UNSOLVED

yobri

updated

22 years ago

Y

yobri

61 Posts

0

9414

March 8th, 2005 05:00

Dell Inspiron 700m - periodic ticking noise, possibly hard drive

I've read the numerous threads of others that have had similar problems, but the 700m that I got TODAY has a Western Digital HD that may be the culprit ticking sound. Whenever the machine is idle, the ticking begins a few seconds or so between ticks (and not in a uniform manner). Sounds similar to a watch. But when I am running the computer with a heavy process (in this case, I am now running Dell diagnostics via the F12 start and the ticking sounds cannot be heard).

I've read that the Hitachi drives had a firmware update that aided in alleviating the ticking sound that was so prevalent with many user drives.

I'd like to know what recommendations that I may receive from board members before I have to contact tech support and deal with the hassle of possibly having to send my unit back. :(

Thanks in advance.
  • Rollie_R

    2 Intern

    •

    2248 Posts

    327

    0

    Posted March 8th, 2005 14:00

    yobri,
     
    The ticking has been heard with many Hitachi drives.  I do not remember another case with a Western Digital drive.  Please finish the diagnostics, and if the noise continues, then contact Technical Support.
     
  • m3l

    28 Posts

    327

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2005 03:00

    when the HD ticks to death, they will swap it under warranty.. then they ship you another one which eventually again ticked itself to death under the same mysterious circumstances within about the same short space of time, they are not about to investigate the problem.. some techs won't even acknowledge that there is an issue.. all they would do is to offer to sell you another potential lemon.. and then proceed to forcibly close your case..

    if you're out of warranty, you're out of luck.. two back to back HD failures in three years.. Dell will not investigate.. they will not tell me what the problem was.. just to assume it was due to my "customer usage profile".. despite dozens and dozens of similar complaints in this their very own forum..

    obviously i asked them, since two HDs failed in 3years, on what basis would any idiot want to buy another potential lemon from Dell? after a break of two weeks, they came back with a 'final offer' to buy another HD from Dell and declared my case 'closed'!

    customer 'support' and 'service'? please tell me another joke..

     

    Message Edited by m3l on 03-08-2005 11:34 PM

  • TimW_of_NY

    92 Posts

    327

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2005 14:00

    While a hard drive shouldn't be completely silent, it shouldn't make a very noticeable sound either.

    From my experience, I only get ticking hard drives when they're really old. I replaced the hard drive in my 300m once the 60 gig 7200 rpm Hitachi drive was available (bought from Dell as well). And I've never experienced any ticking before or after.

    Tim
  • 327

    0

    Posted March 25th, 2005 22:00

    I have a WD drive and it too is making the exact same sound about every 2-3 seconds when there is no machine activity. When drive is working, its fine, I appears to be just when it start to move the head.
  • yobri

    61 Posts

    327

    0

    Posted March 28th, 2005 14:00

    Just to follow-up, I got a another HD sent as a replacement to me. It was a Fujitsu 60GB 5400 and the VERY annoying clicking sound has now disappeared. Seems it was a defective WD drive, so any of you that have the same problems with the WD drive it's time to call up tech support and get your replacement.
  • almer

    64 Posts

    327

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2005 16:00

    Same here. I had WD driv e replaced with Fujitsu drive and my 700m as quiet as it could be. I guess Dell had a "bad luck" with WD drive batch.

    Dell was just great about the replacement. Got new drive in no time and it came preloaded with all the soft.