UNSOLVED

smr

updated

20 years ago

S

smr

64 Posts

0

7315

June 2nd, 2006 00:00

i9100: Upgrade to 100GB/7200rpm 2.5". Which is best, Hitachi or Seagate? [Clicking?]

Hi All,

I want to upgrade to a 100GB 7200rpm (2.5") harddrive and am tossing up between the Hitachi 7K100 and Seagate Momentus 7200.1, and am wondering which is better. Performance and power usages seems pretty close for both, but it's the potential clicking noise that seems to plaugue Hitachi's that I'm concerned about, particularly for a laptop needed to be used in a very quiet environment.

It seems there may be several different clicking problems being reported. One is periodic, perhaps every 10 seconds, and seems to be fixable with a firmware patch from Dell (at least for the 100GB models).

The clicking noise I'm familiar with in drives is in workstations and is a constant ticking that seems to relate to track-to-track seeking. It's at the rate of popcorn popping in a microwave. I don't know if this is something that can be fixed.

There are tools available from Hitachi for changing acoustic and power management settings (always at the expense of performance) but I wonder if this will make the difference that I will need if I find the Hitachi to be noisy.

Regards,

Steven
  • VBdotNet

    415 Posts

    275

    0

    Posted June 2nd, 2006 01:00

    I have the Hitachi Travelstar E7K100 100GB in my iXPS. It originally came with Hitachi's 60 GB hard drive. I like the E7K100 very much.
  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    275

    0

    Posted June 2nd, 2006 10:00

    Hitachi notebook drives are faster than Seagates; Seagate's are quieter and in general, more reliable.