UNSOLVED

chatty2k5

updated

22 years ago

C

chatty2k5

4 Posts

0

10122

March 11th, 2005 14:00

Western Digital 80Gb click sound on Dell 700m

Hi,

I just got my brand new dell 700m with a western digital 80gb hard disk. Similar to another user on the dell forums, I am hearing periodic tick-tock sounds, repeated every second or so. I know this is coming from the hard disk, and atleast one other person is experiencing the same problem with the same disk.

The clicking does stop occasionally, for example after running the dell diagnostics test on the hard drive, but usually only until the next boot up. It might be a configuration issue (improper power mode, faulty data cable?) or possibly is just a hard disk with problems. It does however seem to pass all tests and read/write data normally.

Could someone advice me on what I should try next? I do not want to use the laptop as my primary machine until I clear this up.

Thanks.
~Chad
  • 1062

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2005 15:00

    I am having a similar problem. I purchased the Dell Inspiron 5150 back in August, and recently I already had to replace the hard-drive because it crashed and I lost everything. About a month ago I received a new hard-drive in the mail and I just reinstalled it and Windows again about a week or so ago. Now, since I have had this new hard-drive every now and then when it wants to it makes this "KNOCK" noise. It's almost the same kind of noise as when you put your tongue on the roof of you mouth and make that knocking/smacking noise. I do not understand why it is making this noise, how it is making this noise, and whether or not it is an okay thing or not. Please help me understand what it is that is making the noise, and how I can fix this problem. It bothers me that it makes this noise, and as I am writing this message it also knocked again. I do know that it is coming from around the hard-drive location on my laptop, and I figured it was the hard-drive only because my laptop has never made this noise before. So I am in the same shoes as you "chatty." Someone please help us.
  • i4c

    11 Posts

    1062

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2005 21:00

    hi,
    i, too, have a western digital hdd that makes clicking noises in my 700m  and after going thru the tech support, I did the same thing, the diagnostic tool and like yours, it quit, until i rebooted and now it is doing it again.
    If you find out the answer, please be sure to share! :)
  • JC74

    61 Posts

    1062

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2005 06:00

    I just bought a 80GB Western Digital for my I8100 (probably the same model that you have) and it also clicks every second or so. 
     
    It's kind of depressing since they claim to be the quietest 2.5" hard drive on the market.  I'm thinking of trying a new one to see if it does the same thing.  Keep us posted.
  • chatty2k5

    4 Posts

    1062

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2005 12:00

    I emailed Dell support, and supposedly they will ship a new hard drive this week. I'll wait to see if the new one is any better.

    At this point, it appears likely that it is a problem with a whole batch of hard disks.

    ~Chad
  • JC74

    61 Posts

    1062

    0

    Posted March 14th, 2005 14:00

    Wrong thread.

    Message Edited by JC74 on 03-14-2005 10:57 AM

  • omatary

    10 Posts

    1062

    0

    Posted March 19th, 2005 21:00

    Me too. I had this problem , and the tech support told me they will send me a new Westren Digtai hard drive. Well, They sent me a refurbished non-Westren Digital drive. I did not install the re-furbished hard drive and decided to return the 700m.

     

  • nebgator

    8 Posts

    1069

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2005 02:00

    I had the same problem (WD 80 GB) noise in my 2 weeks old 700m. I called the techservice, and they sent me a pre-loaded Fujitsu HD.. wow!!  what a difference maker, faster and quiter... I do not have that annoying clicking noise now... 
    FYI....
  • JC74

    61 Posts

    1069

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2005 04:00

    I also sent back my Western Digital 80GB because of the clicking and got a Seagate Momentus 100GB hard drive.

    The Momentus is VERY quiet and fast!  I can't believe how much faster my computer boots and my programs run with this thing.  They either need to recall the WD Scorpios or put out some drivers.  There's no excuse for claiming they're the quietest on the market when so many people are having this problem.

  • nebgator

    8 Posts

    1069

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2005 13:00

    Yes, it seems like they have a problem with Western Digital HDs.. May be they are just following the foot steps of Hitachi...
    BTW, how did you get 100GB for a replacement drive when you sent back 80GB? Did you have to pay the difference, or you got the Seagate somewhere else.?
  • JC74

    61 Posts

    511

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2005 05:00

    I got my drives through newegg.com.   They're about the cheapest around other than eBay.