dell has recommended.  I have been most resonable but when you are told by almost each and every technician (with the exception of the last two) that  the problem is something different each time then you can understand the frustration as none seemed to know what to do.  I understand there is no software warranty but of course Dell is going to say it's the software!  I mean with them knowing about this issue they still lied to me and tryed to make me believe that it was one of my personal programs. What about the fact that the hardware is not compatible.  We are seeing things from both sides here.  Is the glass half empty of half full?. 

    So if you read me original post as you stated you have then you know I have done everything Dell has asked but what if Microsoft decides to release some really important updates that are essential for my laptops health and safety?  What then ? Just go along outdated because Dell's hardware will not take updates?  That is a horrible option and one that Dell recommends.  By the way there is no need to wave in my face that Dell can kick me off of here at any time.  Once again I have read the TOS and recognize that they have total sovereingty in these forums.  So there is no need for the "oh, they have the right to kick you off..." just because I question their support tactics.

    I hope I will enjoy the not replacement but "refurbished replacement" machine, but they will not send a conformation email regarding it's status.

    Thanks for your help!

  • PRT940

    21 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 07:00

    I had a similar problem last week.  I inadvertently used an "illegal" word in a post.  The word itself would be welcome in any G-rated children's movie, so when the post was removed later, I had no idea why.  But I discovered that if you "preview" (using the Preview tab) a message you are composing, the "illegal" words will be replaced with asterisk characters.  So there is a way to check before you post if your message might inadvertently contain a "bad" word. 

    Other than asking Dell to "fix" the filtering software to allow these tame words, about all we can do as users is to "preview" every message we send.  :emotion-2:

  • hrova

    2 Intern

    •

    2242 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 07:00

    "Dell has asked but what if Microsoft decides to release some really important updates that are essential for my laptops health and safety?"

    I don't know how you can expect Dell to fix a Microsoft update.

    I never said there was a compatibility issue with hardware, though if you used a wrong download or driver, there may have been. By reinstalling Vista and leaving automatic updates off, it would have given a chance to troubleshoot and  determine if it was an update issue. Refusing to do so was not doing every troubleshooting step they asked, and in this case, it sounds like a key step.

    That Dell is replacing the machine not knowing if it is a hardware or software issue is going above and beyond what they need to do. It is unfortunate that you don't see that.

    Regardless, since the machine is being replaced for you, I am unsure what more you want. Enjoy it.

     

  • Fatsmalloy

    15 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 11:00

    Did you not read the posts?  I have reinstalled Vista many times and disabled the updates.  After about the 4th-6th time I bet you would get frustrated too.  Put yourself in the customer's shoes.  That is what any reputible company would have done.  With the service and attitudes I have received from Dell support it is no wonder they are always on the hot seat. 

    By the way I never said that you said there were compatability issues.  Two guys, one from tech support and another from customer resolutions, have confirmed that Dell's drivers/hardware will not work with Vista updates.  And I have never asked them to fix Microsoft just their (Dell) inadequate drivers/hardware.

  • Fatsmalloy

    15 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 11:00

    Thanks a lot!  That is the only useful bit of information that I have gotten from this situation.  That was so simple you would think that Dell would have told me that.

  • hrova

    2 Intern

    •

    2242 Posts

    804

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 12:00

    Thank you to the poster who confirmed that Dell's filters are not singling out fatsmalloy... As I said, they are automated and therefore would be fair to all.

    fatsmalloy: I did read your post - or the ones that have stayed up, as many appear to violate the TOS.

    Here is what you said regarding automatic updates:

    "...and that I needed to turn off automatic updates. YOU HAVE TO BE KIDDING ME!!!!! I paid to be able to use this hardware and preinstalled software without having to turn on options that the OS provider recommends. I did not pay for a system that would only work if I didn't want to update it. I realize that Microsoft has responsibility here as well but Dell is the retailer that trusted Microsoft enough to put Vista on a computer that has drivers that are incompatable with it. Finally I got Srdnir on the phone and told him that I know that it is their hardware and their software that are incompatable and I was not getting off the phone until I was satified woth the result."

    While it was difficult to read due to thje lack of formatting, nowhere did I see any mention that you actually attempted that suggestion. It sounded like you got indignant at the suggestion and did  not attempt it.

    You also said you wanted Dell to fix their inadequate drivers. Since you'd had this machine for two yeas with workable drivers, it is not a Dell driver issue. They provided you with working drivers.

    Regardless, since Dell is replacing your machine, so enjoy that... It sounds as if you are not clear on the warranty terms regarding software issues and do not appreciate the fact that Dell is going above and beyond in this situation to help you out.

  • hrova

    2 Intern

    •

    2242 Posts

    503

    0

    Posted November 5th, 2009 21:00

    No where did you post you had previous problems. In fact, you stated you had a trouble free two years before the recent problems.I have no idea what  "1 driver that burnt out and 2 refurbished ones that gave me blue screens" means, as drivers are software items. I have never heard of a refurbished driver or one burning out.

    Regardless, enjoy whatever machine you get....