
UNSOLVED
What is the best solution for backup?
I had a hard drive crash recently. It froze during Defragmentation and never recovered. Luckily I had backed up my really critical documents on a thumb drive, but reinstalling all of my software and trying to recover things that were not backed up took months.
My wife and I each have a Dimension 4550 and they are now about 4 years old. My wife runs a home business on her computer and I run our home on mine. I never want to go through the crash and recovery episode again - so I'm looking for the best solution in hardware and software for backup of both computers.
What I want to be able to do - in the case of a hard drive crash - is to completely reinstall everything on either computer just as it was the last time I backed it up: documents, photos - AND - all of my software with the
settings etc. as they were before hard drive crash.
We're not rich, so price is a consideration.
What do people recommend in hardware and software for this kind of solution? Currently, with both computers, we have about 80 GB of information. My wife's computer is a 60 GB with about 20 GB currently filled - and it is unlikely she will ever get to 30 GB on her computer. My computer is a 250 GB with 60 GB used. Over time, I will probably get to 50% or 125 GB used on my computer. So the most we will ever have to back up is about 160 GB - and that is some years down the line.
I want something that can easily move from my computer to hers (We ARE networked, but I've never been able to make the network do anything more than share the same high speed internet connection.) It would be great if I could backup both computers to an external hard drive, connected to my computer via USB.
If that can't be done, then I will need an external hard drive, connected via USB, that I could move from my computer to her computer periodically to do backups - and then put the "backup hard drive" into our safe deposit box.
Any ideas?
We have Dimension 4550. Windows XP. I have 1 GB of memory. She has 500 MG of memory. My hard drive is 250 GB. Hers is 60 GB.
Responses (6)
Solutions (0)
shesagordie
12 Elder
•
46017 Posts
647
0
Posted August 14th, 2006 19:00
SEMANAInstall a second internal [or external USB 2.0], IDE hard drive and image the C: / drive to it daily.You will need a imaging utility, such as Acronis True Image 9.0.
You can download a full retail copy of True Image 9.0 @ $29.99 and burn it to a CD, from here,
The Acronis True Image 9.0 Manual in PDF, can be download from here,
http://www.acronis.com/homecomputing/download/docs/Bev.- Thanks.Here's an answer I got from a friend, which I thought I'd share with the Dell Forum:"There are some very simple solutions to more elaborate. The cheapest is just getting a USB 2.0 Hard drive and attach it to one machine and share it on the network. I saw a 250 GB external in Sunday’s paper at Office Depot for $149 ($99 after rebate). It was a Western Digital “My Book”. Staples had a Maxtor 200 GB for $129 ($89 after rebate). Both of those probably come with backup software, but it would only back up one machine automatically, the other machine would have to be manually backed up. Next up the chain is called a NAS (Network Attached Storage) Office Max had a Simpletech 250 GB NAS on sale for $149. They attach to your network router rather than an individual computer and show up with as a drive to all networked machines. I don’t know if it comes with backup software but if it did it should be able to backup both machines. The most eloquent (and expensive) solution is the Mirra Server by Seagate. It’s about $500 for 320 GB of storage. It automatically backs up both machines and synchronizes the file folders of any shared files. It’s like a small computer (no keyboard or monitor) that plugs into your network also. It also can let you share your files on the Internet via a log in at Mirra’s website. I’m looking at one to share (bigger) photos rather than email them. The biggest plus is everything is automatic, it backs everything up and you don’t have to think about it. Another thing I’d suggest is an UPS (Uninterrupted Power Source) It’s more than just a surge protector and evens out power to make your Computer less likely to be damaged. You’d want one for all your machines and one that has AVR (Automatic Voltage Regulation) it gives each machine clean power levels and has battery back up so if the power goes out you have time to shut the computer down without it crashing." 10.10.06
shesagordie
12 Elder
•
46017 Posts
647
0
Posted October 10th, 2006 19:00
SEMANAThanks.Bev.- Here's what I ended up doing.
I decided I didn't want to deal with a big drive and a complicated "mirroring" software to backup my whole drive and that of my wife. I figured that in 25 years of owning computers I'd only had one drive fail so all I really needed to backup were my documents, pictures, etc.
So I bought a Western Digital 120GB drive for $120 that has its own software and operates through a USB connection with no requirement for a power supply.
The software is very simple to use. It opens a window like Explorer, listing all of the folders on My Computer. I just choose the folder(s) I want to backup and click on "Synchronize" and it backs up the folders. In my case, I just want to backup "My Documents" so I just click on the folder, click Syncronize and the process is completed in a couple of minutes. (The first Synchronize takes 10-15 minutes).
The drive comes with a hard case so I can disconnect the drive, put it in the case and either take it with me or put it in a safe place, like our safe deposit box.
It also excrypts everything that is put on the drive, requiring a password to access. In case I lose the drive and someone else finds it, they can access a "Lost & Found" file on the drive but nothing else. The Lost and Found file has a message put there by you. In my case I put "This hard drive contains personal files and photographs accessible only through the use of a password and of no value to anyone but the owner. If found, please call XXX-XXX-XXXX for information on how to return the drive and receive a $100 reward."
I think this will work for me.
Thanks for the Forum help on this question. shesagordie
12 Elder
•
46017 Posts
647
0
Posted October 25th, 2006 19:00
SEMANAAppreciate the feedback.Bev.Please don't send me questions about your system by DCF Messenger.
Post the issue in the appropriate Board, where they will be answered.

fireberd
11 Legend
•
33399 Posts
•
112848 Points
647
0
Posted August 14th, 2006 12:00
If you are doing "business" on a PC it needs backed up daily or at least the "user" data backed up daily. It needs to be on a separate device such as a CD (if the user data will fit on one) otherwise you need a more robust backup solution. External USB connected hard drives with a backup program is one of the more common solutions today. On commerical servers many still use a tape backup system (and have a weeks worth of backup tapes). The usual home PC does not need backup as frequently as one that is used for business. But, any solution you use such as an external hard drive with some type of backup software such as Norton Ghost or Acronis True Image, you need enough space for several full backups on the hard drive. e.g. at least two full backups for your wife's PC and two full backups for your PC. You want the "last" backup saved in case there is a failure while you are doing the current backup (Murphy's Law does exist).
As far as the type of backups, there are full and incremental. I do not recommend the incremental backups (an incremental only backs up what has been changed since the last back up). When I was managing a network we tried incremental backups on our servers and found it was a "disaster". We went to only using full backups.
Whatever route you take will cost you some money (at least $200 for a high capacity USB drive and backup software) but the backed up data will be worth it.