UNSOLVED

jay nathan

updated

20 years ago

JN

jay nathan

20 Posts

0

12528

April 4th, 2007 19:00

Thumbs down...Thumbs up. Brand new Dell

My Dimension/xps 9200/410 has failed.  Had a Dell Technician look at it and he told me that my computer was not working properly.  I have had it for 10 days.  He said my best option was to do a system exchange. Now I have to wait another 2 weeks to get it replaced.  Not too happy, but the support was very good. 
 
Here's hoping this isn't a sign of things to come from Dell Products.  Here's hoping this is a sign of support to come from Dell's customer and tech support.
  • 639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 01:00

    Count your blessings that it didn't happen 2 weeks later. It still would have been under warranty but would have been much more painful to get fixed. Did the tech say what the problem was? Personally, I would return it for a refund and re-buy it to restart the clock on the 21 day satisfaction guarantee. I'm not sure whether you'll have that luxury on a replacement.
  • jay nathan

    20 Posts

    639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 02:00

    My 13 in 1 reader was faulty, there were start-up issues, my 4 gigs or ram was non-responsive, a host of issues.  The Tech guy had control of my computer for about 20 minutes and he was awe struck with the numerous problems.  He didn't hesitate recommending the system exchange.
     
    I really hope my next system comes with less troubles.
     
    They say that they are putting rush on it so I sort of leapt into the exchange. I may get the restart on the 21 days but I haven't confirmed that yet
  • x_lab rat

    1976 Posts

    639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 15:00

    Dell warranty has the option (for them) of repairing or replacing.  The replacement was a good solution, since they couldn't pin the troubles down to one assembly.  The 21 days does not restart, though you have an option to purchase warranty extension on the new system.
     
    Odds are against the replacement having this degree of problems.  The only thing the refund/repurchase method gains you is the 21 days, plus getting a 'new' vs. 'refurb' which most replacements are.
     
    After the 21 days, Dell can still offer a replacement for a warranty problem, and if they choose to repair it and 3 attempts fail for the same problem a system exchange is a likely next step.
  • x_lab rat

    1976 Posts

    639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 16:00

    "I paid for new" is what everyone says, and they would have a strong point if 'refurb' meant half-worn-out stuff dusted off and repackaged.  Dell 'refurbs' can be reassembled from retested parts, or complete systems retested as good.  Some were never used, some were never even unpacked at the customer end.  The only shortfall is, you have no way of knowing the exact history.
     
    Consider, you got a new one, tested once, that developed problems as soon as you started using it.  So the distinction between new and refurb is mostly one of perception.
     
    As to which one you'll receive--if they have refurbs of the product you bought, that in all likelihood is what you get.  If not, they can (wholly at their option) assemble you another one from either new or refurb components.  It's mostly a logistical expedient for them, whichever is most readily available.  This is all specified in your 'terms and conditions'.
  • jay nathan

    20 Posts

    639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 16:00

    x_labrat
     
    HMMMMMM.  I was under the impression that I would be receiving a brand new machine as a repacement, not a refurb.  I paid for a brand new machine just one month ago, it took 2 weeks to get here and earlier this week I realize it was faulty. 
     
    Just wondering about the truth behind most replacement systems being refurbished.  Can you tell me where you got this info.  I would feel inclined to cancel the exchange and just start new if this was the case.
     
    Thx for the response.
  • jay nathan

    20 Posts

    639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 17:00

    You make some strong points. 
     
    One does feel a little ripped off when they are given refurbished parts and they have paid for new.  But as you stated, the brand new system I had just failed miserably so sometimes new may not be better.  So if Dell can provide me with a shiney tower and and all the parts come together and purrrr than I will be satisfied.
     
    I did pay a pretty penny and asked for many bells and whistles so I just want to feel excited when I log on. 
  • x_lab rat

    1976 Posts

    639

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2007 17:00

    Refurb has a negative connotation, but less a negative impact.  Trade law requires the term attached to any product 'previously shipped as new'.  Your returned system will have components substituted until it works properly, and then shipped with the refurb sticker to another exchangee or sold on Dell Outlet.
     
    That's where I got mine 8 years ago and it has been trouble free.  Except for the red refurb label, the product you receive will be indistinguishable from new.
     
    You raise the strongest point:    I just want to feel excited when I log on.
     
    A major purchase should give you that feeling, and a major problem with a purchase certainly does dilute the experience.  To restore that feeling for you, if I ran the company you'd get another new one.  But if I ran the company the whole transaction might have cost you and everyone else who bought one--whether they had problems or not--another $150.  That's the 'competitive' in competitively-priced.
  • 639

    0

    Posted April 6th, 2007 20:00

    That's what I thought. I ran into that issue about a year and a half ago with an LCD monitor from Dell. The USB ports on it were defective and originally I wanted them to exchange it. After a long hassle on the phone about the 21 day satisfaction guarantee clock I wound up simply returning it for a refund. Then I started the process all over again.