UNSOLVED

drkpfr

updated

19 years ago

Closed

D

drkpfr

8 Posts

0

7356

June 16th, 2007 22:00

Fans working erratic on Inspiron 8200

The fans on my Inspiron 8200, purchased 4/2003 , have been working erratically for about 3 months. In Diagnostics, both fans have been getting 'Fail' , expected '8200 rpm', actual rpm '0'.
I have been using Fangui, and one fan could be forced to max. speed, but in the past 2 weeks that hasn't worked consistently, either. Both fans will still sometimes come on , with correct rpm indicated in fangui, so they are not 'dead' entirely. Now, often neither fan will work, regardless of fangui setting (manual control, max. speed, automatic or let windows control it), and the CPU will gradually creep to over 90 C, until I shut off the machine or it shuts off to protect the CPU.
 I have bought replacement fans from EBay (described as 'pulled, but guaranteed to work'). However , these also 'Fail' in diagnostics, and haven't been seen spinning at all, until I put the old ones back in (at least they work sometimes).My questions :
 1. should I get another set of fans, in case the 'pulled' ones are actually bad ? (somehow I think it's something in the Motherboard)
  2. since the current fans still work sometimes, it can't be contacts, wires etc. Is it a problem in the motherboard, i.e. whatever feeds juice to the fans ? I have run complete diagnostics, and everything but the fans gets a 'pass'
 I have found replacement MoBo on EBay for $ 70-80 , for the I 8200  (but with 2 different Dell Part #, will either one work fine?)
Thanks for your help
 
Inspiron 8200 , CPU 2.0 MHz Pentium M4 Mobile, 1024 MB Ram, 1600x1200 UXGA LCD screen, Radeon Mobilty 9000 , Windows XP Home SP2
  • notladstyle

    268 Posts

    131

    0

    Posted June 17th, 2007 23:00

    Sound like the issue is with your motherboard. You need to take a DVM and measure the voltage between the red and black wires while running the laptop. This is somewhat difficult and the only time I did it, I extended the leads outside the case so that I could close it up and operate it.

    If the fans aren't on and the meter shows 12v or 7v (depending on the fan setting and speed) then the fan is bad. If there is no voltage from the motherboard, then the board if bad.

    You could also use a small 12v power supply to test the fans to verify they work. listen closely for scratching noises which would indicate a bad bearing.
  • drkpfr

    8 Posts

    131

    0

    Posted June 21st, 2007 17:00

    Thanks, unforunately this exceeded my technical ability a bit.
       In the end, I got the MoBo from Ebay (was about $ 75 with shipping) The good news: the replacement fans work perfectly (one bearing on my originals was getting very noisy, anyway) Conclusion: it must have been a problem in the original MoBo, i.e. how it delivers power to the fans.
      The replacement MoBo has the same part# on it as my old one, but is 'Rev. 02' ,vs '00' It identifies itself now as a 'Latitude C 840' in Bios, with different service tag, runs BIOS Version A13 (latest for I8200 was A11) It has caused some minor issues, i.e. Fangui had to be reset for different Laptop, modded version of ATI Catalyst Panel not working. I suppose I need to reinstall drivers etc. in the future as if this is a Latitude C840 ?