UNSOLVED

adortok

updated

17 years ago

A

adortok

7 Posts

0

13634

August 28th, 2009 23:00

no warranty replacement available for XPS M1730

I've been having several non-stop video card issues with my less than 1 year old XPS M1730. Finally Dell Technical Support said they would replace my laptop, however since Dell discontinued the M1730 they told me to choose another laptop. The thing is, there are no more high end gaming laptops made by Dell, and they said they can't replace it with Alienware, so my best choice would be a Studio 16. I am obviously not going to settle for a laptop that is half the cost of what I paid for.

Does anyone have any insight on what my next steps should be to resolve this issue? I would like an Alienware seeing as how it is the only comparable laptop to the M1730.

I find it ridiculous that I have been having issues for over 2 months with my laptop and now they tell me they can only replace it with a computer that is significantly inferior to what I'm entitled to. In the warranty agreement it clearly states:  "If we are not able to repair the product, we will replace it with a comparable product that is new or refurbished. " A Studio 16 is not comparable to a M1730.

  • Tkd

    20 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted August 29th, 2009 00:00

    You are absolutely right, the studio XPS 16 is not a suitable substitute for the M1730 period. My wife has that model, 1 year old now. I just bought myself an XPS 16. I will have to admit though, once they replace it because of the subwoofer rattle, I will totally love this laptop. But, it is no way in the class off the M1730. It was designed as a gamers laptop with 2 video cards, etc. The keyboard is way different with the standard numbers on the right side and everything. You bought that laptop for gaming. The only suitable substitue is the Alienware, period. They can configure it very similar to what you have now. Alienware belongs to Dell  now. They discontinued the M1730 probably because they didn't want to compete with now there own gaming systems. The Alienware laptops are more expensive so Dell is hesitating at replacing the M1730 with it. It is not really fair to you. I would be very upset myself. I know how much I spent on my wife's M1730 and at over $3K they should really replace it with another gaming laptop. Of course that is my opinion. I have been a pretty  loyal Dell fan and that would probably really put me off.

  • Mike3343

    1 Message

    496

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2009 06:00

    'adortok' So, where you able to decide on a replacement for your XPS M1730? I am facing the same issue and would appreciate an update on your case? I am being offered a 15.6" XPS notebook for my M1730!! How messed up is that?

  • adortok

    7 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2009 07:00

    I had to go through a lot of hassle, but I finally got a Precision M6400. My M1730 was fully loaded so it probably depends on what specs you have for what replacement you'll get.

  • adortok

    7 Posts

    506

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2009 08:00

    The FX3700 is better than that 8800s i had.

    I am enjoying the M6400 much better than M1730 and there are no better Dell gaming laptops.

  • Jeff2010

    24 Posts

    506

    0

    Posted October 11th, 2009 08:00

    Precision is a bad choice for gaming. If it comes with an FX card then the system will be great for Auto CAD but not gaming. Just an FYI.

  • dgoerndt

    29 Posts

    506

    0

    Posted October 13th, 2009 07:00

    I was offered much the same replacement for my M1730. When I told the tech I needed two hard drives for Photoshop work, he said the xps 16 only had room for one drive, I was offered the Alienware 17x outfitted with similar components as my M1730. Dell offers the 17x at 1799.00US so it is less than I paid for the M1730. My M1730 started having problems after only 16 months and now it boots but there is nothing on the screen. This is after a MB, graphics card and LCD replacement!

  • teri1957

    2 Posts

    506

    0

    Posted December 17th, 2009 23:00

    I have had problems with my XPS M1730 from the day I bought it.  I bought it with all the top of the line offerings.  intel 9000 extreme processor @2.8 ghz, Blu-Ray Writer,(2) 200gig HDDs@ 7200 rpm , 4 gig ram, Geforce 8800gtx sli with 1 gig ram, Physics card, and a 4 year premium XPS warranty.  The first video card failed after 2 months, the sli feature stopped working. The second card was unstable from the day it was installed. (Random crashes, 2 tries to boot up, programs that just would not run.  The only service Dell provided  was the online tech replacing the video driver driver. After the driver change the symptoms changed but the whole pc was unstable.  Eventually the failure was total, so I received a 8700 gt downgrade until my card was in stock.  Eventually the tech returned and installed a 9800gt sli.  I was happy for 1 day because the 9800 ran cooler. But when I went to play a dvd with digital audio, I found the spidf connector missing!!  As 1730 owners know, the digital audio breaks out from the svideo connector with a dongle. Now I was a bit angry. They tried to pass off a damaged card to me. By now no 8800gtx cards were in stock and no 9800 gt cards were in stock either, so I took another temporary downgrade, an 8700gt sli.  With only 1/2 the memory as my original card, the performance is miserable.  Dell says they will have a 8800gtx or a 9800gt available by mid Jan 2010.  But since Nvidia is tanking now, due to all the overheat problems, I have to wonder whether a replacement card will ever be available.   Now, during my current wait, Dell called me and offered me a 17x. .  At first I said no, I will wait. Two days later, when I called to find out if the offer was still valid, they said they had no record of ever offering me a 17x. Even worse, they said they didnt replace 1730's with alienware anymore. That really got me angry. They were calling me a lier. Anyway, After arguing a bit more on the phone with the Dell supervisor I hung up. He said my system has severely depreciated and is not worth much. He was trying to set me up with an  inferior machine.

    From here I don't know where things will go. I left a note with the unresolved issues department. I received an automated response that said  They are "escalating" my issue.   C'mon Dell.. Either come up with the part, or replace this machine with a model with the same features.  I spent $5700 on this laptop in august 2008, and it has been broken for more then 50% of the time I have owned it.

    Depreciation should not even be considered . Especially when customers have been going through Dell Hell with Dell support.   What about my lost time troubleshooting this beast. What about my lost hours of work , spent instead on the phone with service personnel isn't my time valuable?.  Most customers, myself included have an adversarial relationship with Dell.  It's me against them.  Us vs Them.  This is not the way to resolve problems. Wake up Dell!   What ever happened to the saying that the customer is always right?    I need an acceptable solution to my problem.  A comparable video card or a comparable computer.   My configuration dictates a 17m replacement, and not a bottom of the line one either.  Be fair!!     

    I have a premium xps warranty that runs until august 2012. If Dell wont be replacing this laptop, they better be prepared to keep replacing video cards. By 2012 they will wish they had replaced this laptop.!!!  So far the service tech has visited my house (4) times.  1) 8800gtx replaced with 8800gtx. 2) 8800gtx repalced with 8700gt. 3) 8700gt replaced with 9800gt sli, 4) 9800gt sli replaced with 8700 gt sli .   and the story continues.................

    Teri

     

     

  • jeffc1968

    1 Message

    506

    0

    Posted February 11th, 2010 11:00

    Man reading all these posting makes me ill.  I've just started getting Blue screen dump consistently now and it all points at the NVIDIA card.  Calling dell tech support makes me cringe too, for one I could not understand the tech in India and when he threw it over the fence to someone from hardware support she was clueless.  They think OS should be reinstalled or the game I'm playing isn't supported when I cant get it through their thick heads it's a random occurance and happens whether a game is being played, browsing or just sitting there.  That totally smells of hardware beginning to fail...HELLO!!!!!!

    Well I'm just going to continue to bug them until I get a replacement.  It's obvious from postings replacing cards over and over is a giant nightmare.  Come on Dell if you want me to ever purchase anything from you again you'd better get this one right.  Absurd this high end of a computer can't even make it a year.

  • Minim211

    3 Posts

    506

    0

    Posted February 19th, 2010 16:00

    Familiar story, bought the XPS 1730 in May, slight lag over delivery - shortage of graphics cards, things are great until december, blue screen, then black screen- support says grahics card gne- 1 month to get a replacement.

    New card installed - but keyboard number pad stopped working- keyboard replaced but B & M keys have problems.

    Big issue is the blue screen errors, IRQL_NOT_less _or EQUAL

    support tells me this is software offers to charge £95 for service- explained it has come from hardware so no charge.

    errors continue- regular contact with support, who suggest an upgrade to Windows 7 will solve the problem, so pay up £165 - guess what?

    More blue screen errors than before.

    So now the beast is due for collection and will spend 5-7 working days being tested.

    I will have had the lap top for eight months and it will have functioned correctly for five.

    my letter is in the post to head office looking for replacement/ refund since that device was supplied with a faulty card.

     

    My sons Studio 17 works a dream- so what is the issue with the XPSm1730?

     

  • Minim211

    3 Posts

    226

    0

    Posted February 19th, 2010 16:00

    Familiar story, bought the XPS 1730 in May, slight lag over delivery - shortage of graphics cards, things are great until december, blue screen, then black screen- support says grahics card gne- 1 month to get a replacement.

    New card installed - but keyboard number pad stopped working- keyboard replaced but B & M keys have problems.

    Big issue is the blue screen errors, IRQL_NOT_less _or EQUAL

    support tells me this is software offers to charge £95 for service- explained it has come from hardware so no charge.

    errors continue- regular contact with support, who suggest an upgrade to Windows 7 will solve the problem, so pay up £165 - guess what?

    More blue screen errors than before.

    So now the beast is due for collection and will spend 5-7 working days being tested.

    I will have had the lap top for eight months and it will have functioned correctly for five.

    my letter is in the post to head office looking for replacement/ refund since that device was supplied with a faulty card.


    My sons Studio 17 works a dream- so what is the issue with the XPSm1730?