UNSOLVED

harwayharry

updated

16 years ago

0

1231

December 3rd, 2010 21:00

Dimension E520 - Replacement Upgrade Drive Needed - Any Actual Experiences out There? And Some Advice re Specific Drives Please

I have a problematic original drive (WD 320GB) on the dual core E520 which showed some bad read on tests and wouldn't perform/boot. After failing with a factory repair of windows XP (presumably because of the bad drive sectors) I tried re-formatting and partitioning and got it to work (variably) and I now need a replacement. I also have a second drive installed (Seagate 80GB) together with 2 DVDRs.  The motherboard does not match the manual and specs I was provided and when I rang Dell they said that different motherboards were installed on different PCs !!?? - so I don't know what I've got. It has 4 SATA ports and the drives are on 0 & 4 with the DVDRs on 4 & 5.  Manual says 0,2,3, 4 should be present.

I have spent some considerable time today reviewing posts on the motherboard/drive configuration Q&As throughout these forums and am confused about what I can/can't do and whether there is actual experience out there rather than just opinion. Almost every thread seems to end with advice from somebody (non-Dell) with no follow through by the member on what actually worked or didn't.   So is there some real advice based on experience please? - I don't want to stuff this up.

I had a 3 year Dell warranty/service arrangement which expired a few months ago (without having been accessed for over 2 years) - then the trouble started of course. Now I can't even submit a request by email for accurate information about the differences between my documentation and what was delivered, because my warranty has expired - really annoying - good one Dell!!  Even worse, I can't get the links in the relevant "announcement" to work.

Anyways, as I have external drives I don't need huge internal capacity and was thinking of a 500-750GB drive, either combined with the existing healthy Seagate 80GB, or on stand alone. I fancy the following as prospects that seem to have good specs and won't break the bank.  Would also appreciate advice on whether these drives might do the job on this motherboard. I've had good experiences with Seagate & Samsung drives and bad with a couple of WDs. Here is my current shortlist:

1. 3.5" Samsung 500GB Spinpoint F3 7200rpm SATA11 3.0GB 16MB Cache - 3yr warranty

2. 3.5" Samsung 750GB Spinpoint F3 7200rpm Sata11 3.0GB 32MB Cache - 3yr  warranty

3. 3.5" Hitachi 500GB Ultrastar A7K2000 7200rpm Sata11 3.0Gb 32MB Cache - 5yr warranty

The Hitachi is dearer than the other two but appears to have some extra reliability factors, although it is a bit slower - which probably wouldn't worry me much.

 

Will truly appreciate any advice and will be extra pleased to hear from someone who has actually done this exercise before.

 

 

No Responses