UNSOLVED

cpstarong

updated

3 years ago

C

cpstarong

14 Posts

0

5951

March 1st, 2022 01:00

U2723QE, DSC won't work with MST ON on USB-C?

I've got these devices:

  • ThinkPad X12 Detachable, i5-1130 (with Iris Xe), TB4, DP 1.4, aka X12
  • ThinkPad USB-C Dock Gen12 (40AS0090), 2*DP out, 1*HDMI out, main chip is Synaptics VMM5320, support DP 1.4/HBR3 DSC, support 2*UHD/60Hz, aka 40AS
  • U2723QE supports DSC (Display Stream Compression), aka 2723
  • U2720QM not supports DSC, aka 2720

So I made many combination, but only few of them gave the correct UHD/60Hz.

  1. X12 - 40AS - DP*2 - 2723 & 2720
  2. X12 - 40AS - DP - 2723 - MST - 2720
  3. X12 - USBC - 2723 - MST - 2720
  4. X12 - USBC - 2723

As not supporting DSC of 2720, only first scenario gives me UHD/60Hz*2, whereas the second one gives a UHD/60Hz and a UHD/30Hz. In the last scenario, ONLY if I turn OFF MST, 2723 will woks at UHD/60Hz, otherwise it only works at UHD/30Hz. In the third scenario, 2723 works at UHD/30Hz and 2720 could only get 2048*1280/60Hz top.

Based on the last scenario, according to the display info, MST ON means no DSC neither High Resolution nor High Data Speed. MST OFF takes DSC back. With DSC, I can get UHD/60Hz, otherwise UHD/30Hz top. As the manual (page 17), 2*UHD/60Hz also requires DSC.

Note: UHD stands for 3840*2160, which is not exactly 4K by some definitions.

  • cpstarong

    14 Posts

    3623

    0

    Posted March 1st, 2022 02:00

    With further test, I've got a GTX1080 on a workstation which uses DP connect 2723 and MST to 2720.

    First of all, still no DSC. But both of displays get UHD/60Hz, however 2720 is not working on RGB444 but YCbCr422. And the display info shows stream is 5.4Gbps(HBR2) comparing to USB-C on X12 that's 8.1Gbps (HBR3)

  • 3609

    0

    Posted March 2nd, 2022 05:00

    I have two U2723QE monitors, connected via USB-C to a Surface Book 3. I am struggling to get the MST daisy chaining to work properly, as the SB3 is capable of DP 1.4 Alt mode and 2 x 4k60 yet only one monitor seems to be able to be set at 60hz. MST is enabled, and they do support this, but somethings not quite right.

  • cpstarong

    14 Posts

    3591

    0

    Posted March 2nd, 2022 17:00

    The first U2723QE works at High Resolution, and the second U2723QE gets 60Hz?

  • DELL-Chris M

    Community Manager

    •

    56891 Posts

    •

    232143 Points

    3577

    0

    Posted March 3rd, 2022 06:00

    USB-C/DP 1.4 and DP 1.4 DSC (Display Stream Compression) = Maximum external monitor resolution with the maximum number of external monitors supported is 3840x 2160 60Hz only when DSC is enabled on graphic cards or with graphic cards that support DSC.

    captainscotty,
    The U2723QE USB-C/DP 1.4 only delivers 90W back to source device. Are you testing with the power adapter connecting to the Surface Book 3?

    cpstarong,
    The U2723QX/U2723QE/U3223QE hardware DP 1.4 and USB-C/DP 1.4 supports DSC. In the monitor it is "on" all the time. The U2723QX/U2723QE/U3223QE Menu does not have an option to enable or disable DSC. The usage of DSC is totally dependent on the capability of PC graphics card and graphics card driver. I have tried to re-write your setups below =

    (1)
    ThinkPad X12 USB Type-C --> 40AS --> 40AS DP #1 --> U2723QE DP to DP cable --> U2723QE DP in port = 3840x2160 60Hz
    ThinkPad X12 USB Type-C --> 40AS --> 40AS DP #2 --> retail DP to DP cable --> U2720QM DP in port = 3840x2160 60Hz

    This works. So why even mess with MST daisy chain?

    (2)
    ThinkPad X12 USB Type-C --> 40AS --> 40AS DP #1 --> U2723QE DP to DP cable --> U2723QE DP in port (MST daisy chain on)
    U2723QE DP out port --> retail DP to DP cable --> U2720QM DP in port = U2723QE 3840x2160 60Hz, U2720QM 3840x2160 30Hz

    The resolution and Hz for the both monitor are defined by the available bandwith of the USB Type-C source device.

    (3)
    ThinkPad X12 USB Type-C --> U2723QE USB Type-C to C cable --> U2723QE USB Type-C in port (MST daisy chain on)
    U2723QE DP out port --> U2723QE DP to DP cable --> U2720QM DP in port = U2723QE 3840x2160 30Hz, U2720QM 2048x1280 60Hz

    The resolution and Hz for the both monitor are defined by the available bandwith of the USB Type-C source device.

    (4)
    ThinkPad X12 USB Type-C --> U2723QE USB Type-C to C cable --> U2723QE USB Type-C in port (MST daisy chain off) = U2723QE 3840x2160 60Hz
    ThinkPad X12 USB Type-C --> U2723QE USB Type-C to C cable --> U2723QE USB Type-C in port (MST daisy chain on) = U2723QE 3840x2160 30Hz

    In a single monitor setup, MST daisy chain on should always be off.


    DELL-Chris M (old account)

    #IWork4Dell

  • cpstarong

    14 Posts

    3543

    0

    Posted March 4th, 2022 01:00

    First, I'm sorry for my unclearly description. Secondly, your rewrites are exactly correct. Now, I'm using the forth scenario with MST off.

  • cpstarong

    14 Posts

    3518

    0

    Posted March 6th, 2022 17:00

    But I'm still expecting a feature that DSC works when MST is on, as I want to connect a second screen via daisy-chain. Maybe there'll be a firmware upgrade or something else?

  • 3502

    0

    Posted March 7th, 2022 03:00

    The U2723QE USB-C/DP 1.4 only delivers 90W back to source device. Are you testing with the power adapter connecting to the Surface Book 3?

    I am using the power adapter, yes. So power is not an issue. I have also tried to use a USBC to DP adapter to take the 'power' out of the equation. 

    I can still only get one of the two monitors to work at 60Hz when both are set to 4K. Is there some sort of bug or firmware issue because there should be plenty of bandwidth available on a Surface Book 3 15" with Quadro 3000 graphics.

  • cpstarong

    14 Posts

    3478

    0

    Posted March 8th, 2022 00:00

    I guess that SB3 requires more than 90W power? With 90W power supply, SB3 may work but performance limited. My laptop would work minimum to 45W. So 90W is not an issue.

    May you try to connect the two U2723QE via USB-C and MST, to see if you can get two 60Hz? DP input works at DP1.4/HBR3/4Lane may offer a better bandwidth for video signals, but in USB-C High Data Transfer mode, the bandwidth is limited to 12.96Gbps, and 4k/60Hz without DSC needs about 12 798Mbps.

  • 3473

    0

    Posted March 8th, 2022 02:00

    The power adapter is plugged into the Surface Book 3, so its not limited by the 90W delivered from the monitor via USB-C.

    Do you mean connect the two monitors together via a USB-C cable somehow? The daisy chaining can only be done with a DisplayPort cable to my knowledge, which isn't limited in bandwidth. Currently the SB3 is connected to the first monitor via USB-C so should be able to use all 4 lanes as that first monitor is set to High Resolution, meaning it is not expecting the laptop to dedicate any significant bandwidth to USB 3. Perhaps it's this implementation in the monitor that isn't working properly.

  • cpstarong

    14 Posts

    755

    0

    Posted March 8th, 2022 18:00

    Well, first of all, I don't think High Resolution is a good option to make better usage of this monitor, as this monitor supplies many USB ports, it's more like a hub. Without USB data transferring, the USBs may not work properly. At least my Windows 10 keeps telling me that there's an unknown device and not working properly. So I prefer to use High Data Speed.

    And secondly, as your description, you can only get one 4K/60Hz and the other one is 4K/30Hz? And you connected the first monitor by USBC-DP adapter, connected the second one to the first one's DP-Out by DP-DP cable, MST set on in the first monitor, is that right?

    Note my fourth scenario, MST on and off make completely different results, that's what I'm confusing about.

    I guest that it's a capability issue of the main chip of U2723QE, which is MT9800 by MEDIATEK. Or it's only a firmware limitation or bug, and there would be a firmware upgrade to get a better performance.