2407FPW & HD Resolution support from various sources sources
can someone tell me what HD resolutions this monitor is meant to support if anyone has tried them properly?
will it support 1080p/1080pHDCP through DVI *from my PC*?
will it support 1080p/1080pHDCP through DVI *from external sources using component inputs*?
will it support 1080i/1080iHDCP through DVI *from my PC*?
will it support 1080i/1080iHDCP through DVI *from external sources using component inputs*?
i have seen the list of what is supported but it only says no or yes....pretty bad answer. I want to know exactly does it support what HD resolutions through what sources?
Just got this monitor 2 weeks ago and have been playing with it since then.
1st - For PC use at just a monitor its great. Picture and response time I have zero issues with.
2nd for use as a HDTV monitor its junk I dont see how they could release this monitor in this condition. As to you specific questions I can address the ones I just tried myself yesterday.
1080i over DVI - NO get an display error message
1080p over DVI - NOT TESTED not sure did not have a source for this.
720p over DVI - Works looks great!
480P Component - Works looks horrible
720P Component - Works looks horrible
1080i Component - Works looks horrible
480P Component to VGA - Works but everything is green *shrug*
720P Component to VGA - does not work
1080i Component to VGA - does not work display error message
All of these were tested from a Dish Network HDTV receiver. At this point I gave up this monitor is going back to Dell and I just placed an order for a Samsung 244t which does not have ANY of these issues. Again if you are just using for a pc monitor its ok but if you are going to use any other inputs forget it.
thanks for your info, yeah i am using this LCD as my PC Monitor aswell as a TV for my room as i don't have space left in my room so i will be largely using it as my TV source for HD and future HD Content where i need "proper" support for ALL HDTV and HDCP resolutions aswell as good component input quality, and i agree aswell as everoyne that the component is just..... well.. amazingly BAD!
I will end up return my monitors and gonna wait for a new model or different manufacturer.... i would go the samsung 244t but i don't like what i am hearing about mouse input lag.... i play fps games regularly and need my good response...
Also just wanted to know as my initial question was will it support these resolutions such as 1080p/1080pHDCP through DVI (from my PC, playing videos on my HDD or HD-DVD from an internal BLU-RAY or HD-DVD Optical Drive?)
Message Edited by AssyrianKing on 08-06-200606:38 PM
Message Edited by AssyrianKing on 08-06-200606:39 PM
Message Edited by AssyrianKing on 08-06-200606:39 PM
2407 DVI -
1080p-60Hz = Works
1080i-50Hz = No
1080i-60Hz = No
1080p-50Hz = No
720p = Yes
2407 Component -
1080i-60Hz = Works
1080i-50Hz = Works
1080p-60Hz = Works looks horrible
1080p-50Hz = Works looks horrible
720p = Works looks horrible
480P = Works looks horrible
2407 Component to VGA -
480P - Works but everything is green
720P - No
1080i - No
If you add your notes to his, here's what it should be (I've had the same results w/ vA02):
2407 DVI -
1080p-60Hz = Works
1080i-50Hz = No
1080i-60Hz = No
1080p-50Hz = No
720p = Works
2407 Component -
1080i-60Hz =
Works
Works looks horrible
1080i-50Hz =
Works
Works looks horrible
1080p-60Hz = Works looks horrible
1080p-50Hz = Works looks horrible
720p = Works looks horrible
480p = Works looks horrible
2407 Component to VGA -
480p - Works but everything is green
720p - No
1080i - No
Well this is all quite shocking. I want to push try 1080i and 1080p to this screen and it just doesn't do it.
Now I can push 1920x1200 (16:10) and show a 1920x1080 (16:9) picture with black bands top an bottom from myPVR, but it work work off other HD sources.
Plus I need 1920x1200 50Hz (PAL) and not 60HZ (ATSC) for New Zealand. Doesn't look like this screen will do it so its going to get returned at this rate.
Furthermore, after clarification that this monitor would only support 1080p at 60hz, I posted photos showing that the monitor was indeed accepting a signal at 60hz and this claim was unsubstantiated. I had asked for further help in trying to find a solution to this problem, namely a further discussion of the monitors capability to display the advertised 1080p and perhaps the source (HD DVD, BluRay, PS3 DevKit, external box) the Imaging Group were using in lab to test the monitor.
This was just over 5 weeks ago and no response. Perhaps the engineers are taking an extended vacation to recuperate after their exhaustive 8 months of testing and quality control? Or better yet, they're working overtime to perfect the A03 before the Playstation 3 comes out, and this problem becomes more mainstream?
Just a frustrated, albeit patient customer who's only joy is that my monitor was not equipped with rechargable battery.
I'm glad you've been able to test out 1080p @ 60hz fine. I unfortunately have not, hence my enquiry into what sources everybody seems to be using to drive this monitor as they are somewhat limited at the moment. And when I enquire on sources I'm refferring to external boxes such as a Toshiba HD DVD Player, Samsung BluRay player, 1080p cable/sat box etc. NOT a PC driving the monitor at 1920 x 1080 @ 60hz. That's not the issue. This monitor is targeted as a multimedia monitor, and is HDCP complaint but I have yet to see it display a 1080p image @ 60hz from an external source.
What sources have people in this thread been using to drive this monitor at 1080p as at least 2 in this thread seem to have had success with this endeavor.
So I take it that no one here has an external source driving this monitor at 1080p? I mean I have 3 years to warranty this model when and if it can't deal with such a signal, but I would just like to get this overwith now. Anyone?
jpkyle
1 Message
639
0
Posted August 6th, 2006 22:00
1st - For PC use at just a monitor its great. Picture and response time I have zero issues with.
2nd for use as a HDTV monitor its junk I dont see how they could release this monitor in this condition. As to you specific questions I can address the ones I just tried myself yesterday.
1080i over DVI - NO get an display error message
1080p over DVI - NOT TESTED not sure did not have a source for this.
720p over DVI - Works looks great!
480P Component - Works looks horrible
720P Component - Works looks horrible
1080i Component - Works looks horrible
480P Component to VGA - Works but everything is green *shrug*
720P Component to VGA - does not work
1080i Component to VGA - does not work display error message
All of these were tested from a Dish Network HDTV receiver. At this point I gave up this monitor is going back to Dell and I just placed an order for a Samsung 244t which does not have ANY of these issues. Again if you are just using for a pc monitor its ok but if you are going to use any other inputs forget it.
Good Luck on your purchase!
Joseph