UNSOLVED

tibbitts

updated

18 years ago

T

tibbitts

13 Posts

0

1696

February 5th, 2009 14:00

Vostro: use built-in video or older card

I have a new Vostro 220MT with built-in video.   I was wondering if I should install an old Dell Radeon x300 SE 128mb video card that I have, or whether this (c. 2004) card is so old that the built-in Intel 4500 video is better.

I have older Pentium II Optiplexes that  I'm using with my new Vostro analog 1680x1050 monitor (on a kvm switch), and was pleased to find that I'm able to use the native monitor resolution even with their old Rage AGP chipsets (I did upgrade them from 4 to 8mb), so I'm not thinking that video performance (or memory) might be that big a deal either way, but I thought I'd ask.

Thanks

Paul

 

  • RobinBredin

    6 Operator

    •

    3717 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted February 6th, 2009 02:00

    Hi tibbitts, Your manual is HERE, it states that you have an PCIe graphics card slot on you mobo. I would recommend that you upgrade your video, with an card with at least 512mb of ram.

  • tibbitts

    13 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted February 6th, 2009 23:00

    Yes, and I think the x300se is a pci-e x16 card, but an early generation.  I'm wondering if the performance of the card is better or worse than the built-in 4500 graphics.  I could probably use whatever memory I could recover from the video-shared memory, but don't want the performance to be worse than the built-in graphics.  While 512mb would probably be nice, I'm doing kind of ok with 8mb, so I'm thinking 128mb might be ok too.  Or, if there is an inexpensive new card that would be a big improvement, I might consider that too.

    Thanks

    Paul

  • 50pence

    166 Posts

    410

    0

    Posted February 7th, 2009 15:00

    The X300SE will work fine in the Vostro on XP with the right drivers, the only question is X300SE drivers for Vista though I am sure they exist. It will be pertectly adequate for all but gaming, that being said it will offer little advantage over the onboard graphics except that it will release the memory being used by the on board graphics.

    I prefer a dedicated graphics card so would either install the X300 or spend 25 quid or so on an nVidia 8400GS, a great card that uses the same drivers and utility as the high end nVidia cards.