UNSOLVED

Venomous

updated

20 years ago

V

Venomous

22 Posts

0

1908

July 18th, 2006 19:00

Displeased with Dell 2007FWP - Need Advice

I purchased the Dell 2007FWP revision A02 on sale for roughly $400 with tax and shipping. I need advice on picking a new widescreen LCD that fits my needs (or if I should keep this one).

First, here are my problems with the Dell in order:
1) Banding
2) Brightness
3) Refresh Rate

Specs of Dell:
DVI-D, 1680x1050 @ 60hz, 16ms (black to black) and 8ms (grey to grey), 300 cdm2, 800:1 contrast ratio, and 20.1'' size.

Things I like and will possibly miss about the dell:
1) hdcp 2) picture in picture 3) ergonomics (it's gorgeous)

Concerning banding, I'm tired of it. This monitor (even the a02 model) bands, just a lot less than the A00 model, but it still bands. To me, this is unacceptable and the primary reason I am getting a refund on this monitor.

Concerning brightness, I have done everything to try to get this monitor to be easy and pleasing on my eyes. The brightness is too jacked up. By decreasing the brightness, my black levels turn to junk quickly and lose all detail. If I try to adjust contrast in the nvidia control panel, I am adding banding. Adjusting gamma hasn't seemed to help very much. Like many LCD tvs (which I have experience with), by having such a bright display (300cdm2 in this case), you can produce acceptable black levels, a more jazzy showroom display, and most important, often it allows you to artificially jack up your contrast ratio. Also, reading text is very hard on the eyes for longterm as this monitor is very, very bright. Most CRTs by comparison are 100cdm2. Cleartype hasn't helped.

I am looking for:

I am looking for a widescreen monitor with a DVI-D input, proper color scales, 8bit panel, no banding period, fash refresh rate for games (preferably higher than 60hz), possibly hdcp (but if that really limits things then it isn't necessary). I am looking for a LCD that is pleasing on the eyes and not a full lit sun sitting on your desk, basically a LCD with nice black levels that doesn't need to artificially inflate them by jacking up the backlight. I am looking for a good LCD with many properties of a fully functional CRT. proper color reproduction, no banding, fast refresh rate. This LCD will be primarily for reading text (for graduate school) and Gaming. Picture in picture is nice feature of the Dell that I wish I could get again but it isn't a deal breaker. However, I hope I can get hdcp again. Quality is king. Something this Dell lacks overall or it would never have gotten past quality control.

If for $400, you would just keep the dell and accept the minor banding and brightness issues, then please say that as well.
  • Falgor

    8 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 18th, 2006 19:00

    Man, sorry for this post, but all these displeased comments about 2007wfp are really making me reconsider even thinking about buying it. I hope you find the solution, there were some tips on the same page I think.
  • gpro

    2 Intern

    •

    2024 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 00:00

    concerning brightness, see my reply in your other thread:
    http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=61889#M61889

    My understanding is that LCDs are generally brighter than CRTs. I would be skeptical of manufacturer's brightness and contrast specifications.

    Again, my understanding is that adjusting gamma or contrast will introduce banding on any display.

    As for alternatives, did you see this review? BeHardware - 13 20" LCDs
  • skibum5000

    2 Intern

    •

    150 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 02:00

    but some can take much more adjustment before banding really becomes noticeable, some even still have less than unadjusted 2407.

     

  • Dufflover

    2 Intern

    •

    429 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 03:00

    During my 20" research the "best" for me was actually the Samsung 215TW (21") but the Dell costed $300AU less with the loss of only component input and USB/Computer control of the monitor (which is probably something Dell is rueing at not putting) so that's what I went with. I guess you already know I'm happy with mine. As more reference to currency, the prices are: Viewsonic VX2025WM $579, Dell 2007WFP $699, Samsung 215TW $940

    So yeh, have a look at the Samsung.

    http://www.samsung.com/au/products/monitors/tft/tvmonitor/215tw.asp?page=Specifications

     

  • Venomous

    22 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 23:00

    I've had several people recommend that Samsung and Viewsonic. I've also had people recommend (for a heftier price tag and an upgraded S-IPS display) to get the NEC 20WMGX2. Problem is, while I can find a local store that carries the Samsung and Viewsonic, I know of almost no stores (unless someone has any ideas) that carry the NEC. Based on what I've read, eventhough the NEC is about $250 more, I think it's exactly what I'm looking for. However, before dropping the change for the NEC, which I'll only be able to see if I order it online, I'm planning on hitting up best buy and compusa tomorrow evenign to give the Samsung and Viewsonic a look. If either one is significantly better than the Dell, I may just go ahead and get one of those and save myself the extra money and possible risks associated with ordering that NEC. I think my problem with this Dell (Banding aside)is that my expectations were too high (something every company needs to manage or you get dissatisfaction).

    Even if I were able to magically eliminate the banding, the brightness of this monitor is absolutely destroying me. I really like what I've read about the NEC...addresses problems with overt brightness of LCDs in general and have many modes that supposedly don't band. I say supposedly because I am skeptical of all companies now if such a simple issue as banding could get past the quality control of a company as huge as Dell. It takes approximately 5 seconds to test a monitor for banding.

    Concerning that samsung you purchased, compared to the dell, how is it? My areas of concern: banding (have you ran any gradient tests?), response rate (how does it perform in games compared to the dell), image quality, and especially BRIGHTNESS and the reading of black text on a white backdrop (like 90% of the webpages out there heh). Do the whites sting your eyes? Did you have to do a lot of tweaking on the monitor to get it acceptable?

    Thanks.
  • Falgor

    8 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 23:00

    That's the exact same model I was looking at :)! Got great imputs and all. Seems to be good according to these two reviews here:

    http://www.trustedreviews.com/article.aspx?art=3081

    http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2006/07/07/samsung_syncmaster_215tw/1.html

    Message Edited by Falgor on 07-19-200607:32 PM

  • Dufflover

    2 Intern

    •

    429 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 20th, 2006 01:00

    I only have bought the Dell but I remember ruling out the NEC because in a review (pre-banding) it was beaten by the 2007WFP, and not just on color reproduction and what not. I didn't look into it any further after that though.
     
    But looking at the Samsung it's the closest in price and functionality to the Dell (except it has software control and component input). I don't see how the NEC could be so much better to cost $250 more to the others. If I've mis-interpretted and both Samsung and NEC sit around the same price I would go Samsung.
     
  • gpro

    2 Intern

    •

    2024 Posts

    342

    0

    Posted July 20th, 2006 05:00

    review of the NEC at Widescreen Gaming.
    Some people object to it's distinctive glossy coating which is very reflective.