UNSOLVED

todd33

updated

23 years ago

Closed

T

todd33

19 Posts

0

20492

November 27th, 2003 00:00

P4 versus Centurion Performance

Which is better performance wise for graphics and multimedia?  A P4 or a Centerion M.  Basically the top of the line 5100 versus the top of the line 8600 (not taking the graphics card situation into effect)

  • todd33

    19 Posts

    476

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 01:00

    Centrino, sorry about the brain fade...
  • Verns600m

    130 Posts

    476

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 01:00

    centrino?
  • CSmith06

    2 Intern

    •

    956 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 01:00

    Centrino 1.7 Ghz is about a 2.4 Ghz DESKTOP p4 some say, so it's about the same power as a 2.6 Ghz p4-m or 2.5 Ghz p4-m then 1.6 is about a 2.3 Ghz p4-m or so and so on down the line. This is highly disputed however, and everyone has their own opinion about it.

    Truth be told, you'll be just as happy, if not more happy (because of added battery life), with a 1.7 or 1.6 Ghz P-M (Centrino) as with a 2.4 Ghz - 2.5 P4-M.
  • NeXur

    8 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 12:00

    My opinion:

    PM--P4

    1.3=2.0

    1.4=2.2

    1.5=2.4

    1.6=2.6

    1.7=2.8

    -------------------

    Inspiron 8600
    PM 1.5GHz
    512MB RAM
    60GB HD
    128 MB NV31 (5650)
    15.4" WXGA
    8x DVD / 24x CD-RW combo
    Windows XP Home

  • matt37b

    134 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 14:00

    I heard the multiply factor was 1.6. 
  • ofelas

    649 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 14:00

    Apparently, multiply by a factor of 1.9 to get-

    1.4 Centrino = 2.66 P4

    1.6 Centrino = 3.04 P4

    1.7 Centrino = 3.23 P4

     

    After using both, I see no reason to doubt the figures above-my 1.7 Centrino D800 EASILY keeps up with my 3.06GHz 5150, and betters it in most applications, and is configured similarly.

  • CSmith06

    2 Intern

    •

    956 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 16:00

    there's no way that you multiply by 1.9...it's definitely 1.6
  • CSmith06

    2 Intern

    •

    956 Posts

    108

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 16:00

    Yeah I suppose that for a word processing and internet browsing because it's the same for nearly ANY computer made today and increasing the processor speed to 3.__ Ghz is not going to change this, but for anything besides basic tasks, then no.
  • rodal

    2 Intern

    •

    69 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 16:00

    I've heard the multiply factor to be 1.5

    For example my 1.6ghz would equal out to a 2.4 P4 mobile.

    I think this is more realistic. 

  • anglete

    32 Posts

    487

    0

    Posted November 27th, 2003 16:00

    the multiplier is a rough number.

    These don't scale directly to P4's, so for some applications, you could very well use a multiplier of 1.9...

    In any case, they're a lot more fuel efficient and so far my 500m is a lot more stable than my friends 8500. They also run a lot colder with her temperatures reaching 140 degrees F, mine never passing 110.