UNSOLVED

montazuma

updated

20 years ago

M

montazuma

11 Posts

0

12234

February 20th, 2007 21:00

Looking to buy a monitor

Hi, So I've been scouring through about 16 pages here on the forums trying to find some insight on LCD's as this will be my 1st potential LCD purchase. Originally the E228WFP was the one I was going to pick up but after reading about the backlight bleeding that so many are experiencing I started to look at other options. Next was the 2007WFP. Slightly smaller, more options and about $100 more but I have learned about what is called the monitor "lottery". (S-PVA / S-IPS) One thing led to another and long story shot, I'm now so confused as to what my best bet would be to go with. My biggest concern is gaming. Do I go with the 2007WFP and hope that I get an S-IPS? IS S-PVA that bad? Is the whole S-PVA vs S-IPS thing completely overrated? Should I really steer clear of the E228WFP's TN technology? What about the E207WFP? How is that one? Could someone shed some light on this situation? confused
  • gpro

    2 Intern

    •

    2024 Posts

    361

    0

    Posted February 20th, 2007 23:00

    @montazuma wrote:
    IS S-PVA that bad? Is the whole S-PVA vs S-IPS thing completely overrated? Should I really steer clear of the E228WFP's TN technology?
    Excellent questions, unfortunately I don't think there are simple answers. Each technology has its strengths and weaknesses, and in some cases I think it just comes down to personal requirements and preference.

    One thing that is clearcut is that the 20" and 22" monitors have the same resolution. I would prefer the finer pixel pitch of the 20".

    I have found these sites helpful in understanding the technology:
    TFT Central - LCD Specifications
    AnandTech - LCD Buyer's Guide
    Hardforum - LCD Panel Technology Type and Characteristics
    X-bit’s Guide: Contemporary LCD Monitor Parameters and Characteristics

    I bought a 2007WFP S-IPS 10 months ago, my priority being color accuracy over response time, and I have been very pleased with this monitor.
  • montazuma

    11 Posts

    361

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 20:00

    Thanks for your reply and for the links gpro.
     
    I've been looking through them and have decided to stay away from the E228.
     
    Now it's just a matter of do I want to enter the lottery or not.
     
    This one monitor did catch my eye though.
    I can't seem to confirm what kind of panel it uses. I could have sworn I found one page that said it was S-IPS but I can't find it now.
     
    Any input on this monitor?
     
    Or maybe any input on a confirmed S-IPS monitor within the $350-450 pricerange? (no smaller than 20")
     
    Thanks again!
  • gpro

    2 Intern

    •

    2024 Posts

    361

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2007 01:00

    a quick Google:
    16.2million colors here
    160-degree (horizontal) and 145-degree (vertical) here
    - pretty much confirms a TN panel. That last review wasn't too impressive.

    couldn't find that model listed on panel reference sites - only these
    Philips 200W6B LG.Philips S-IPS (LM201W01)
    Philips 200W6S LG.Philips S-IPS (LM201W01)
    http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/

    Philips 200WB7ES (widescreen) has a 20 inch 8 ms TN (Chunghwa CLAA201WA01) panel.
    Philips 200WP7ES has a inch 8 ms (g2g) S-IPS (LG.Philips LM201W01) eller et 8 ms (g2g) P-MVA panel.
    http://www.flatpanels.dk/panels.php

    The LM201W01 is the S-IPS panel used in the 2007WFP.
  • montazuma

    11 Posts

    361

    0

    Posted February 22nd, 2007 16:00

    Thanks again! :smileyhappy: