UNSOLVED

MikeTheChemist

updated

21 years ago

0

8390

January 10th, 2006 12:00

SATA Interface vs Max transfer rate

When I purchased a Dell E510 on a budget, I skimped on the hard drive.  It came with one 80GB Wester Digital SATA Drive (WD800JD), which has a Serial ATA 150 Interface.
 
I'd like to upgrade now, and I'm trying to decide if I should buy the same size/type drive and try a RAID configuration, or if I should just replace it with one or more larger hard drives.  There are other Western Digital models that appear to have different Interface & transfer rates, so I am wondering what would be the best for my E510?  I have read that the Interface is backwards-compatible, but I don't want to waste money on something I may not perform better on my particular system.
                            Max Transfer Rate
Interface               (Buffer to host)
Serial ATA150                     150 Mb/s
SATA 300 MB/s                   300 Mb/s
 
Serial ATA150                     1.5 Gb/s
  • 540

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2006 12:00

    I accidentally posted that first message before I was done (Oops!)...

    This is what I was trying to type before I accidentally hit tab and Enter...

    Western Digital                                 Max Transfer Rate      Rotational
     Family / Model        Interface                (Buffer to host)          Speed     
    Cavier SE
                        JD        Serial ATA150          150 Mb/s               7,200 RPM
                        JS        SATA 300 MB/s       300 Mb/s                7,200 RPM
    Raptor
               GD, AHFD    Serial ATA150          1.5 Gb/s              10,000 RPM

    The E510 has two on-board SATA connectors.  Can I use any of the models listed above?  Would I see a benifit in performance if I get a SATA 300 MB/s, which is less $$ than the Raptor? 

     

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    540

    0

    Posted January 10th, 2006 12:00

    The limiting factor for all 7200 rpm drives is not the interface - it's the spin speed. Even the 10,000 rpm Raptor will deliver in the 70s (MBps wise) max. Although RAID0 should theoretically double that, it doesn't - for desktop use it makes very little difference.

    In other words, SATA150 is fine for anything you can use on the desktop. For that matter, so is ATA100.