UNSOLVED

stephenvv

updated

24 years ago

Closed

S

stephenvv

3 Posts

0

31220

April 12th, 2003 04:00

Will D-Expansion Dock work on 8500?

According to this, the 8500 is compatible with Latitude D-Dock systems:

http://www.dell.com/us/en/bsd/products/model_inspn_inspn_8500.htm

This is the D-Dock I would like to use:

http://docs.us.dell.com/docs/acc/despestn/

Because it has a PCI slot. However, a phone sales guy could not tell me if it was compatible nor how to order it with an 8500 since it's not listed as a choice.

Any help appreciated.

  • stephenvv

    3 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 13:00

    Well, that mirrors what I found out by calling Dell. I sales person said yes, the other no and tech support is not sure
  • nanakivii

    37 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 13:00

    If it's anything like the C-Series versions, the Inspiron BIOS will prevent you from connecting to the Latitude docks.

    The Latitude C/Dock and the Inspiron APR both use the same connectors, however there is a metal hook on the C/Dock that prevents an Inspiron from just sliding in. (The hook can be easily removed I am told.) Also, an Inspiron notebook can not connect to a C/Dock unless the user flashed his/her BIOS to the systems Latitude equivalent. (i.e. Inspiron 8200 to Latitude C840)

    Rance the moderator made a comment about it to this effect, but I can not find the post. (It would be pretty old by now...)

  • LDouglasL

    3 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 13:00

    I would think the D/Dock Expansion Station would work as it has the same connector as the D/Port Advanced Port Replicator.  I use the Advanced with my I8500 and recently sent a P.O. in for the D/View Notebook Stand.  And if you read the Product highlights about it, it only list the Latitude but the Inspirion also has it listed as an option.
  • LDouglasL

    3 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 17:00

    The I8500 series uses the D series docking stations.  The Advanced Port Replicator that I have for my I8500 is the D series.  So I would not see any reason why it would not work.
  • nanakivii

    37 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 17:00

    BIOS Limitation. This was the exact same for the C-Series. (The I8200 has an APR that is roughly like the C\Port and C\Dock, just like the I8500 has an APR, except they actually call that one the D-Dock. Search the forum for references to the C\Dock II and the I8x00 series; you will find that it will not work unless the user flashes their BIOS to their system's Latitude eqivalent.) I found the thread I mentioned, where Rance states that the D-Dock is not designed for use with the Inspiron 8500, but rather for it's Latitude equivalent.

    http://delltalk.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_video&message.id=71404

    I quote from Rance: "There is a D series docking station (with a PCI expansion slot) and D series advanced port replicator. Just like before, the docking station is only designed to be used for Latitude systems. The D series advanced port replicator will work with both our newer Inspiron and Latitude systems."

    Message Edited by nanakivii on 04-15-2003 01:32 PM

  • stephenvv

    3 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 17:00

    Thanks for the link - that answers the question - it won't work. Appreciate the info, even if it's not good news.
  • nanakivii

    37 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2003 20:00

    Well, I'm not necessarily saying it won't work, but it may be more trouble than it's worth at this point in time.

    It may be possible to make it work, like how you can make a C\Dock II work with an I8200, but I don't know if the same methods would apply, and I doubt that many I8500 users would be comfortable taking the necessary steps this early on in their ownership. (Heck, I still don't feel comfortable thinking about doing it with my I8200...)

  • tracedef

    11 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 19th, 2003 08:00

    The new D-Series have improved upon the C-Series and are cross compatible between the New Inspiron and Latitude lines, you will have no bios issues etc...............
  • nanakivii

    37 Posts

    1555

    0

    Posted April 19th, 2003 14:00

    Based on Rance's post (which I linked to earlier in this thread) and the following observations I have made:

    • The "Tell Me More" page on the D/Dock page for the Latitude line in the small business section does not mention compatibility with the Inspiron series.
    • Dell does not offer the D/Dock on the Inspiron line in the Small Business section, it does offer an Advanced Port Replicator,  and does not mention any other D-Family docking solution.
    • Dell does not offer the D/Dock on the Inspiron line in the Home/Home Office section either.
    • Nothing esle on the support site that could possibly mention D/Dock compatibility with the D/Dock in question.

    I need proof that goes past this information to accept/confirm your currently unjustified claim.

  • DEMETRIOS13

    1 Message

    618

    0

    Posted April 21st, 2003 04:00

    what is the D-Bay for external modular devices?