I have an Optiplex 5060 SFF that I would like to re-purpose as a NAS. This unit has a PCIe x16 and x4 slot. Can I install PCIe adapters that support 2 NVMe drives into these slots? I do not believe this unit supports PCIe bifurcation?
It's not clear to me if the M.2 slot on the motherboard supports a stand-alone NVMe SSD, meaning non- Optane. Assuming it does I'd put a NVMe SSD in there first (you might need to come up with a "hold down" screw to secure the end of SSD if the 5060 SFF didn't come with the hardware for that.) The motherboard's M.2 slot may be bootable since the BIOS is aware of it, but it isn't clear from the documentation.
I'd consider whether you ever want to upgrade the wired ethernet capabilities of the 5060 SFF beyond it's native 1 GbE (max transfer speeds ~100 MB/s). Same with its wireless capabilities. If so, you might want to reserve the PCIe x4 slot for a add-in card for that.
The PCIe 3 x4 slot can be used to add one NVMe SSD with a simple add-in card for this. These cards are usually $20 or less. (Whether a NVMe SSD on the card would be bootable I'm not sure.) Using this as a data drive should not be an issue. Obviously, the card would need to be low profile and fit into the SFF case.
Regarding the PCIe 3 x16 slot - I see no mention of bifurcation settings in the BIOS, so I assume it doesn't have this.
With the PCIe 3 x16 slot you have two general options:
1) Get a simple PCIe 3 x4 NVMe SSD card like I suggested above for the x4 slot. This will allow you to add one NVMe SSD. There should be no issue using it as a data drive, as a boot drive uncertain.
2) Add a PCIe 3 x16 or x8 Switch card with either 2 or 4 NVMe SSD slots. Again, it would have to be low profile and the length of the card would need to fit within the SFF chassis. These cards can be obtained for around $100-150. Again, data drive no issue, booting uncertain.
I'm using a PCIe Switch card in a different Dell that has no bifurcation settings. It's totally transparent to the PC. Most PCIe 3 Switch cards are based on PLX PEX8747 or ASM2824 chips.
The M.2 slot on the motherboard does support a stand-alone drive, as that was what I was using for the OS on the PC previously. I would again throw an M.2 in there as the boot drive. I would use the x4 slot and throw in either a 4 port 1 gig network adapter(Intel I350) or 4 port 2.5 gig network adapter. I would use the onboard NIC as the mgmt NIC and the 4 port adapter would allow NAS data to traverse to the network. As to the x16 slot I did not know about PCIe 3 switch cards. I will look into this asap.
Some of the 4 slot low profile cards have 2 SSD slots on the front of the PCB and 2 on the back. The 2 SSD slots on the back of the card can cause spacing issues with an adjacent PCIe card. M.2 NVMe SSDs may need heatsinks, which adds to this potential issue. There are some 2 slot low profile cards with slots only on the front of the PCB or another possibility is to just not populate the 2 slots on the back of a 4 slot card.
There is a known potential issue with ASM2824 based cards where they can be unstable under write load if there is only one SSD in the device. This is not an issue as long as the card is populated with 2 or more SSDs. What system configuration or whatever causes this doesn't seem clear.
I'm using a QNAP QM2-4P-384 Quad PCIe SSD card which is low profile and has all 4 M.2 NVMe SSD slots on the front of the card. It's an x8 card, but the switch spreads the load between any and all SSDs across all 8 lanes to/from the host. It uses a ASM2824 chip. It's in an old PCIe Gen 2 PC slot and, maybe because of that, has the one SSD write stress stability issue. I can reproduce it by doing CrystalDiskMark write tests. And I can confirm it goes away by adding a second SSD. Picked it up cheap so I can't complain.
@SteveFP , Low profile cards PCIe Gen 3 Switch cards with dual M.2 NVMe SSD slots that are readily available with easy returns (for example, shipped from Amazon itself) for just over $150 include (both are ASM2824 based and almost the same design):
There are also combo cards out there that do dual SSDs and one or more ethernet ports. Usually more expensive than the same functionality in separate cards and modularity is lost (like ability to upgrade only the ethernet in the future). Also, some of them cut costs by internally using a less capable PCIe Switch chip - usually electrically/physically supporting less PCIe lanes on the card (like x4 instead of x8 or x16). But, a PCIe Switch is not bifurcation so all the host upstream bandwidth is shared but available to all devices (SSDs and ethernet ports) and PCIe is duplex. For example, see QNAP QM2-2P2G2T - 2 x PCIe Gen3 M.2 NVMe SSD & 2 x 2.5GbE port expansion card, which is a PCIe 3 x4 card. I think it's around $180.
The low profile 2 drive cards seem more readily available, so I will end up installing two 4TB M.2 SSDs and run RAID 1. The full height 4 SSD cards will not fit in the 5060. I will end up upgrading my CPU from an i3 8100 to a i7 8700. The 8700s are really cheap now, and if I need more CPU power down the road I can install the gen 9 CPUs. I am going to put a four port 2.5 gig network adapter in, as it will run on a x4 PCIe slot. I will LACP all ports up to the switch, so in essence getting 10 gig.
I am all set and ready to go. This is replacing my Synology DS718, which is over 5 years old. While I love the Synology its older than the 5060 CPU and memory wise, so I am gaining a huge upgrade. With the 4 port network card my data will fly across my network!
@SteveFP , have you considered Mellanox 2-port 10GbE NICs like the ConnectX-3 EN. $60 or so, I believe. They're PCIe 3 x8, but since the PCIe x4 slot in the 5060 SFF seems to be open ended this shouldn't be a problem. Note all the bandwidth of dual 10 Gbe will fit into PCIe 3 x4, and the NIC will auto negotiate from x8 to x4.
You could hook up one of the NIC's two 10 GbE ports to an unmanaged ethernet switch with at least one 10 GbE port - same NAS bandwidth as you're talking about above (4 x 2.5 GbE). In the meantime, you'd have an extra 10 GbE port available. And, now or in the future, you'd have the option to use LACP with dual 10 GbE on a managed 10 GbE ethernet switch that has LACP.
@SteveFP , it's my understanding that LACP will only give you total non-aggregated bandwidth (4 x 2.5 Gb). Meaning individual endpoint devices will be limited to 2.5 Gb - LACP just lets you have 4 endpoints at that speed at the same time.
Regarding LACP, it isn't clear exactly which dual 10 GbE NIC models support it. Probably have to delve into the NIC or NIC's chipset specs.
In reviewing everything 80% of my network is 1 gig and I am not saturating that. I am going to leave well enough alone. I am going to put a 4 port intel I350 card in the x4 slot. I am going to create two 2 port bonds(2 gig each), as I plan on two different data streams. One will be normal data and the second will be iSCSI data, as I am using that on the current Synology NAS.
When I am ready to upgrade to 10 gig then I will do it all at that time. This saves me significant cost that I just cannot justify right now. My biggest bottleneck is my Internet, which is gig right now.
@Techgee I have had poor results trying to install a lan adapter on a nvme to PCIE adapter.
I figured it was because I have a xx60 3060 and 5060 OptiPlex micro.
Can you confirm a working adapter? I want to move a video card into a printed case for optiplex micro for steam deck setup and another as a dedicated UNRAID local AI machine.
Techgee
2 Intern
•
623 Posts
0
0
Posted February 6th, 2025 19:44
It's not clear to me if the M.2 slot on the motherboard supports a stand-alone NVMe SSD, meaning non- Optane. Assuming it does I'd put a NVMe SSD in there first (you might need to come up with a "hold down" screw to secure the end of SSD if the 5060 SFF didn't come with the hardware for that.) The motherboard's M.2 slot may be bootable since the BIOS is aware of it, but it isn't clear from the documentation.
I'd consider whether you ever want to upgrade the wired ethernet capabilities of the 5060 SFF beyond it's native 1 GbE (max transfer speeds ~100 MB/s). Same with its wireless capabilities. If so, you might want to reserve the PCIe x4 slot for a add-in card for that.
The PCIe 3 x4 slot can be used to add one NVMe SSD with a simple add-in card for this. These cards are usually $20 or less. (Whether a NVMe SSD on the card would be bootable I'm not sure.) Using this as a data drive should not be an issue. Obviously, the card would need to be low profile and fit into the SFF case.
Regarding the PCIe 3 x16 slot - I see no mention of bifurcation settings in the BIOS, so I assume it doesn't have this.
With the PCIe 3 x16 slot you have two general options:
1) Get a simple PCIe 3 x4 NVMe SSD card like I suggested above for the x4 slot. This will allow you to add one NVMe SSD. There should be no issue using it as a data drive, as a boot drive uncertain.
2) Add a PCIe 3 x16 or x8 Switch card with either 2 or 4 NVMe SSD slots. Again, it would have to be low profile and the length of the card would need to fit within the SFF chassis. These cards can be obtained for around $100-150. Again, data drive no issue, booting uncertain.
I'm using a PCIe Switch card in a different Dell that has no bifurcation settings. It's totally transparent to the PC. Most PCIe 3 Switch cards are based on PLX PEX8747 or ASM2824 chips.