
UNSOLVED
Closed
I9200 WUXGA problems
I have a 9200 on it's way buy UPS, and of course as my luck would have it I found on this post
http://notebookforums.com/showthread.php?t=52484 a lot of people are not happy with Dell's new 17" WUXGA. Is this really a problem? Is Dell working to fix this? What recourse other than not accepting the computer when it gets here do I have if there really is a problem. Thanks LeeU
Responses (14)
Solutions (0)
The sparkle effect is very troublesome to me. I returned mine. I too thought I could live with it and get used to it... which I did... and was going to keep, then I put it next to another computer with way less performance, and everything looked horrible on the 9200 compared to the other computer. This was simply due to the 9200's screen. You may get used to it, but once you have it next to another computer, you will see that it should not look like that...The white backgrounds are actually a dingy yellowish color. But in the end it is just personal preference. I am going to try out the WXGA+ since no one has complained of it, and everyone with it seems to be happy, I guess they didn't use the same screen coating on that one.
jslessley
- LeeU11: If I were you I would accept it and try it out. As some one who reveived a 9200 WUXGA last week, I think there is no way to tell whether if you will like the screen without trying it out. I was bothered by the way white bacground looked at first, but the more I use it, the less I notice it unless I deliberatly look for it. What I really like about this screen is hows sharp the text looks. I wish the view angle were as wide as my 20" Apple Cinema Display, but for a laptop it is pretty good.
Spending 2000 dollars on a computer, you should be able to look at it however you want without noticing a sparkling effect, or anything else wrong with it for that matter. You shouldn't have to not deliberately look at it to not notice it. It may work for you, but I do not want to keep a notebook that I am going to have to keep from looking at certain aspects of the screen, so I can not see the imperfections.
jslessley
- I saw these pictures before on the other forum, and from my point of view, the difference is pretty clear, and I don't mean only the Apple white which is white, but about the clarity of the colors on the blue line and on the radio button.Anyway I still wait for my 9200, and I will make my opinion.I agree that if this screen is not perfect, it makes no sense to keep it. It's much too expensive to just try to accommodate with something that hurts your eyes, and it's something that I'm planning to keep for at least one year, so it should be perfect from the beginning.As i said before in another message, it seems to be a question of luck, because from what I read till now, it appear to be different qualities of screens sent with different machines.D
- jslessley: If that's the way you feel, then the 9200 WUXGA is definitely not for you. Sony is the only company that make a 17" WUXGA, so the choices are pretty limited at the current time.
I did a bit of microcospic analysis with a macro lens to compare the 9200 WUXGA against a 20" Apple Cinema Display which happens to be the best display I have seen, period. Here is a sample:
http://pbase.com/image/37062932.jpg
For reference, the Apple display background looks like a piece of paper.
Then, I went a step further and take a closer shot of the two so that now I can see blurry RGB dots instead of white dots (I didn't post that image), and both screen looks horrible.
The point is, if you look deep enough you will find flaws with everything. When I am reading a book, if the paper has enough texture I may find it anoying, but for the most part if it is smooth enough I couldn't care less. Same thing about a screen, if the coating is such that it stands out too much it would bother me, but otherwise I wouldn't go out of my way looking to see if I can see the grains which are smaller than the pixels themselves (well I did, but then I got a hold of myself). To me, the whole perception is more important. I keep my mind open, and use it for a little while. If it bothers me, then it's not good. The 9200 WUXGA screen coating bothered me at first, but when I stop thinking about it and started using it as I would a computer, I seem to like it more and more everyday. From my experience, I would say a real test is to use it for a day without focusing microcsopically at the background.
It's not that I don't care about ultimate quality. I am looking forward to the days when I can get an organic LED. But if I am waiting for better products to come along, I would still be using pencil and paper. Nothing beat paper when it comes to display quality. (But then again, if you put paper under a magnifying glass you would start debating if the surface is smooth enough). unclejung:
I agree that nothing can be perfect and you can't wait for somthing that is absolutely perfect or you will never have anything. But I have used tons of screens on notebooks over the years and have NEVER noticed anything like this before. Obviously this one is not for me because I wont put up with it when I can get the same product without the problem (wxga+). If all laptops were like this I could understand keeping it as there is nothing without the problems, but the fact is there are hundreds of laptops out there without this problem. But in the end it's if you are happy that counts. I was not, although I loved the high res., I could not stand the screen.
jslessley

mattcowger
2582 Posts
420
0
Posted December 6th, 2004 01:00