
UNSOLVED
Dell Inspiron 1420 - Won't power up (just blue LEDs)
I have a Dell Inspiron 1420 laptop purchased in 2008, with Core 2 Duo, 4 GB RAM and Windows 7. It's been extremely well treated and lightly used. Never had any issues with it before.
Well, last night I attempted to turn on my laptop only to discovered it has spontaneously died. If I press the power button, there is NO activity from the fan, hardisk or screen. The only sign of life is the power LED on front lights solid up for 5 seconds, and then goes out. If I plug in the DC wall-charger, power LED lights up for 5 seconds, goes out, and then the battery LED blinks once every 10 seconds.
Holding down 'FN' while pressing power results in more LEDs, the Bluetooth and caps/num/scroll-lock lighting up briefly. In otherwise, apart from a few LEDs lighting up, it is completely, and utterly dead.
Tried the following...
- Removed battery
- Tried powering up with DC charger only (also tried a different charger)
- Removed both memory DIMMs (also tried popping in a different DIMM from spare parts)
- Removed DVD burner
- Removed SATA hardisk
- Removed WIFI card and modem card
- Unplugged CMOS/clock battery
- Removed and reseated CPU and heatsink
Likely a bunch of other stuff I'm forgetting, including giving it some dirty looks and cursing at it. Grrrr. If I've missed something, I'm opened to other suggestions though!
The last thing I did with the laptop was leave it plugged in and charging the battery for several hours, while sitting idle at the Windows desktop. Then did a Windows shutdown. Did it overheat or something?
At this point I assume the motherboard is at fault. Question is, WHAT kind of fault? Could it be GPU related, or some capacitor issue? Likely it's out of warranty and not worth the cost of replacing the motherboard, but I wonder if doing a reflow of the GPU with a heatgun might bring it back. Nothing to lose expect my time but thought I'd see if anyone else has experienced this issue.
Responses (5)
Solutions (0)
Its online spec list the GPU as the Intel GMA X3100 (unfortunately I have no way to verify that at the moment as it won't post).
It's strange it died so suddenly out of the blue, without any symptoms beforehand. The only "unusual" thing I did, was leave it powered up and running for several hours without actually using it.
If the GPU is at issue here, is this a typical symptom? To go completely dead, no power? I've seen other laptops where the GPU is at fault (failed solder contacts due to excessive heat) but at least they briefly power up and the fans run.
I might try a reflow of the GPU if that's the likely source of this problem.
Did some quick research and discovered the Dell Inspiron 1420 is listed in a class action suit for having that problematic Nvidia GPU. Likely too late to get compensation. And I can forget about any support whatsoever from Dell.
Well, with nothing to lose, I disassembled the laptop and removed the motherboard. Pulled off the heatsink from the GPU and sure enough, there's a NVidia chip: G86-631-A2 (which I believe is the "8400M GS" GPU).No signs of scorching or discoloration, but likely THIS is the source of the failure. Either the solder under the GPU isn't making a proper contact or the chip itself has failed outright. I'm just surprised there were no symptoms beforehand, like video artifacts or freezing.
For the heck of it, I'll try doing a reflow with a heatgun and see what that does...
EDIT UPDATE:Okay -- a lot of work done, and 3 hours later. No success. Tried a dry reflow of the GPU and reassembled everything. Absolutely NO change. *** it. Maybe it's something else that's failed on the motherboard? Or the GPU just completely died?
Also tried swapping in a new CPU (Core Duo), nothing either. Not pleased, looks like the only solution is a new motherboard, but what's the point if it has the same NVidia GPU that's going to fail in time.
At any rate, I think this is a lost cause. :(
The problem with these GPUs is that the material they're made from doesn't stand up to thermal cycling -- and most engineering analyses say the only true fix would have been a complete redesign. nVidia never did that - so they're all suspect.
If the system otherwise works, you can get a board with an Intel GPU for about $50:
< >
You'll need a new heatsink to make the swap, but for a total of about $70 if the system is otherwise functional, it'll likely run for quite a while longer.
I just gave up on the 1420 and stripped it for parts tonight.
The good news is I found an Inspiron 1525 in my parts pile (never got around to tinkering with it because it came missing the hardisk and caddy). I installed the Core 2 Duo (T5750), 4 GB RAM, 160 GB SATA HD and the better condition keyboard. Installing the hardisk was a bit tricky without the sled caddy, and leaves it exposed on the side, but it booted up and runs! The 1525's BIOS is version A16 from 2008, and seems to recognize the CPU so I may leave that as-is. I'll see how stable the replacement laptop is; at least it uses an Intel GPU.
Still would have preferred the 1420 for it's smaller and more compact size (plus it has a webcam built in, the 1525 does not) but this at least gets me back up and running for now. I'll have to think about whether it's worth repairing the 1420, I may just sell the LCD screen and toss the rest.

ejn63
11 Legend
•
87469 Posts
•
321256 Points
1870
0
Posted February 9th, 2016 04:00
If the system has an nVidia GPU, it could well be that chip that has failed. This generation of nVidia GPUs was well known for that.
The boards look like they run in the $60 range -- if you want to save the system, it won't be an unduly expensive repair.