UNSOLVED

AT_Wolfgang

updated

21 years ago

Closed

A

AT_Wolfgang

47 Posts

0

17156

September 15th, 2005 13:00

Why Dell's new, "no built-in, internal microphone" policy is a bitter deception

I just confirmed yesterday, in an effort to see where my options lay, that NONE of Dell's new notebooks now has an internal microphone, nor will they for the foreseeable future.

Hence, so far as practical voice audio goes (voice chat, voice telephony, voice recording, etc.), ALL of Dell's new notebooks, including (as a painful, permanent example) my new maxxed-out Inspiron 9300, are substantially inferior to any notebook computer I've owned going back to the old 486 IBM 701C Butterfly 15 years ago.

It's unusual for a high-tech company to step backward so far, so fast, and users will pay a very high price to save Dell's nickel.

From now on, even on Dell's "luxury" (or beyond that, in my case, and even funnier, "multimedia powerhouse") notebooks, you won't be able to do voice chat using Skype, Google Talk, Windows Messenger, etc. without buying, carrying with you, and connecting an external microphone EVERY TIME you want to chat--and this at the precise time that voice comes of age on the Net.

It's simply unbelievable--and since it's done against the universal experience of buyers and WITHOUT NOTICE by Dell, it's extremely deceptive.

An analogy: it's like buying a new Lexus over the web, only to discover that it does not have air conditioning. At first, you might not even notice--if it's fine outside, or cold, or if you think it just isn't working for some reason ("Dang, the climate control is complicated!"). But when you do figure it out, once you regain your senses, you'll be really, really ticked off. There's still an A/C indicator in the car's control panel, just no actual A/C. And once you find out there's really no money-back guarantee ("Sure, you can return the Lexus to us, but if you notice, there's a rather enormous restocking fee, so you might want to consider just living with it, sir, with all due respect. Thank you for buying Dell!"), you may be outraged (as many, many are--only actual customers, though, not would-have-been customers, who are usually just amazed and bemused).

SPREAD THE WORD--not to demean Dell, but to reveal it. Make sure your friends and colleagues have NO interest in voice before they order a new Dell until Dell changes its bizarre policy. Probably < 1% of Dell customers know this now--if it gets up to 25%, it will have a substantial impact on Dell sales, and then--ONLY then--the policy will change back to normal, and only those in the tragic interval (like me) will consider themselves cursed by Dell's incompetence.

On a more personal note: suddenly losing the Trackpoint, ubiquitous on Dell notebooks for years, for those coming from an IBM ThinkPad background particularly, is analogous to a new Lexus without power windows--_almost_ as stunning, and one's just incredulous that it's not at least an option.

Indeed, for each of these de-features, the very fact that there was no option is part of the disingenuous concealment: you wouldn't EXPECT there to be an option for A/C or power windows on a new Lexus now, would you? Is there an option even on a new Camry? On a new Corolla (maybe on the ultra-low end?)?

Count this as "fooled us once"--shame on Dell.

Message Edited by AT_Wolfgang on 09-15-2005 09:13 AM

Message Edited by AT_Wolfgang on 09-15-2005 09:14 AM

  • 985

    0

    Posted September 15th, 2005 15:00

    I am supporting you by not following through on my intended purchase of a high end configured XPS Gen 2 or 9300; 2GHz, 2GB, 100GB 7200RPM, 256MB NVIDIA Go 6800, 17" W-UXGA-TL, 2915 WLAN w/Bluetooth, MCE w/Remote, DVD Burner, back pack, etc.
     
    DELL is just flat out plain wrong and deceptive to be doing this.  Especially without making customers aware the ubiquitous defacto standard customary internal microphone feature has been removed from the high end "Multi Media Powerhouse" system they are purchasing.

    Power To The People

    St. John 3:16 - More than just a sign at a sports event, read it, the book, and be cool.

    Dell® Inspiron® 8600
    Intel® Centrino® Mobile Technology

    Pentium® M Processor,1.4 GHz
    15.4 in WUXGA (Wide Aspect UltraSharp® Display)
    128 MB nVidia® GeForce® FX Go 5650 4X AGP Graphics
    512 MB,DDR,333MHz
    40 GB Ultra ATA Hard Drive (replaced with 60 GB 7200 RPM)
    2x CD/DVD Burner (DVD+RW/+R)
    Intel® PRO/Wireless 2100 WLAN
    Dell® TrueMobile® 300 Bluetooth

    Message Edited by St. John 15.13 on 09-15-2005 09:31 PM

  • carvwa

    2 Posts

    985

    0

    Posted September 16th, 2005 04:00

    I must agree I am pretty angry about this same situation.  I too have a recently purchase 9300 and am very angry that it took countless hours of research, after some troubleshooting time, before finally giving up and calling Dell.  Luckily the web cam I believe to work the best for me also has a built in microphone, but come on.  If you are going to pull a standard feature, don't stealth the fact you have.  Let people know.  I am with you on this one, and I recommend Dell's all the time to every one I that ask's me.  Secondly, I work for a company that has an extensive history with Dell, and we regularly purchase hundreds of Dells through out the enterprise.  The next time Dell has one of their "What would you like to see in the future from Dell, I guarantee this will come up.  Furthermore, Dell is now cut off until they can resolve this issue.  I will not point anyone else looking for a Laptop to Dell if they are not going to:
    1) fix their terrible error in judgement (not putting microphones in laptops or even making it an option)
    2) change their policy on notification and documentation of removed features
    3) right the wrong of the users that currently purchase Laptops (like the 9300) without any acceptable notice that there was no longer a "standard" feature avaliable or even the option.
     
  • tomintx

    1003 Posts

    985

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 00:00

    Message Edited by tomintx on 09-16-2005 09:05 PM

  • AT_Wolfgang

    47 Posts

    985

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 01:00

    Tom,

    In most cases for home and in many for office users--basically, whenever a speakerphone is an option for conventional telephony--headsets are unnecessary and inconvenient. (And Google Talk, e.g., typically gives superior quality viz a viz landlines, making headsets even less important, in my experience.)

    If you had actually _used_ a _good_ built-in mic before (in, e.g., various ThinkPads and Dells), then you would _know_ from experience they work very well for voice-over-IP. In fact, my friend in Korea is using her year-old Dell Latitude D800's built-in microphone right this moment to talk with me, and even as she wanders around her studio apartment in Seoul, I'd describe the call quality as _excellent_ without reservation (much better than a domestic US landline handset call, e.g.). (BTW, _I'm_ using a headset, but _only_ because I'm using my stupid new, beyond 21 days, "high end", "multimedia powerhouse" Inspiron 9300 that has no microphone. None of my other notebooks would require that, and none of my interlocutors uses a headset--though it's true I just have my headset sitting on the desk in front of me. :^> )

    Of course, if you have a poor microphone design, then it doesn't work well, whether internal or external.

    It's a pointless and (until now) unnecessary hassle indeed to have to buy and then, when on the move, carry, unpack, and connect a headset every time you want to use voice (and reverse the process when done), especially when there's an incoming call or when the call is brief, especially since most headsets don't pack/unpack particularly compactly. To have the OPTION to use a headset is important, in that we agree (in a noisy environment, or to increase privacy), but to have it mandatory is bizarre, and to have it _covertly_ mandatory is deceptive.


    BTW, the solution for Office is just to turn off the voice recognition stuff--the idea that's it's actually _better_ instead just not to have a microphone strikes me as even more bizarre than Dell's decision (which I presume is based on saving 25c or 50c or whatever--though it's now conceivable to me, only increasing the incredulity, that someone at Dell could have disastrously thought your way). I've used Office for years, around a decade, with never a microphone issue, and every notebook computer through those years (and before) had a microphone, it goes without saying.

    Do you work for Dell, by any chance?
  • tomintx

    1003 Posts

    985

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 01:00

    Message Edited by tomintx on 09-16-2005 11:37 PM

  • tomintx

    1003 Posts

    1013

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 02:00

    Message Edited by tomintx on 09-16-2005 11:37 PM

  • AT_Wolfgang

    47 Posts

    1013

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 03:00

    I find a number of your comments strange--e.g., who said anything about a conspiracy? This is just a very, very dysfunctional and (as carried out) dishonest Dell decision that's harming tens of thousands of users--maybe hundreds of thousands. (Though many don't know it yet--it wouldn't bother you, e.g., as you assertively point out.)

    And the point about well-designed internal microphones working extremely well with HQ voice-over-the-net services is not opinion, but simple, absolutely demonstrable fact. I demonstrate it repeatedly every day (in hearing others, none of whom use headsets or external microphones in talking with me, and indirectly by leaving my headset on the desk, using only its microphone as an ersatz internal microphone--people can hear me fine, every time).

    NB: I _am_ assuming a good VOIP service here, but they're easily available free now--again, Google Talk comes to mind and is what I use. Given a good microphone, a good voice service, and a reasonably good audio environment, there's _no_ _genuine_ _debate_ _whatever_ amongst people who try it.

    (I would absolutely agree that a good headset offers _even_better_ quality--9 or 9.5 versus 8 or 8.5, perhaps, in a quiet home or office environment. But that slight audio superiority can pale in comparison with the dramatic convenience inferiority, particularly if one is mobile in one's use [even mobile within the home or office]. OTOH, if you're in a noisy environment or need greater privacy, and if you're not mobile, headsets are wonderful.)

    If you and your "hundreds of other users [you] know" who have "never used a built in mic" before would try it before condemning it, at least many (most? nearly all?) of them would realize this too. (Others will have inferior microphones, inferior VOIP service, or a poor audio environment--in any of those cases, you might need a headset just to salvage any communication at all.)


    Eventually, Dell will reverse course here--not for the sake of users, but for the sake of its reputation and, most of all, it's bottom line. But so long as people don't know what they're missing (a microphone, or, as in your case, just how useful an internal microphone can be), they'll get away with it. I and many others are trying to hasten that day--for Dell's sake, but mostly for the users' sakes.

    Fortunately, in all the many comments on many different threads on this subject, yours is the first and only one to come out in support of Dell, and you argument, to be frank, is demonstrably unsound, as I and presumably nearly every other contributor to this and similar threads realizes.
  • AT_Wolfgang

    47 Posts

    1013

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 14:00

    BTW, if folks out there are wondering why I've spent/wasted so much time on this, originally detailing the issue and then responding in depth to the _one_ critic out there, there's a very simple, if quixotic, reason: THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT TO ME AND MANY, MANY OTHERS.

    I'd_never_ have purchased any new Dell without a microphone, and that goes for a huge percentage of others, too. But we didn't know Dell had suddenly stripped them out.

    And utterly ill-informed opinions like Tom's are very common out there, and perhaps (much more inexcusably) very common in the relevant Dell management circles.

    Dell NEEDS to know, for the sake of its customers, that this is not some sort of "well, experts differ" kind of issue. Those of us with experience know that it's very cut and dried, very straightforward, very simple: a built-in microphone, in many, many cases, works extremely well and is extremely convenient; stealthily removing that feature has _substantially_ reduced the value of any new Dell notebook computer _far_ in excess of the cost of the microphone.

    I, e.g., would like to sell my 9300 on eBay (if the warranty is transferrable), but I face a quandary: if I do not point out that it had no microphone, then I'm as bad as Dell, but if I _do_, the machine will go for a lot less money. (Dell must have known or suspected this--hence the stealth.)


    There is an extremely simple and _low-cost_ solution to this self-inflicted wound: Dell _must_ return to the status quo ante, and they _must_ do so ASAP, before customers generally internalize this lack of an internal mike and just conclude "Dell = no voice".

    In the short run, this is severely harming customers.

    But in the long run, this will severely harm Dell.

    And if Dell thinks saving $300,000 or something on microphones is a big deal, wait until they start losing $100M or more in cumulative revenue as customers gradually become aware and drift to rival notebooks with at least basic voice capabilities.

    It's our job, as it were, to make sure customers (and indirectly then, Dell) learn the truth sooner rather than later.


    P.S. They should also return to the status quo ante regarding the Trackpoint, at least as an option, though for most customers this will not prove as big a deal at all as the loss of voice. The Trackpoint is an acquired, expert taste--but once acquired, it's hard to go back to the simple but less-capable and -convenient touchpad. Why not an option, at least? I'd pay an extra $100 for a trackpoint--amortizing the power and convenience over 4-5 years of heavy use makes it a no-brainer, in fact.

    Message Edited by AT_Wolfgang on 09-17-2005 10:43 AM

  • AT_Wolfgang

    47 Posts

    1013

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2005 16:00

    Blast--just FYI, the warranties, including extended warranties, are NOT transferrable. Once more: unbelievable.

    Thanks to Dell's successful deception, this really was money completely down the toilet for me and myriad others. I can't even sell this machine to someone who doesn't want voice capability now, since it will have no warranty, even though I paid something like $400 for a 4-year, night-and-weekend, on-site coverage plan.

    And people wonder why we're all so angry?

    Why on earth would being _tricked_ into _irreversibly_ getting a wholly inappropriate, multi-thousand dollar (list; even with discount it was over 2 grand), "it does everything except the essential basics" notebook computer make people angry?

    We're right to be angry. This needs to change.

    And it will _inevitably_ change as Dell re-realizes how important voice is--but it should change NOW.

    Dell's losing and alienating customers buy the truckload--when will they figure this out?
  • vshay

    12 Posts

    475

    0

    Posted October 1st, 2005 22:00

    i have to agree that  i m very disappointed with that I6000 doesn't come with built in mic.  i had 8600 before this and it has built in mic and it worked great comes very handy and had numerous conversation online in chat, with relatives overseas on yahoo/msn messagers.  never had any problem with quality of voice.  I think if not standard feature then atleast it should be available as option.  I am going to buy a webcam with microphone that will help me but u dont always have video conference.  Very disappointed in Dell.   I tried to get an explanation why built in mic was removed but was not able to get reasonable answer from Dell techs or any reasoning behind it other than its not avaliabe anymore.  spent hours on the phone. what a waste.
     
    Not just the mic issue but i also had several issues with their customer service and hour long wait only to get someone who cant help you or resolve your issue completely.  Their techs seems to have no knowledge of their products and just make up answers.  I used chat feature to ask one of their techs if the I6000 comes with infrared transfer device and I was told yes it does.  Even when i pointed out that website doesn't show it.  Tech insisted that its on their.  Sure when i got the laptop, it wasn't there.  Untrained techs.  Poor service.
     
    One of the salesperson at Best Buy explained that Infrared doesn't come with any new computers because it is slow by today standards.  He was very knowledgeable and helpful.  Next computer will definitely be at BEst Buy.  NOT buying Dell again.  too much trouble and hassel.