UNSOLVED

fsx

updated

20 years ago

F

fsx

67 Posts

0

12496

August 21st, 2006 13:00

New Hard Drive questions

I'm looking to purchase a new hard drive for my Dimension 8300.

Right now, I have two IDE drives, 120 and 20gigs. The 120 is at 5400 RPM, and the 20 gig, being at least 8 years old is probably a lot worse. My choices are between an IDE Ultra ATA100 drive, the Western Digital 80gig 7400 RPM and the Western Digital 160GB 7200 RPM SATA drive. Obviously the SATA is a little more expensive. Would there be a big performance benefit over using the SATA than the IDE? Also, does the 8300 have SATA cables inside, or would I have to purchase some sort of adapter or cable?

Thanks.

Message Edited by fsx on 08-21-200610:23 AM

  • kjharris

    428 Posts

    546

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2006 15:00

    I doubt that you would notice any speed difference with the SATA drive. While the 8300 came with connections for SATA drives, you would have to buy the cable(I think you need one with right angle connectors). Also, if you add a SATA drive, the 8300 defaults to the SATA drive as the boot drive so if you wanted to keep your original drive as the boot drive you will need to do a bit of configuration work. The easiest thing to do would be to replace the 20 gb drive with the new IDE(PATA) drive.

    Ken
  • fsx

    67 Posts

    546

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2006 15:00

    I found these hard drives, can you recommend one based on price and performance?

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822144118

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822148103

    Thanks.

    Message Edited by fsx on 08-21-200601:28 PM

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    546

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2006 17:00

    You can use either PATA or SATA drives; there's no difference in performance excepting the WD Raptor 10,000 rpm units.

    You'll need a SATA data cable if you buy a bare drive. A retail SATA drive kit will come with one.
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    546

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2006 20:00

    fsx

    Both the WD Ultra ATA100 shown, seem to be identical, therefore either drive, should work fine in your D-8300 system. 

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822144118

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822148103

    Bev.

  • riell

    7 Posts

    546

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2006 22:00

    actually the difference between the sata and pata is the way the data is being stored,  there's different type of configuring sata and one of the configuration may have the same speed as the pata but on other configurations you can increase the data transfer that you will  get in using SATA as compared to PATA.
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    546

    0

    Posted August 21st, 2006 23:00

    The fact that both drives spin at the same 7200 rpm has an overwhelming effect - the rate at which data spins onto or off the platters is far lower than either ATA or SATA can support.

    In the real world, there's no difference.

    If you want a faster drive, you have to increase the spin rate. So far only Western Digital has brought 10,000 rpm to SATA - the other two major makers (Seagate and Hitachi) have SCSI drive businesses to protect. So far they've limited desktop drives to 7200 rpm. WD, having no such business to protect, has pushed them to 10,000 rpm.

    So far no one has brought 15,000 rpm to the desktop - but I'd expect WD to be working on that.