Dazz2017

updated

7 years ago

D

Dazz2017

1 Rookie

•

16 Posts

0

1325

May 4th, 2020 22:00

P2419HC, DP cable to 4k monitor?

I've just bought a Dell P2419HC monitor and am hoping someone can solve or explain a problem I'm having.

My 4k monitor works fine when plugged into laptop via a USB-C --> hdmi dongle.

But with my setup using the P2419HC monitor, my laptop display settings will only allow a max resolution of ~2K on my 4K monitor.

XPS 13 9360 --> USB-C cable --> P2419HC monitor --> displayport cable --> Philips 328P (4K) monitor.

Is there some fundamental design limitation I'm unaware of?

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    976

    0

    Posted May 5th, 2020 06:00

    @Dazz2017Your XPS 13 9360 supports DisplayPort 1.2 over USB-C.  A USB-C connector has four high speed lanes in it.  When all four are dedicated to video, as is the case when using a USB-C to HDMI cable, then you have the full bandwidth of a DisplayPort 1.2 interface available, which is enough for 4K 60 Hz (assuming in this case that your USB-C to HDMI cable is rated for HDMI 2.0).  But I don't think you have enough bandwidth for 4K 60 Hz + another FHD display.  In addition, when connecting via USB-C to USB-C cable, there's a good chance that the U2419HC is setting up the USB-C link to carry video and USB 3.x simultaneously in order to allow you to use the USB 3.x ports built into the display.  Carrying USB 3.x requires two high speed lanes within the cable, which means there are only two left for video, which cuts video bandwidth in half.  At that point you only have enough display bandwidth for dual displays up to 1920x1200 or a single display up to 2560x1440.  Some USB-C displays allow you to configure how they set up the USB-C link, choosing between this "half video bandwidth + USB 3.x mode" or "full video bandwidth + USB 2.0 mode".  USB 2.0 works because USB-C connectors have pins dedicated to USB 2.0 traffic, so running that doesn't take away any video bandwidth.  But I'm not sure the U2419HC offers that option.  Dell seems to only be offering that on QHD displays and up to allow users to choose between having USB 3.x data or having enough video bandwidth to run a daisy chain.  But they don't seem to offer it on their 1080p displays because even when running USB 3.x data, there's still enough bandwidth left for a second 1080p display.  Dell doesn't seem to be accounting for users who want to run a second display that's higher resolution than the first.

    You could try running a USB-C to DisplayPort cable to the first display to see if maybe you can squeeze out enough bandwidth for 4K + FHD that way.  Again, I doubt it, but I'm not 100% sure it won't work because that's not a common setup.  But then of course you lose the benefits of system charging and USB data being carried over a single cable to your system.  If that doesn't work or you're not willing to give up single cable connectivity, the only way to get those two displays running together would be through hardware that tapped into Thunderbolt 3, such as a Thunderbolt dock like the WD19TB or a Thunderbolt 3 to Dual DisplayPort adapter -- although the latter again wouldn't give you the benefit of charging and USB data over a single cable.  A dock would, but it's of course more expensive.

    All that said, a 24" FHD display and a 28" 4K display is really not going to be a good combination overall.  The pixel densities of those two displays are so far apart that you're going to have to run very different display scaling factors to get both of those displays rendering content at a reasonable physical size, but then you'll run into the reality that even though Windows can run multiple scale factors simultaneously, it can't optimize for multiple scale factors simultaneously.  Basically it will internally render everything at the scale factor of the display that was primary when you first logged in to Windows and then use post-render scaling to blow up or shrink down the content to fit on displays using any other scale factor.  That will cause those other displays not to look nearly as good as they would if Windows had actually been rendering for their scale factor, and the farther apart the scale factors are, the worse the degradation.  This will be especially noticeable with text.  You'll notice that whichever display is secondary won't look as good as when Windows is using it as a primary display (assuming you sign out and back in after switching, since again Windows decides its scale factor when the user session begins).