UNSOLVED

DJBucs2005

updated

21 years ago

D

DJBucs2005

34 Posts

0

18421

June 25th, 2005 23:00

Should I get a new computer if I want to play games and do graphics work?

I have posted messages about upgrading my computer.  I know this baby is not great at playing games.  One game in particular I want to buy and be able to play on my computer is Battlefield 2.  The downside of the game is that there are some steep requirements.

Here are the specs for my Dell Dimension 2400:

Celeron 2.4 GHZ
16X DVD ROM 48X CDRW
512 MB DDR SDRAM (I ordered another 512 MB of RAM)
80 GB
hard drive
Integrated Intel 3D AGP Graphics card (I am thinking about upgrading like I have said numerous times on different boards)
While upgrading my graphics card for my
computer is not soley based on wanting to play Battlefield 2, upgrading a mother board is. I want to upgrade to an nVidia GeForce FX 5700LE PCI. However, I have been told that I would only be able to play on a 800x600 resolution on low settings, and my default resolution for my computer is 1024x768, and if I played on 800x600, BF2 would look like doo doo. Is what I have been told true you think????????

How would I go about upgrading my mother board? I have been told that I could only upgrade my Dell Dimension 2400 mobo to a 4600 mobo, and in that case, I'd have to call Dell Spare parts, and lie, saying I need a new mobo for my Dell Dimension 4600, as if I told them I wanted to put the 4600 mobo in a 2400, they would tell me that "you can't".

I do believe the 4600 mobo has an AGP slot, and I've been reading that it will get phased out soon. However, this is probably one of my best options other than...

Just buying a new dang computer. If I sold this PC and counted my losses, instead of sinking money into a NON-gaming PC, and used the $ towards a new PC. I could probably afford a new PC, but selling this PC would probably be a pain, and I most likely wouldn't make a bunch of $ off of it. That would be the last option...this is SUCH a headache.

What do you think about the Dell Dimension 4700 which includes the 128MB PCI Express™ x16 (DVI/VGA/TV-out) ATI Radeon™ X300 SE?  It seems like EVEN this PCI-express card, in which I thought PCI-e cards were supposed to be good...is not good for playing games..or so I have heard.

Someone please help me...YIKES!!!

 
  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 00:00

    There is a reason why the 5700LE is only $38.

    Its a crippled GPU with 64 bit Memory interface.

    Get a PNY Geforce FX5500 pci card with 128 Bit memory interface.

    The 5500 is 8 times faster than the 5700LE.
  • swins2

    22 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 00:00

    if you upgrade to the nvidia and get a gig of ram youll be able to play the game at a higher setting than 800-640... the next one up i belive and battlefield 2 will still look good no matter what setting. all the extra eye candy is on the higher setting. Get the nvidia its a much easier desicsion.
  • pparks1

    59 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 00:00

    If you are looking to play Battlefield 2, you are going to want to invest some money into a new computer. The 2400 is simply not a gaming box. It cannot be upgraded to PCI-E or AGP video cards. If you want to game today, you have to use either AGP or PCI-E. I am currently playing the game and understand the system requirements pretty well.

    As you noted, even a Dimension 4600 with the Radeon X300 PCI-Express card is going to give low performance. This is the budget card for the Dell computers. If you spend the minimum on the card, you are gonna get minimum gameplay. With that said, you would likely be able to play BF2 at 1024x768 between the Low and medium settings.

    If you plan to do some gaming in the future, I would suggest going with a 2.8 to 3.2ghz CPU, 1GB of system RAM, a Sound Blaster Audigy 2 and at least the GeForce 6800 256MB PCI-express card. That card will allow you to play BF2 at 1024x768 between medium and high.....which looks really good. For a dimension 8400 system with these specs, you are gonna pay around $1000-$1200.

    I have an 8400, 1GB of RAM, a 160GB SATA drive, an SB2 Audigy ZS and an ATI Radeon X800XT 256MB PCI-E card and it runs BF2 beautifully.

    Message Edited by pparks1 on 06-25-2005 08:17 PM

  • DJBucs2005

    34 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 03:00

    Well, thanks for your help.  I am now considering selling the computer I have now, and buying either a 4700 or 8400.  Lol..I swear..this never ends..I keep on thinking about making a buy, but not actually buying it. 
     
    I have other software included with my PC including:
     
    Norton Internet Security 2005
    Photo Album 5.1 STandard
    Win XP Home
    Adobe Acrobat Reader 6.0
     
     
    Hardware:
    17 in flat monitor
    Basic speakers
     
    The input devices are a basic keyboard and a two click optical mouse
     
    Realistically, how much do you think I'd be able to get for my computer?  If there is anything else you need to know about my PC to gauge the value, feel free to ask.
     
    I DO have car insurance (such a rip off..I swear, if I ever get in an accident, they dang well better cover the whole cost) to pay for and I also want to buy some goodies for my computer (Photoshop CS2 and POSSIBLY a digital tablet), but on the bright side, I should be getting in addition to the $ I already have received, another $300-$500 for graduation from relatives and parent's friends.  That would help, but that 8400 is more like something that would be for the whole family, instead of just myself, mainly because of the cost.  Do you know how often they offer big savings on PC's like the 4700 and 8400?  I think one offer expires 6/26 for the 8400.  I have probably about $1300-$1400 in my bank account right now, but as of right now, I have no summer job.  It's real hard to find a job...I wouldn't be mentioning that if it wasn't related. 
     
    Thank you once again for your help.  I'm sure I'll be asking more questions about this.  I' m SO sick of not being able to use my new computer for anything but surfing the net.

    Message Edited by DJBucs2005 on 06-26-2005 12:52 AM

  • CSPlayer089

    563 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 19:00

    you should build your own computer.

    10 billion times cheaper, and more fun since you choose the parts :smileyhappy:

     

    but, its up to you

  • CSPlayer089

    563 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 20:00

    lol thats fine i figured you didnt know how too.
     
    but if you did, keep in mind a P4 IS NOT the kind of processor you want.
     
    you would want an AMD Athlon 64. it is a 64-bit processor instead of a 32-bit P4, so in a sense it is twice the speed.
     
    put it this way: a 2.2 ghz AMD64 can outperform a P4 3.6ghz
     
    amd64's are also WAY cheaper than P4's.

    Message Edited by CSPlayer089 on 06-26-2005 04:48 PM

  • DJBucs2005

    34 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 20:00

    Trust me man, if I could, then I would.  I don't know anything about that though.  I know  what a good amount of RAM is to have, how big of a hard drive, I know that PCI-e is the way to go for video cards, and that P4 is the processor I would want to buy, but I do not know how to build it, and I honestly don't want to spend a month learning about this stuff and then spend another couple of weeks trying to put it together.  The only way I would consider is if there is some kind of updated material online, in one or two spots.  I don't want to have to go on a hunt searching for all this stuff in 10 different sites.
     
    Is there anyone who could give some input on my previous post?
  • Daddyjaxx

    1081 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 21:00

    Athlon 64's are not twice the speed of the P4.

    The 2.2 GHz 64 can only outperform the 3.6 in some things.  The P4 is better in others.

    The Athlon 64's are not necessarily way cheaper than the P4....yes they are somewhat cheaper, but the days of Athlon being the bargain chip is gone.  Have you seen the 1100.00 4800+ X2?

  • CSPlayer089

    563 Posts

    861

    0

    Posted June 26th, 2005 22:00

    there would be no point in buying that for mainstream gaming, would there?

    if you are buying a comp to play games like doom3, hl2, the choice of an amd64 is wise, such as a 3200+, 3500+ etc. anything greater than those is a waste of money and the only thing insane about them is their price tag.

  • DJBucs2005

    34 Posts

    206

    0

    Posted June 27th, 2005 00:00

    Well...I have some good news as far as my fincances are concerned.  It turns out that people were more generous than I thought they would be, and I made $715 from graduation.  With the money I already have in my account (approxomiately $1600) plus the money that I would get from my Dell Dimension 2400 (let's just say $300), that comes out to $2615.  I can afford a computer of this quality, and will not be spending every single penny I have.  My mom ordered this Dell Dimension 2400 from QVC, and unfortunately, the time for me to have returned this item has passed.  That leaves me with (shudders...as I have had a bad experience purchasing from eBay) selling my PC on eBay. 

    I will go ahead and list everything that is listed in my PC specs sheet, and let you figure out what is an asking price I should list.  I'll bold the more important ones

    Dell Dimension 2400 Includes:

    Celeron 2.4 GHZ, MMT, INT VIDSNDNI

    16X DVD ROM and 48X CDRW, DIM, V

    17 in E173FPV, FPIB, DIM, V (Flat screen monitor)

    3.5IN 1.44MB, FD, 212, MG (floppy drive)

    512 MB DDR SDRAM at 333 MHZ, TIED (I ordered an upgrade of 512 MB RAM)

    80GB 7200 RPM Ultra ATA, DIM, V

    Adobe Acrobat Reader 6.0

    Aol DHS

    Boradband Icon for Consumer

    Decoding Software, Power, DVD, DIM

    Dell 2-Button USB Optical Mouse, DIM

    Dell A215 speakers, SIB, DIM

    Dell Quietkey Keyboard, 104, English, Tied

    Dell Support 3.0, DIM 3000, 4600, 4700

    Dell/My Way Home Page

    DMX 3.0 Basic, DIM

    H AND R Block Consumer Promo/Tax S/W

    Image Restore, DIM

    MS WOrksuite 2004, CDWD, OEM, US, ENG, DIM

    Music Match 9.0 Basic, DIM/INSP

    Netzero ISP, DIM/INSP

    Norton Internet Security 2005, 90DAY, DIM

    Photo Album 5.1 Standard, DIM/INSP

    Soft Contracts-Qualxserve

    V.92/56K PCI DataFAX, INT MODEM, DIM, TIED

    WIn XP HOme, SP2, EN, DIM, TIED

    Windows Media Player 10, DIM

    Integrated 10/100 Ethernet

    Integrated Intel 3D AGP Graphics Card

    Integrated ADI 1885 Audio, TIEd

    Service Options:

    NBD, DIM NW, QLX, S90, 2YR EXT, DHS (LOW)

    3 Year limited Warranty

    Tech Support, DIM 2 YR ext

    Tech Support, DIM, INIT YR

    Thanks a lot everyone.  You guys rock on here.   You seem to care more than those dang Indians from Dell tech support whom I have to wait to talk to for an hour, and then can hardly flipping understand!!!

    Some good news...my mom said she would help pay for the new PC, so $ is not really an issue anymore.  As long as I'm getting a good PC for a good value (other than building my own), I will be happy.

    By the way, where can I find a link to where Dell has special offers on computers?  The Dell Dimension 8400 deal just ended today, and while I would like to order that bad boy now, I think it's just a BIT too soon.  I'll probably wait a little bit longer asking for opinions as to what I should get in order to avoide this problem down the road.  Also, do their offers  really include rebates and FREE shipping?

    As for selling on eBay, if I decide to do so...is it better to a.)  Just put a modest starting bid, b.)  Put a modest starting bid AND offer a "Buy Now" option that is a little bit higher, or just c.)  Offer the "Buy Now" option ONLY?