UNSOLVED

parisnwinter

updated

14 years ago

0

42206

March 24th, 2012 16:00

Vostro 1710 embedded/discrete GPU

I am trying to replace the motherboard for my vostro 1710.

I know I want it with discrete graphic GPU onboard, but I also know I do not want a board that has the nVidia chip. I want to get a better motherboard than what it came with, so I have a few part numbers for the various motherboards for the vostro 1710, and I have searched and searched and searched and cannot find good and/or complete specs for these motherboards. Does anyone has the specs or provide a link where I can read what kind of GPU each of the following 1710 motherboards has?

X805C - discrete video onboard?

X806C - GE Force 8600 256MB

D816K - nVidia

Y183C

Y185C - Intel GM965 Chipset

P383J - nVidia

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1123

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2012 16:00

    The only option on these systems for discrete video is nVidia - there's no other, and these are the faulty chips that earned nVidia such a black eye.

    The Intel-integrated version is the only one that doesn't have nVidia - Y185C is one of these.

  • rseiler

    2 Intern

    •

    125 Posts

    1123

    0

    Posted May 2nd, 2012 10:00

    Is the Y185C the highest-end non-Nvidia available (information on this subject is sparse)?  My 1710 has a 1920x1200 screen, which according to the technical docs for the GM965 chipset shouldn't be a problem (it tops out at 2048x1536x32 @ 60Hz), but I'd like to consider all possibilities.

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    1123

    0

    Posted May 2nd, 2012 10:00

    It's the only alternative to an nVidia-based board.

  • rseiler

    2 Intern

    •

    125 Posts

    1123

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2012 22:00

    It turns out that I had one barely in warranty, so they set me up with a Dell replacement part of  H212G, which is not listed above and which there's almost no detail about on the Internet. The GPU BIOS and Rev are newer, so I would have to assume that there is a fixed version after all.

    The old board had:

    Video Adapter: nVIDIA GeForce 8600M GS (Dell)

    GPU Code Name: G86M (PCI Express 1.0 x16 10DE / 0425, Rev A1)

    BIOS String: Version 60.86.64.0.25

    The new board has:

    Video Adapter: nVIDIA GeForce 8600M GS (Dell)

    GPU Code Name: G86M (PCI Express 1.0 x16 10DE / 0425, Rev A2)

    BIOS String: Version 60.86.64.0.26

  • rseiler

    2 Intern

    •

    125 Posts

    1123

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2012 14:00

    Did you accidentally say H211G?  I'm speaking of the H212G:

    accessories.dell.com/.../productdetail.aspx

    Note the different phrasing with the H211G:

    accessories.dell.com/.../productdetail.aspx

    The 212G says "discrete" (reference to video) and the 211G says "unified memory" (apparent reference to integrated video).

    I'm not the primary user, but I'll try to open it up the next time it's in my orbit. I'd be surprised if it's anything but the H212G, since that's what they told me it was when they were putting the part aside for the onsite tech. Plus, as you said, the Y185C uses the GM965 chipset, which has onboard graphics. I ran an Aida64 report on the new board (and I have it for the old one as well), and they're both PM965, the one without integrated video.

  • 1123

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2012 14:00

    I have seen the Y185C - Intel GM965 Chipset advertised on eBay with the H211G part number as well. Check out the sticker on the board under the second memory module and tell us what part number it shows. I'd be curious to know what is the Dell approved replacement.

  • 1128

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2012 17:00

    Updated list of boards for the 1710 available. I take it the Y185C is the best that does not have the nVidia chip.

    X805C - discrete video onboard?

    X806C - nVidia GE Force 8600 256MB

    D816K - nVidia GeForce 8600M GS (H212G)

    Y183C

    Y185C - Intel GM965 Chipset (H211G)

    P383J - nVidia

  • 1128

    0

    Posted May 26th, 2012 11:00

    To our dell techs out there, now that I installed a new Y185C on my vostro 1710 and it is back to life, i wonder if it can handle a WUXGA screen?

    It currently has a 17 in (obviously) WXGA with a max screen resolution of 1440 x 900, so my question is whether i need to go to an nvidia board to be able to handle the higher resolution of the WUXGA?

    I am not using it for video editing, photoshop and dreamweaver are my two main uses, and do not handle photo files larger than 15MB.

    I have to say that I have had a vostro 2510 with an nvidia board since 2009, and it has not let me down. I must be one of the lucky ones, I guess. I have used that laptop daily since i first bought it, and all i had to do to it was replace the keyboard (wore it down) and the DC jack at the MB because I stepped on the chord and yanked it out of the laptop which in turn broke the inner socket of the dc jack. It was a hairy proposition, and I had already bought a replacement board for it, but replacing the jack worked out just fine. I feel bad for all those who have had such a bad experience with the onboard nvidia video chip, but like I said, I have literally worn down one keyboard already, and it continues to deliver solid performance. I have been using Dell systems for eleven years already (4 laptops and one slim profile desktop hooked up to the large flat screen in my household), and I have nothing but great service and experiences with them.

  • rseiler

    2 Intern

    •

    125 Posts

    1128

    0

    Posted May 26th, 2012 12:00

    The chipset technically supports 2048x1536x32 @ 60Hz, so on paper it should be able to do 1920x1200. You're saying that you have a WUXGA screen but Windows isn't showing you a resolution above 1440x900?  If so, there's a hack for that, probably something along these lines (as someone in the comments mentions, the numbers will be different for 1200, but that should be out there somewhere):

    komku.blogspot.com/.../how-to-get-1920x1080-full-hd-resolution.html

  • 381

    0

    Posted May 26th, 2012 15:00

    Great! No, it currently has a WXGA lcd screen so the intel utility shows to max out at 1440x900. Great hack for using with a larger tv screen. I just ordered a WUXGA lcd for it, so i wanted to make sure it could handle it when i install it.